
measure heat released by respiring seeds, calculate energy transfer between trophic levels, and argue from evidence why ecosystems support few top predators while matter is recycled.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. An oak woodland holds millions of grass plants and acorns, thousands of mice and ground squirrels, dozens of hawks and snakes, and perhaps one or two mountain lions. Write one hypothesis for why the numbers shrink so sharply at each step up the food chain.
Soaked, sprouting peas and dry peas sit in two sealed, insulated cups for two days. What happens to the temperature?
Trophic levels and the ten percent rule. Producers capture light energy by photosynthesis. Primary consumers (herbivores) eat producers, secondary consumers eat herbivores, and so on. At each step, most of the energy in the food is not stored in the consumer’s body. Some food is not eaten or not digested, and most of what is absorbed powers cellular respiration for movement, growth, repair and body heat, and leaves the organism as heat. On average only about 10% of the energy at one level becomes biomass at the next level; the real figure varies from roughly 5% to 20%.
Worked example 1: an energy pyramid (illustrative). If the producers in a patch of woodland store 20,000 kJ per square meter per year, herbivores store about 2,000 kJ, secondary consumers about 200 kJ and tertiary consumers about 20 kJ. The top level receives only 20 ÷ 20,000 = 0.1% of the energy the producers captured. A mountain lion needs a lot of energy each year, so it needs a very large area of producers beneath it.
Where does the energy go? A measurement. Germinating seeds are alive and respiring rapidly, breaking down stored starch to fuel growth: C6H12O6 + 6O2 → 6CO2 + 6H2O + energy. Part of that energy is captured as ATP, and all of it eventually ends up as heat.
Lab procedure (heat from germinating seeds).
| Time (h) | Germinating seeds (°C) | Dry seeds (°C) | Room (°C) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | |||
| 4 | |||
| 24 | |||
| 28 | |||
| 48 |
In one illustrative run, the germinating peas warmed from 22.0 °C to 27.8 °C, a rise of 5.8 °C, while the dry peas rose by only 0.4 °C. That heat is energy leaving the food chain. No seeds? Use these illustrative numbers.
Matter cycles, energy does not. Energy enters an ecosystem as light and leaves as heat, a one-way flow. Matter is different: the carbon, nitrogen and phosphorus atoms in a dead oak or a mountain lion are returned to the soil and air by decomposers, bacteria and fungi, and are used again by producers. Decomposition can be aerobic, releasing CO2, or anaerobic, in waterlogged soils, where it is slower and can release methane.
Worked example 2: a drained peatland. Many river deltas and fens were once wetlands with deep peat soils, built up because waterlogged, low-oxygen conditions slowed decay. When such land is drained for farming, oxygen reaches the peat, microbes decompose it aerobically, and the land surface sinks as its carbon goes into the air as CO2. Some drained peat islands now lie below sea level, behind levees. The atoms did not vanish; they moved from soil to atmosphere.
Building the argument. Claim: ecosystems support few top predators because energy is lost as heat at every trophic level. Evidence: your seed data, the pyramid calculation, and counts of organisms at each level. A strong argument also rebuts a counter-claim, such as there are few predators because people hunt them. Hunting may matter, but it cannot explain why the pattern holds in ecosystems where predators are protected.
Reading: OpenStax Biology 2e, Chapter 45 (Population and Community Ecology) and Chapter 46 (Ecosystems), CC BY 4.0.
Work in lab pairs. Show every calculation.
Write your argument.
Compare the temperature rise in the two cups and explain the difference with cellular respiration. Then use your seed data and a pyramid calculation as evidence for the claim that ecosystems support few top predators.
Write the rebuttal paragraph: state a counter-claim about why top predators are rare, and use evidence to explain why energy flow is still the better explanation. Name two sources of error in the seed lab and their likely effect.
Energy flows; matter cycles. Next: how do ecologists count populations and measure biodiversity?
Exit ticket: why does a herd of grazing elk need a much larger area of grass than a pack of predators would need of elk? Use the ten percent rule.
How confident are you that you can use data and the ten percent rule to argue why ecosystems support few top predators?
Timing: this lab spans two 50-minute periods with a 48-hour temperature record between them. Soak half the seeds 24 hours before day one.
Materials: dried peas or mung beans (about 1 cup per group), two insulated foam cups with lids or small vacuum flasks, two alcohol thermometers or probes, cotton wool, paper towels, goggles.
Listen for: “energy is destroyed” (it is converted to heat); “matter is lost up the food chain” (it cycles); confusing biomass with numbers of organisms.
Support / stretch: provide a pyramid template with one level filled. Stretch: if transfer efficiency were 15% instead of 10%, how much energy would reach the tertiary level? (67.5 kJ from 20,000.)