tell which sources give good science information about where water is found, instead of just opinions.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Fact or opinion? Your teacher reads two sentences. “Lakes are the prettiest kind of water.” “Most of Earth’s water is in the ocean.”
Which sentence is a science fact?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Facts and opinions. A fact can be checked. An opinion tells how someone feels. “Ice is cold” is a fact. “Ice is fun” is an opinion.
Good science sources. Good sources come from scientists. They use measurements and observations. They tell how they know. Examples: science books, science agencies like NOAA and the USGS, and our own careful tests.
Not-so-good sources. A post that says “I think” with no evidence. An ad trying to sell something. A story that is made up.
Worked example 1: Sofia checks two sources. Sofia read the USGS page and the NOAA page. Both said most water is in the ocean. She wrote, “Two science sources agree, so I trust this fact.”
Worked example 2: Andre spots an opinion. Andre saw a poster: “Rivers are the best!” He said, “That is an opinion. It does not tell where water is or how they know.”
Ask three questions. Who wrote it? Do they use evidence? Do other good sources agree?
Sort the source cards with your team.
Be a source checker.
Your teacher gives you four source cards. Circle the good science sources. Write why for one of them.
Good science sources use evidence. Next time, we explain how we know some changes are slow.
Exit ticket: name one question you can ask to check if a source is good.
Pacing (40 min): fact or opinion 4, reading 8, mini lecture 7, card sort and guided practice 12, source checker 7, exit 2.
Materials: source cards (made-up, labelled sample): a science agency water page, a science book page, an ad for bottled water, a post saying “I think most water is in lakes.”
Note: the NOAA page and the USGS page give slightly different percentages because they count differently; grade 2 compares only the shared big idea. Do not use numbers.
Misconceptions: “If it is on the internet, it is true.”
Answer guide: good sources: agency page and science book; questions: Who wrote it? Do they use evidence? Do other good sources agree?
NOAA National Ocean Service, How much water is in the ocean? · U.S. government work, public domain
NOAA is a group of ocean and weather scientists who work for our country. They answer the question, “How much water is in the ocean?”
Their answer: almost all of Earth’s water is in the ocean. Most of Earth’s water is salt water.
A small part of Earth’s water is frozen. It is locked up in glaciers and ice caps. An even smaller part is fresh water that is not frozen.
A tiny bit of water floats in the air as water vapor, a gas we cannot see.
The ocean is huge. It covers more than two out of every three parts of Earth’s surface.
How do these scientists know? They use measurements. They also use numbers from other scientists, like the U.S. Geological Survey. That is the same group that wrote our lesson 2.07 reading.
Both science groups say the same thing: most water is in the ocean, and some is frozen as ice. When good sources agree, we can trust the facts more.
Source: NOAA National Ocean Service, How much water is in the ocean? (oceanservice.noaa.gov)