use our questions, observations and information to describe the hillside problem and what a good wash-away stopper should be like.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Look back. Read our Wonder Board and our Fast or Slow chart. Which ideas help us understand the hillside?
Which clue might help us stop the hillside from washing away?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers describe the problem first. Before we build, we write a clear problem. Who has the problem? What is happening? What do they want?
Our problem. Rain and wind wash soil off the bare hillside next to the playground. Mud covers the path, and the hill gets smaller. The playground team wants the soil to stay on the hill.
What should our stopper be like? It should slow down water and wind. It should work in big storms and in many small rains. It must be safe for children. It should use materials we can get.
Worked example 1: Mia’s problem statement. Mia wrote, “The playground team needs a way to keep soil on the hillside, because rain and wind wash it onto the path.” It tells who, what and why.
Worked example 2: Diego’s stopper list. Diego wrote, “It should slow water. It should hold soil, like roots do. It must be safe to play near.” He used science from our readings.
Next up. In Part 2, we will draw, build and test our Hillside Wash-Away Stoppers.
Build our problem statement and stopper list together.
Write your own problem statement and stopper list.
Write a problem statement for the hillside. Then list three things your stopper should do or be.
Our problem is clear. Our list is ready. In Part 2, we design and test our stoppers!
Exit ticket: draw a quick idea for a stopper. Label one part and tell what it does.
Pacing (40 min): look back 4, reading 7, mini lecture 7, guided practice 10, problem statement 9, exit sketch 3.
Materials: Wonder Board, Fast or Slow chart, hillside map from 2.10, chart paper for the class stopper list.
Note: do not choose a solution today. Ideas like plants, walls or mats are fine as sketches; part 2 tests them (2-ESS2-1, K-2-ETS1-2, K-2-ETS1-3). The reading reuses the 2.06 source with a new purpose.
Supports: frame: “The playground team needs ___ because ___.” Stretch: ask how the stopper should work for both fast and slow change.
Answer guide: statements name the team, keeping soil on the hill, and rain or wind. Lists include slows water or wind, holds soil, safe, uses classroom materials, works in big and small rains.
National Park Service, Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore: Sand Dune Geology · U.S. government work, public domain
Let’s reread our dune reading like engineers. We are looking for clues.
Clue 1: wind slows down behind things. A rock or a clump of grass can slow the wind. When the wind slows, it drops its sand.
Clue 2: plants hold sand. Beach grass, sand cherry and cottonwood trees are some of the first plants to grow on the dunes. Their roots hold the sand in place. As old plant parts break down, they make the soil richer. Then more plants can grow, and later even forests.
Clue 3: bare sand can be scooped out. When strong wind strips away the plants, it can blow a bowl-shaped hole into the dune.
Clue 4: moving sand can be powerful. Moving dunes can slowly cover trees and poles. Blowing sand can even polish rocks smooth.
What do these clues mean for our hillside? Bare ground loses soil. Things that slow down wind and water, like plants, may help hold the soil.
Source: National Park Service, Sleeping Bear Dunes National Lakeshore: Sand Dune Geology (home.nps.gov)