use evidence to explain how we know a canyon formed slowly and a sandcastle washed away fast.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Back to the puzzle. Look again at our canyon photo from lesson 2.01. Now we know much more about water, wind and rock.
What carved the canyon?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Two ways to know. We know a change is fast when people can see it happen. We know a change is slow when we only see the change after a long, long time, by looking at clues.
Canyon clues. Rock layers stacked up. A river at the bottom. Cracks broken open by ice. The canyon is still changing, a tiny bit at a time.
Sandcastle clues. We watched it. It fell in seconds. We saw the start and the end.
Worked example 1: Isla explains the canyon. Isla wrote, “I know the canyon formed slowly because no one saw it happen. Scientists use clues like rock layers and the river.” That is a claim with evidence.
Worked example 2: Ravi explains the sandcastle. Ravi wrote, “I know the sandcastle washed away fast because we watched it fall in our demo.” He used what he observed.
Our explanation frame. Claim: what changed and how fast. Evidence: what we saw or read. Reasoning: why that shows fast or slow.
Build explanations with your team.
Write your explanation of the big puzzle.
Write two or three sentences. How can water make both a fast change and a slow change? Use one piece of evidence from a test and one from a reading.
We solved part of our puzzle! Next time, we use everything we learned to describe the hillside problem clearly.
Exit ticket: is our hillside washing away fast, slowly or both? Tell how you know.
Pacing (40 min): warm-up 3, reading 8, mini lecture 7, guided practice 10, written explanation 10, exit 2.
Materials: canyon photo from 2.01, a stack of colored paper layers as a rock-layer model, Claim-Evidence-Reasoning frame.
Boundary: the NPS page gives ages in millions of years. Do not share or assess them (2-ESS1-1 excludes quantitative time scales). Explain “pushed up high” simply as the land rising; keep the park unnamed in student talk.
Misconceptions: “A huge flood made the canyon at once.” Floods help, but the canyon took a very long time.
Answer guide: fast: sandcastle, storm, pour test (we saw it); slow: canyon, weathered chalk model, beach rebuilding (only seen after a long time). Hillside exit: both, fast in big storms and slowly in many small rains.
National Park Service, Grand Canyon National Park: Geology · U.S. government work, public domain
One national park has a very deep canyon. Park scientists tell its story in steps.
First, layers of rock formed, one on top of another, like a stack of pancakes. Then the land was pushed up high.
Next, a river began to cut down into the rock. The river is strong and steep. In floods, it carries rocks that scrape the bottom. Bit by bit, it cut deeper.
Smaller streams helped, too. Rain and melting snow fill these streams. They made the canyon wider. Rain also wears away bare rock.
In winter, water freezes in cracks in the rock. The ice pushes the cracks open. That breaks the rock, too. There were never glaciers here.
The canyon is still changing today. It is still getting deeper and wider. It is getting wider faster than it is getting deeper.
No one watched the whole canyon form. Scientists use clues, like the rock layers, to tell its story. It was a slow change.
Source: National Park Service, Grand Canyon National Park: Geology (nps.gov)