describe the hillside problem and tell what our wash-away stopper must do and what limits it has.
Phase 4: Build
Welcome back, Land Detectives! Picture a hill next to a playground. After a rainy week, there is mud and sand on the slide path. Where did it come from?
Rain falls on a bare sandy hill. Where will the sand go?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Land Detectives, welcome to Build! You learned that Earth can change fast and slow. Now you will be engineers. An engineer designs a way to solve a problem.
Our problem. Water and wind are washing sand and soil off a hillside. The sand ends up near the playground. When land wears away and moves, we call it erosion. We want to slow it down.
Our design criteria. Criteria are the things our stopper must do to be good. The playground team needs a way to keep soil on the hillside. One: it slows down water and wind, so less sand reaches the playground line than with no stopper. Two: it works in big storms and in many small rains. Three: it stays in place on the hill. Four: it is safe for children to play near.
Our constraints. Constraints are our limits. We use materials we can get: only items from our class materials bin. That means pebbles, craft sticks, felt, cotton balls, paper towels, modeling clay and small cups. Everything must fit on our tray. We build in one class time.
Worked example 1: Lena asks good questions. Lena looks at the muddy path. She asks, “Does the sand move more in a big storm or a small rain?” She asks, “Does wind move dry sand too?” Good questions help us understand the problem.
Worked example 2: Marcus tells the problem. Marcus says, “Rain and wind move sand down the hill to the playground. We need a stopper that keeps the sand on the hill. It has to work in small rains and big storms. We can only use things in our bin.” Marcus used criteria and constraints.
Our model. Each team gets a sand hill on a tray. A tape line at the bottom is the playground. We count spoonfuls of sand that pass the line.
| Criteria check | How we check | Yes! | Not yet |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Slows water and wind: less sand reaches the playground line | count spoonfuls past the tape in the fan and rain tests | ||
| 2. Works in big storms and many small rains | test both kinds of rain | ||
| 3. Stays in place | look after each test | ||
| 4. Safe for children | no sharp or loose small parts | ||
| Limits: bin items, fits on tray, one class time | check our list |
Let’s plan together. Read each question with your partner.
Show you understand the problem.
Draw the hill, the playground and the rain. Draw arrows to show where the sand goes. Write one sentence: what do people want to change?
Finish this sentence: Our stopper should be ____ so that ____. Use one thing you know about sand, water or our materials.
Great planning, engineers! Next time we find out how real people stop water from washing land away.
Exit ticket: write one of our four criteria in your own words.
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 8, mini lecture 9, guided checks 9, drawing and writing 8, exit 2 minutes.
Setup: post the criteria and constraints on chart paper. Keep it up all part. Show one sample tray: a sand hill from one cup of damp sand packed in a cup and turned out, and a tape line about a hand’s width from its bottom.
Misconceptions: “all rain soaks in” (much flows off); “erosion only happens in big storms” (many small rains move sand too).
Supports: sentence frames and a word bank (runoff, erosion, criteria, limit). Stretch: read the challenge quote and tell how it fits.
Answer guide: a drawing with downhill arrows and a sentence like “people want the sand to stay on the hill” shows K-2-ETS1-1:1a and 3a. Questions about rain size or wind show 2a. “Our stopper should be heavy so that it stays when water hits it” shows 4a.
U.S. Geological Survey Water Science School, Runoff: Surface and Overland Water Runoff · U.S. government work, public domain
When rain falls on the ground, it does not just sit there. Gravity pulls it. Some rain soaks into the ground. The rest flows over the land. Water that flows over the land is called runoff. Runoff moves downhill into streams and rivers.
Big storms make a lot more runoff. Then streams fill up with much more water.
Many things change how much water runs off. The kind of soil matters. Plants matter. Hard ground, like roads, parking lots and roofs, does not let water soak in. So more water runs off, and it runs faster. A steep hill sends water down quickly too.
Flowing water is strong. It can move soil and rocks. Over time, it can change the shape of the land. Runoff can carry bits of soil and sand, called sediment, into streams. People sometimes dig ditches or ponds to catch that sediment before it gets to a stream.
“Flowing water has tremendous power—it can move boulders and carve out canyons…” (USGS Water Science School)
Source: U.S. Geological Survey Water Science School, Runoff: Surface and Overland Water Runoff (usgs.gov)