use information from three different sources to sort Earth events as fast or slow and compare how long they take.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Evidence wall. Look at our class wall. We have photos of our sand hills, our chalk jars and our wind box. We also have three readings.
Can one beach have both fast and slow changes?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Good scientists use more than one source. One source might miss something. When three sources agree, we can trust our idea more.
Our three sources. Source 1 is our sand hill test. Source 2 is the storm and beach reading from lesson 2.01. Source 3 is today’s beach-in-winter reading.
Comparing time. We can compare without numbers. Faster or slower? Did it happen while we watched, or only after a long, long time?
Worked example 1: Priya fills the chart. Priya made a chart with three rows. Sand hill pour: fast. Storm on a beach: fast. Beach building back up: slow. She wrote the source for each row.
Worked example 2: Marcus compares. Marcus wrote, “A storm takes sand away faster than calm waves bring it back.” He used two sources to compare.
Big idea. The same thing, like water, can make fast changes and slow changes. That is the answer to part of our big puzzle!
Use the evidence wall and the chart. Work with a partner.
Fill in your Fast or Slow chart.
Make a chart with columns Event, Fast or Slow, and Source. Add at least three events from three different sources.
Three sources agree: water makes fast and slow changes. Next time, we learn how to pick good science sources.
Exit ticket: name one fast event and one slow event and the source for each.
Pacing (40 min): evidence wall 4, reading 8, mini lecture 7, guided practice 11, chart 8, exit 2.
Materials: photos from 2.04-2.06, copies of the 2.01 and 2.03 readings, chart paper with three columns.
Boundary: compare durations qualitatively only (faster, slower, watched it, after a long time). The page names a storm year and sand height; we retell only “taller than a grown-up.”
Supports: pre-fill one chart row. Stretch: add glacier valley (2.08 source).
Answer guide: fast: pour, storm, earthquake, landslide; slow: canyon, rock weathering, beach rebuilding, glacier valley. Sources: our test, NPS beach storms, NPS beach in winter, USGS earthquakes, NPS weathering.
National Park Service, Acadia National Park: Sand Beach in Winter · U.S. government work, public domain
One beach in a national park sits in a small bay called a cove. Its sand is always on the move.
In winter, the waves sweep the beach. They pull the fine, soft sand out into the deeper water of the cove. The bigger, rougher grains stay behind on the beach.
In summer, the winds and waves change. The waves push sand back onto the beach. Soft, pinkish-gold sand covers the rocks again.
The biggest changes come from big storms, like hurricanes. During one big storm, the waves took away a layer of sand taller than a grown-up! But most of the sand stayed in the cove. Over time, the beach built back up.
Why is the beach still there? The shape of the land around it traps the sand. That keeps the sand from washing away for good.
So this one beach has fast changes and slow changes. A storm is fast. The beach building back up is slow.
Source: National Park Service, Acadia National Park: Sand Beach in Winter (nps.gov)