show what I know about materials, changes and our shelter tests.
Phase 5: Prove It
Warm up your brain. Tell a partner your shelter’s roof material and one property that made you choose it.
Different materials have different properties.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Builders, this is a checkpoint. It is not a scary test. It shows what you know. Read each question twice. Then answer.
Remember materials. Each material has properties, like hard, soft, bendy, stiff or absorbent. We sort materials by their properties. A property can make a material good for a job.
Remember changes. Some changes from heating or cooling can be reversed, like melting ice. Some cannot, like cooking an egg. Small pieces can be taken apart and built into something new.
Remember our test. Build two versions. Test each one 3 times. Write the data in a chart. Look for a pattern. Tell what is good and not so good.
Worked example 1: Elena’s answer. “We used foil for the roof because foil is not absorbent. Water runs off it. Our towel stayed dry 3 times.” She named a material, a property and her data.
Worked example 2: Theo’s answer. “Shelter A held 2 blocks. Shelter B held 6. B has stiff sticks under the roof. B is best.” He compared data and named the feature that made the difference.
Part A: answer on your own.
Part B: draw and write short answers.
Draw your shelter. Label the roof, walls and floor. Write how the shape of one part helps it do its job.
Use your chart. Write which version is best for our job. Give one good and one not so good thing about the other version.
Write a claim: can melted chocolate be changed back? Give your evidence.
Checkpoint done! Next time, our guests come to the Shelter Show.
Exit ticket: which idea do you know best? Which one do you want to practice?
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 6 min, mini lecture 5 min, Part A 10 min, Part B 14 min (conference while others write), exit 2 min.
Coverage: with the project rubric and the 1.26 Shelter Show, this checkpoint covers every unit id. Part A maps to 2-PS1-1 and 2-PS1-2 (properties, uses), 2-PS1-3 (reusing pieces), 2-PS1-4 (reversible change), K-2-ETS1-1 (the problem), K-2-ETS1-3 (comparing data) and revision. Part B covers labeled models and shape (K-2-ETS1-2), best design (K-2-ETS1-3:3a) and claim with evidence (2-PS1-4).
Misconceptions: “the version I like is best” (ask for data); “foil is absorbent because it gets wet.”
Supports: read items aloud on request; accept labeled drawings and short dictated answers in Part B.
Answer key, Part A: felt; lasts a long time and does not burn; pieces can be used again; water freezing into ice; Shelter B; to keep a toy hiker dry and safe; one thing at a time.
Answer guide, Part B: “Yes. When melted chocolate cools, it gets hard again.”
National Park Service, Preservation Brief 4: Roofing for Historic Buildings · U.S. government work, public domain
Builders have made roofs from many materials. Each one has its own properties. Let’s look at four.
Clay tile. Clay tiles were used on roofs long ago. Some tiles had a little bump on the back. The bump hooked the tile onto a strip of wood, so no nail was needed. In strong wind, builders sometimes put mortar between rows to hold the tiles.
Slate. Slate is a kind of stone. People liked it because it lasts a long time and does not burn. Slate comes in colors like red, green, purple and blue-gray. Some people made patterns with the colors.
Wood shingles. Rain and sun slowly wear down wood shingles. If wood stays wet too long, moss can grow and the wood can rot.
Metal. Sheets of metal became popular for roofs because they were lighter and easier to put on.
Every material has good and not so good parts. Builders choose the one that fits the job.
Source: National Park Service, Preservation Brief 4: Roofing for Historic Buildings (nps.gov)