find patterns in our test chart and tell what is good and not so good about each design.
Phase 4: Build
Number hunt. Look at the sample chart. Find the biggest number. Find the smallest number. What test do they belong to?
| Test (sample data) | No stopper | Design A: Pebble Wall | Design B: Felt Blanket |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wind: 10 fan waves | 5 spoonfuls | 4 spoonfuls | 1 spoonful |
| Gentle rain: 3 small sprinkles | 6 spoonfuls | 2 spoonfuls | 1 spoonful |
| Big storm: 1 cup poured fast | 12 spoonfuls | 5 spoonfuls | 6 spoonfuls |
| Stayed in place? | (none) | yes | slid a little in the storm |
Which design did best in the wind?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers, today we are data detectives. A pattern is something we notice again and again. Patterns in our chart tell us how each design works.
Step 1: compare with no stopper. Did each design lose less sand than the bare hill? In the sample chart, both did, in every test. So both meet criterion 1.
Step 2: look for the best in each row. Circle the smallest number in each row. That design did best in that test.
Worked example 1: Mia finds a pattern. Mia says, “The Felt Blanket did best in the wind and the gentle rain. The Pebble Wall did best in the big storm.” She asks why. “The felt covers the sand. But in the storm, lots of fast water slid under it.”
Worked example 2: Leo connects features. Leo says, “The wall is heavy and goes across the hill. Heavy and across is good for fast water. The blanket is flat and covers everything. Flat and covering is good for wind and drops.” Leo connected each feature to how well it worked.
Big idea. Each design has good parts and not-so-good parts. Like the living shoreline and the wall, we compare them to choose.
Use the sample chart and your own chart.
Be a data detective.
Make a T-chart for each design: good parts and not-so-good parts. Use numbers from your chart.
Which design better protects our hill overall? Explain with one number and one feature.
Both designs have strengths. Next time we see how a real team protects sand from wind and meet a scientist who helps with land.
Exit ticket: what could you borrow from the other design to make yours better?
Pacing: warm-up 4, reading 8, mini lecture 8, guided checks 9, T-charts 9, exit 2 minutes.
Misconceptions: “the design with the smallest number in one row wins everything”; “bigger numbers are better” (here, fewer spoonfuls is better).
Supports: highlight one row at a time; give a feature word bank (heavy, across, flat, covers, gaps). Stretch: add up each column to compare totals (sample: no stopper 23, A 11, B 8).
Answer guide: “The blanket was best in wind and gentle rain, the wall in the storm” shows K-2-ETS1-3:2a. Linking a feature to results (“the wall is heavy so the storm did not move it”) shows 2a and 2-ESS2-1:3a. Picking a design and backing it with a number shows 2-ESS2-1:3b and 3a.
NOAA National Ocean Service, What is a living shoreline? · U.S. government work, public domain
Land next to water can wash away. People protect it in two main ways.
One way is hard. People build walls or pile up big rocks at the edge of the water. A pile of rocks like this is called riprap.
The other way is a living shoreline. It uses natural things, like plants, sand and rock. Sometimes it uses plants and a low line of rocks together.
Scientists compared them. Living shorelines can hold up better than walls in big storms. A strip of marsh plants about 15 feet wide can soak up about half the push of the waves. Hard walls can cause more washing away nearby. They can also stop marsh plants from moving to new places.
Living shorelines do other good jobs too. They give fish a home, help keep water clean and trap sand and mud.
Each design has good parts and not-so-good parts. Engineers compare them to choose the best one for the place.
Source: NOAA National Ocean Service, What is a living shoreline? (oceanservice.noaa.gov)