
compare candidate metal ions for each color with a weighted decision matrix, predict the ions, salts and bond types the chosen metals form, rank their reactivity from periodic trends, and draft version 1 of the color brief.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. The committee’s letter asks for a red, a green, a blue and a yellow. From the flame tests and your notes, write the metal you would choose for each and one thing that worries you about it.
A firework star meant to burn red also contains a trace of sodium. What will the audience see?
The design brief. The committee needs to know which metal ions give which colors, why, and how to handle the salts safely. Several metals can give a similar color, so the brief must say which one is best and why. Teams now turn five lessons of evidence into version 1 of the brief.
Candidate emitters (published colors). Red: strontium compounds (deep red, light mostly between about 600 and 690 nm from SrCl and SrOH molecules in the flame), lithium compounds (crimson, strong line at 670.8 nm), calcium compounds (orange-red). Green: barium compounds (light near 505–535 nm, mostly from BaCl). Blue: copper compounds with a chlorine source, which form CuCl in the flame and emit near 420–460 nm. Yellow: sodium compounds (589 nm). Purple is a mix of strontium red and copper blue. White and silver come from burning magnesium, aluminum or titanium metal, which glow white-hot and give a continuous spectrum.
Class criteria for the color brief (set by the class with the committee’s letter). The brief must (1) give, for every color, the metal ion, a representative wavelength, its frequency and photon energy with units and correct significant figures; (2) explain every color with energy levels (excited electron, drop, photon); (3) give each chosen metal’s configuration and usual ion, and explain its ionization energy, radius and reactivity compared with at least one neighbor using Coulomb attraction and shielding; (4) include safety and environmental notes for every salt; and (5) fit on two pages that a committee member with no chemistry background can follow.
Worked example 1: a weighted decision matrix for red (sample scores). Weights: color match ×3, brightness ×2, toxicity and environment ×2, cost ×1. Scores 1–3.
| Criterion (weight) | Strontium | Lithium | Calcium |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color match (×3) | 3 → 9 | 2 → 6 | 1 → 3 |
| Brightness (×2) | 3 → 6 | 2 → 4 | 2 → 4 |
| Toxicity and environment (×2) | 2 → 4 | 2 → 4 | 3 → 6 |
| Cost (×1) | 2 → 2 | 1 → 1 | 3 → 3 |
| Total | 21 | 15 | 16 |
Strontium wins on color and brightness, which is why it is the standard red. Calcium is the safest but too orange. The matrix shows the trade-off instead of hiding it. Green is the hard case: barium gives the best green, but soluble barium salts are toxic, so researchers have developed barium-free greens based on boron compounds; the brief should name that trade-off honestly.
Predicting ions, salts and bonds. From 1.06: Sr2+ and Ba2+ (group 2), Na+ (group 1), Cu+ or Cu2+. With chloride: SrCl2, BaCl2, NaCl, CuCl and CuCl2. With nitrate (NO3−), common in fireworks because nitrates supply oxygen: Sr(NO3)2 and Ba(NO3)2. Electronegativity differences predict the bond type: a difference above about 1.7–2.0 is usually treated as ionic.
Worked example 2: bonds and reactivity. Camila compared the chlorides. SrCl2: 3.16 − 0.95 = 2.21, ionic. NaCl: 3.16 − 0.93 = 2.23, ionic. CuCl: 3.16 − 1.90 = 1.26, polar covalent with partial ionic character, because copper holds its electrons much more tightly (IE 745.5 kJ/mol). Then she ranked the group 2 metals’ reactivity with water: calcium < strontium < barium, because first IE falls (589.8, 549.5, 502.9 kJ/mol) as the valence electrons sit farther from the nucleus behind more shielding. She added a key point for the committee: the metals themselves are reactive, but in salts they are already ions with noble-gas configurations, which is why the salts are stable enough to store.
Safety and environmental notes to research. Soluble barium salts are toxic if swallowed. Copper salts are harmful if swallowed and toxic to aquatic life. Strontium salts have low toxicity. Nitrates and chlorates are oxidizers and must be kept away from fuels and heat. Every salt needs a sealed, labeled container, goggles and gloves, no food nearby, and disposal through hazardous-waste channels, never the drain or the lake. Check each claim against a safety data sheet. Reading. OpenStax Chemistry 2e, section 7.2 (electronegativity and bond type), CC BY 4.0.
Answer before your team chooses its emitters.
Build your team’s decision matrix and draft version 1 of the brief.
Score barium, copper (green from copper atoms) and a boron-based green on your team's weighted criteria. Write a claim about which to recommend, citing two rows of the matrix and one safety fact.
Draft the periodic-trends section: compare first IE, radius and electronegativity for your chosen metals, explain each comparison with Coulomb attraction and shielding, and predict the salt and bond type each forms with chloride.
Version 1 is drafted. Next class: peer critique, and version 2.
Exit ticket: write the one sentence in your draft that a committee member is most likely to misunderstand, and rewrite it in plainer words without losing the science.
Materials: printed safety data sheets for SrCl2, Sr(NO3)2, BaCl2, CuCl2 and NaCl from a school chemical supplier, the 1.04 data table, decision-matrix templates, the criteria poster.
Notes: matrix scores are sample values for teaching; students set their own weights. Keep the brief advisory: the committee’s licensed display company chooses and handles all fireworks compositions. Do not provide or discuss firework formulations.
Listen for: “barium is green because it is in group 2” (the color comes from its energy gaps, not its group); “salts are dangerous because the metal explodes in water.”
Support / stretch: give a paragraph frame for one color (ion → excited electron → drop → photon → wavelength). Stretch: predict the formula and bond type of strontium oxide and copper(II) oxide (SrO, 3.44 − 0.95 = 2.49, ionic; CuO, 1.54, polar covalent with ionic character).