revise our stopper plan for many years of small rains and explain why slow changes matter as much as fast ones.
Phase 5: Prove It
Time machine. Imagine our hill a very long time from now. Rain has fallen on it many, many times. What does it look like?
With no stopper at all, what happens to the hill after many, many years of small rains?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers, real solutions must last. A big storm is a fast change. But many small rains, year after year, are a slow change. Our criteria say our stopper must work for both.
Little adds up. In our gentle rain test, the bare hill lost 6 spoonfuls. That seems small. But a real hill gets rain many times a year. Over years, that is a lot of sand. A river cut a whole canyon this way.
Worked example 1: Hana does the math. Hana says, “If our bare hill loses 6 spoonfuls each gentle rain, then after 10 rains it loses 60 spoonfuls. Our improved stopper loses 1 each time. After 10 rains, that is only 10.” Hana shows why slow changes matter.
Worked example 2: Caleb revises for the long run. Caleb says, “Felt can wear out. On a real hill, we should use plants. Plants keep growing, and their roots hold more soil each year.” He revises his plan to add real grass at the top and rocks at the bottom.
Choose your path. Revise: fix one thing from your share-day wish. Or extend: plan how your stopper would work after many, many years of rain.
Think about time with your partner.
Revise or extend.
Draw your hill now and a very long time from now with your stopper on it. Write how your stopper helps with slow changes.
Which is better for the real playground hill over many years: your stopper or no stopper? Explain using a number from your tests.
You are Land Detectives and engineers! You know that water and wind change land fast and slow, and that people can slow those changes.
Exit ticket: what is the most important thing you learned in this unit?
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 8, mini lecture 7, guided checks 8, revise or extend 12, exit 2 minutes.
Flex use: students who got a share-day wish revise their model or plan; others do the long-run extension. Hana’s numbers come from the sample data.
Misconceptions: “slow changes do not matter”; “the canyon took a few years.” The NPS page gives ages in numbers; do not share or assess them (2-ESS1-1 excludes quantitative time scales). Keep time as “much longer than anyone has lived.”
Supports: counters for repeated adding (2 + 2 + 2 + 2 + 2 = 10). Stretch: compare 10 rains for the Pebble Wall and the Felt Blanket.
Answer guide: “we only see a canyon form after a very long time” shows 2-ESS1-1:3a, and using the river and canyon as evidence shows 1b. Planning for many small rains and big storms shows 2-ESS2-1:2a; comparing stopper and no stopper with a number shows 3b.
National Park Service, Grand Canyon National Park, Geology · U.S. government work, public domain
In a national park, there is a giant canyon. A canyon is a deep valley with steep sides. A river carved it.
The river cuts down into the rock little by little. When it floods, the water carries big rocks called boulders. The boulders scrape the bottom of the river like tools. Smaller side streams make the canyon wider.
This is a very slow change. The river has been cutting the canyon for a very, very long time. That is much, much longer than anyone has lived.
The rocks in the canyon walls are even older than the canyon. The rock layers formed first. Then the river cut down through them.
The river also drops down a long way as it flows through the canyon. Its steep path and big floods help it wear away rock.
Water made this huge change slowly. Water can also make small changes fast, like washing away a sandcastle.
Source: National Park Service, Grand Canyon National Park, Geology (nps.gov)