use our test patterns to improve our stopper, test it again and check it against our criteria.
Phase 5: Prove It
Mix and match. The Pebble Wall was best in the storm. The Felt Blanket was best in wind and gentle rain. What if we used both?
A team puts a felt blanket on top and a pebble wall at the bottom. How will it do in the big storm?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers, welcome to Prove It! Real engineers improve their designs. They use what they learned from tests.
Our design criteria. Criteria are the things our stopper must do to be good. The playground team needs a way to keep soil on the hillside. One: it slows down water and wind, so less sand reaches the playground line than with no stopper. Two: it works in big storms and in many small rains. Three: it stays in place on the hill. Four: it is safe for children to play near.
Our constraints. Constraints are our limits. We use materials we can get: only items from our class materials bin. That means pebbles, craft sticks, felt, cotton balls, paper towels, modeling clay and small cups. Everything must fit on our tray. We build in one class time.
Use your patterns. Look at your T-chart. Keep the good parts. Fix the not-so-good parts. The dune plants work above and below the ground. Our stopper can work on top of the hill and at the bottom.
Worked example 1: Aria’s team improves. Aria’s Felt Blanket slid in the storm. Her team tucks the felt under the hill and presses clay at the edges to anchor it. They add a low pebble wall at the bottom. Sample retest: wind 1, gentle rain 1, big storm 2 spoonfuls.
Worked example 2: Jonah checks the criteria. Jonah checks each row. Slows water and wind, with less sand than no stopper? Yes. Works in big storms and many small rains? Yes. Stays in place? Yes. Safe for children? Yes. Bin items only and fits on the tray? Yes. Their improved design meets every criterion.
| Sample retest | No stopper | Improved: Blanket + Wall |
|---|---|---|
| Wind | 5 | 1 |
| Gentle rain | 6 | 1 |
| Big storm | 12 | 2 |
Plan your change, build it and retest. Answer as you go.
Show how your design got better.
Write your old and new numbers for the big storm. Did your change help? How do you know?
Use the criteria checklist. Mark yes or not yet for each row. Write one sentence telling how well your stopper protects the hill now.
Your stoppers are stronger now! Next time you show what you know.
Exit ticket: is your improved stopper better than your first designs? Use one number.
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 6, mini lecture 6, plan and build 8, retest with checks 12, writing 3, exit 2 minutes.
Setup: same trays, water amounts and fan counts as 2.20. Teams may make one or two changes, using bin items only. Retest numbers in the lesson are sample data.
Misconceptions: “changing everything is best” (change one or two things so you know what helped); “if the number did not drop, we failed” (that is useful data too).
Supports: keep/fix organizer. Stretch: test the improved stopper with two big storms in a row.
Answer guide: using old and new numbers to judge the change shows 2-ESS2-1:3a. Saying the improved design works better than the first ones, with a number, shows 3b. Explaining good and not-so-good parts and choosing the best design for our hill shows K-2-ETS1-3:3a.
National Park Service, Fire Island National Seashore, Sand Dunes · U.S. government work, public domain
At a seashore park, wind shapes the sand into dunes. Plants help the dunes grow.
Dunes grow slowly. Some dunes in this park are about 40 feet tall. A dune that tall can take a very, very long time to form.
A plant called beachgrass catches sand as the wind blows it. Little by little, the trapped sand builds the dune up.
Plants hold the dune in two ways. The parts above the ground slow the sand. The parts below the ground, the roots, hold the sand in place. Together they anchor the dune, like a boat’s anchor holds the boat still.
Dunes are the first wall against storm waves. They also protect the land behind them from strong waves, wind and storms.
People can help. When visitors stay off the dunes, the plants stay healthy. Healthy plants protect the dunes.
Source: National Park Service, Fire Island National Seashore, Sand Dunes (home.nps.gov)