
write and defend a design brief that explains each candidate heater’s energy change from bonds broken and formed, uses calorimetry and thermal-equilibrium data as evidence, predicts the meal pouch’s performance with a computational energy model, and recommends a reaction for each kit item with its trade-offs.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. List the three strongest pieces of evidence you collected this unit (a calorimetry ΔH, a mixing result, a model run, a prototype curve). Next to each, write the claim it supports.
Which pairing best matches reaction to kit item, based on this unit's evidence?
The context. The relief nonprofit’s supply director will decide what goes into thousands of shelter kits from your brief. She is not a chemist, but her board includes one. Your brief has to be clear to her and correct to him.
Part A: Where the energy comes from (HS-PS1-4). For the meal heater and the hand warmer you recommend, draw an energy diagram: system and surroundings, reactant and product levels, ΔH, activation energy, and the bonds (or attractions) broken and formed. Give ΔH from Hess’s law or enthalpies of formation, and explain how the change in the system is balanced by an equal and opposite change in the surroundings, carried by molecular collisions.
Part B: Lab evidence (HS-PS3-4). Report your calorimetry ΔH for CaCl2 and its percent difference from the published value; your hot-and-cold mixing result showing energy lost by the hot component against energy gained by the cold one; and your hand-warmer prototype curves. Explain thermal equilibrium with the second law. Evaluate accuracy and precision, name where energy appeared to be lost, and describe the revisions you made and why.
Part C: The meal pouch model (HS-PS3-1). Present your spreadsheet: components, boundary, zero references, the algebra for each energy and flow, and a graph of meal temperature against time. Report the largest possible temperature change for your recipe, the predicted peak with losses, and the recipe and sleeve that meet 60 °C within 15 minutes. List the model’s assumptions and how each could make the prediction wrong.
Part D: The recommendation (HS-ETS1-3). Use a criteria table to score every candidate on temperature reached, time, energy per gram, safety (burn limit, gases released indoors) and reusability or cost. Recommend one reaction for the meal pouch and one for the hand warmer, and state the trade-off plainly. Any cost figure is labeled illustrative unless you cite it. A strong brief tells the shelter what to print on the package: for a magnesium heater, “use only in a ventilated space”; for any warmer, “do not hold against bare skin while sleeping.”
Worked example: a strong recommendation sentence. “We recommend the magnesium-iron pad for the meal pouch because it releases 14.5 kJ per gram within minutes, so 5 g heats a 250 g meal to 60 °C in our model; the trade-off is hydrogen gas, so pouches must be activated by a door or window, not beside sleeping cots.” Claim, number, evidence and trade-off in two sentences.
Quality bar. Every energy claim names the system and the direction of flow. Every ΔH has a sign and units. Every calculation shows q = mcΔT or Hess’s law with numbers. Sample data stays labeled as sample. Published values are cited (OpenStax Chemistry 2e, NIST).
Stages. Plan, draft, peer review, revise, and defend in four minutes (live or recorded), answering one question from a “board member.”
Plan and peer-review checks.
Write and revise the brief across the work sessions.
Write Parts A and B with your energy diagrams, calorimetry and mixing data, and your evaluation and revisions (about 450 words).
Write Parts C and D: the model with its graph and assumptions, the criteria table, and the recommendation with trade-offs and package warnings, with sources cited.
Task: For the relief nonprofit’s supply director, Part A explains each recommended heater’s energy change with an energy diagram, bonds broken and formed, and ΔH from Hess’s law or enthalpies of formation. Part B presents your calorimetry, mixing and prototype data, the second-law explanation of thermal equilibrium, and your evaluation and revisions. Part C presents the spreadsheet energy model of the meal pouch with its maximum possible change, predicted curve and assumptions. Part D recommends a reaction for each kit item with a criteria table, trade-offs and package warnings. Cite at least three sources.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Energy of reactions (HS-PS1-4) | Energy diagrams with system, surroundings, ΔH and activation energy; correct account of bonds broken and formed and of energy conserved between system and surroundings. |
| Computational model (HS-PS3-1) | Components, boundary, zero references and algebra stated; model predicts the meal temperature and the maximum possible change; assumptions and limits named. |
| Investigation and evaluation (HS-PS3-4) | Mixing and calorimetry data show energy lost and gained; second-law explanation; accuracy, precision, apparent losses and revisions evaluated. |
| Recommendation and trade-offs (HS-ETS1-3) | Criteria table, a reaction chosen for each item with evidence, trade-offs and safety warnings stated plainly. |
| Sources and communication | Published values cited, sample data labeled, clear writing for a non-chemist, and a defense that answers a question with evidence. |
Your brief turns a unit of evidence into a decision. Next: the unit checkpoint.
Exit ticket: what question did the board ask your team, and how did you answer it with evidence?
Timing: the brief runs across about three sessions: this lesson launches it and covers planning and peer review; drafting and the presentations need further work time.
Materials: peer-review checklist, the teams’ calorimetry, mixing and prototype data, the spreadsheet models, the OpenStax Appendix G table, rubric copies for visiting “board members.”
Listen for: “bonds breaking release energy”; energy that “disappears”; real prices with no source; a recommendation with no trade-off.
Support / stretch: give a paragraph frame for each part. Stretch: model the reusable sodium acetate warmer with the same spreadsheet approach, holding the temperature at 54 °C until the crystallization energy runs out.