test whether each shelter stands in the wind and how many blocks it holds, then find a pattern in our data.
Phase 4: Build
Think. Snow can pile up on a roof. Is a big pile of snow light or heavy?
What does a big pile of snow do to a roof?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Builders, today is the Strong Test. Our second criterion is Stands Strong. The shelter must stay up in the wind and hold at least 5 wooden blocks on its roof.
Wind first. Your teacher turns the fan on low for 10 seconds, one arm’s length away. Does the shelter stay standing? Write yes or no.
Then blocks. Set one block gently on the middle of the roof. Count. Add another. Stop when the roof sags to the floor or the shelter falls, or when you reach 8 blocks. Write the number it held. Do it 3 times and circle the best number.
Look for a pattern. A pattern is something that happens again and again. Look at your chart. Did the stiff roof hold more? Did the slanted roof stay drier? Patterns help us see how a feature is connected to how well a shelter works.
Worked example 1: Ana’s blocks. Ana’s Shelter A has a foil roof with no sticks under it. It held 1 block. Shelter B has a foil roof on 4 craft sticks. It held 7 blocks. Ana sees a pattern: the roof with stiff sticks held more. These are sample results.
Worked example 2: Eli’s class chart. Eli looks at every team’s chart. All 4 tent roofs had 3 dry tries. Only 1 of 4 flat roofs did. Eli says, “The pattern is that the slant helps water run off.” These are sample results.
| Shelter | Rain Test 1 | Rain Test 2 | Rain Test 3 | Dry tries | Stands in wind? | Blocks held (best) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shelter A | ||||||
| Shelter B |
Test, record, then look for patterns.
Finish your chart.
Write the best number of blocks each shelter held in the chart.
Write one pattern you see. Use this frame: “The shelter with ___ held more blocks or stayed drier because ___.”
Our charts are full of data. Next time, we decide which shelter is best and why.
Exit ticket: which property of a material helped your shelter stand strong? Use your data.
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 6 min, mini lecture 7 min, Strong Tests 14 min (guided checks during testing), chart and pattern 8 min, exit 2 min.
Setup: one small fan on the teacher’s table, away from the water trays; bring each shelter to it for a 10-second wind check on low. 8 same-size wooden blocks per team. Teach the “gentle hands” rule and model one test. Post a class chart so teams can add their numbers for Eli-style pattern finding.
Misconceptions: “the shelter that looks biggest is strongest.” Ask for the block count. Some students drop blocks to make the test harder; the test is only fair if every block is set down gently.
Supports: a number line 0-8 to circle the best count. Stretch: compare where blocks were placed (middle or edge).
Answer guide: “The shelter with craft sticks under the roof held more blocks because the sticks are stiff.” Accept rain patterns, too (“The foil roof stayed drier because foil is not absorbent”).
National Weather Service, Cloudburst Chronicle: Snow Loads · U.S. government work, public domain
Snow looks light and fluffy. But a lot of snow on a roof can be heavy. Its weight presses down on the roof. This weight is called the snow load.
Many people ask the National Weather Service about snow loads. A weather writer shared one way to check. Push a tall tube down into the snow, all the way to the ground. Bring the snow inside. Let it melt. Then measure how deep the water is.
The more water you get, the heavier the snow was. Each inch of water from melted snow means a little more than 5 pounds on a small square of roof, one foot on each side.
The writer gives a tip for grown-ups: measure the snow on your own roof if you can, because snow can be much deeper in one spot than in another, even close by.
The roof’s shape matters, too. On a slanted roof, less of the weight pushes straight into the roof. Snow stays on a slanted roof only until it starts to slide.
Source: National Weather Service, Cloudburst Chronicle: Snow Loads (weather.gov)