use evidence from a sand hill model to explain how gentle rain makes slow changes and heavy water makes fast changes.
Phase 2: Investigate
Think back. Remember the mud on the playground path? Today we build a small sand hill and test what water does to it.
Which will move more sand right away?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Erosion. Weathering breaks rock. Erosion carries the pieces away. Water is a strong mover of sand and soil.
Our test. Each team builds two sand hills the same size. On Hill A, we sprinkle a little water with a watering can, a few drops at a time. On Hill B, we pour the same cup of water all at once.
A fair test. The hills are the same. The amount of water is the same. Only one thing changes: how the water comes. That keeps our test fair.
Worked example 1: Hana’s evidence. Hana poured on Hill B. A ditch opened right away and sand slid onto the tray. She wrote, “The big pour made a fast change. I saw it happen.”
Worked example 2: Leo’s evidence. Leo sprinkled on Hill A. At first, almost nothing happened. After many sprinkles, tiny grooves showed. He wrote, “Gentle rain moves sand slowly. I saw the change only after a long time.”
Back to our hillside. A big storm is like the pour. Many small rains are like the sprinkles. Both wash the hillside away. Our stopper will need to work for both.
Run both hills, then answer with your team.
Write your evidence.
Draw Hill A and Hill B after the water. Finish: The pour made a ___ change because ___. The sprinkle made a ___ change because ___.
Water moves sand fast or slowly. Next time, we test the wind.
Exit ticket: what evidence shows the pour made a fast change?
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 3, reading 7, mini lecture 6, test and guided practice 16, evidence page 6, exit 2.
Materials (per team): 2 trays (or one long tray), damp sand, two cups of water measured the same, a small watering can or a cup with holes poked in the bottom, towels.
Tip: sprinkle hill gets many small doses over 5 minutes; pour hill gets the same total at once. Photograph both hills for the 2.11 evidence wall.
Misconceptions: “Slow water does nothing.” Point to the tiny grooves.
Answer guide: evidence for fast: a ditch opened right away, sand slid off while we watched. Slow: tiny grooves only after many sprinkles.
National Park Service, Erosion: Water, Wind and Weather · U.S. government work, public domain
Last time we learned that rocks break into little pieces. What happens to the pieces next? Often, something carries them away. Scientists call this erosion.
Erosion happens when loose bits of rock are carried away by something that moves. Moving water can do it. Wind can do it. Big, slow rivers of ice called glaciers can do it, too.
Rivers and streams carry sand, gravel and fine mud. They drop it in low places in a valley. When a fast mountain stream slows down, it drops its sand and rock. The pile can spread out in a fan shape.
At the shore, waves and moving ocean water carry sand along the coast.
In dry places with few plants, a heavy rain can make a flash flood. That is a flood that comes quickly. The rushing water carries away a lot of loose ground.
In our model, watch where the water carries the sand and where it drops it.
Source: National Park Service, Erosion: Water, Wind and Weather (nps.gov)