test both designs with wind, a gentle rain and a big storm, and record the results in a chart.
Phase 4: Build
Rain match. A gentle rain falls softly for a long time. A big storm pours a lot of water fast. Which one is a slow change? Which is a fast change?
Which test will wash the most sand past the line on a hill with no stopper?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers, it is test day! A test tells us how well each design works. We test each design the same way, so it is fair.
Our three tests, in order. Test 1, wind: fan the dry hill 10 times from the side. Test 2, gentle rain: sprinkle a little water three times, like many small rains. Test 3, big storm: pour one cup of water fast at the top. After each test, scoop up the sand past the tape line and count the spoonfuls.
Gentle rain and big storm. Many small rains are a slow change. A big storm is a fast change. Our criteria say our stopper must work for both.
Worked example 1: Jada’s no-stopper hill. Jada tests a hill with nothing on it. That shows what happens if we do nothing. Her sample data: wind 5, gentle rain 6, big storm 12 spoonfuls. Now she has numbers to compare with.
Worked example 2: Sam fills in the chart. Sam writes each number right away so he does not forget. He also writes if the stopper stayed in place. Here is the class sample chart.
| Test (sample data) | No stopper | Design A: Pebble Wall | Design B: Felt Blanket |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wind: 10 fan waves | 5 spoonfuls | 4 spoonfuls | 1 spoonful |
| Gentle rain: 3 small sprinkles | 6 spoonfuls | 2 spoonfuls | 1 spoonful |
| Big storm: 1 cup poured fast | 12 spoonfuls | 5 spoonfuls | 6 spoonfuls |
| Stayed in place? | (none) | yes | slid a little in the storm |
Big idea. A chart lets us see all our test results in one place.
Run your tests. Use the sample chart to answer.
Show your data.
Fill in your team chart for both designs and all three tests. Circle the smallest number in each row.
Did each design work in both the gentle rain and the big storm? Write one sentence for each design.
Great testing, engineers. Next time we look for patterns in our charts.
Exit ticket: which test moved the most sand? Was it a fast or slow change?
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 6, mini lecture 6, tests with check stops 18, chart writing 5, exit 2 minutes.
Fair test: run the wind test first while sand is dry, then lightly mist the hills before the rain tests. Gentle rain: a watering can, three short sprinkles of about a quarter cup each, held a ruler’s height above. Big storm: one full cup poured in about two seconds at the top of the hill. Rebuild the no-stopper hill the same way each time. The chart numbers in the lesson are sample data; real numbers will differ.
Misconceptions: “the design that loses 0 is the only one that works” (less than no stopper meets criterion 1); “one test is enough”.
Supports: pre-printed chart, number cards. Stretch: run the big storm twice and compare.
Answer guide: a complete chart with numbers for both designs shows K-2-ETS1-3:1a. A sentence like “the wall worked in the storm but let some sand blow” shows 2-ESS2-1:2a and begins 3a.
U.S. Geological Survey Water Science School, Surface Runoff and the Water Cycle · U.S. government work, public domain
Scientists say runoff depends on the rain. Is it rain, snow or sleet? How hard is it falling? How much falls? How long does it last? All of these change how much water flows over the land.
The ground matters too. If the soil is already wet from rain the day before, it cannot soak up as much. Then more water runs off.
The same storm can do different things in different places. A storm in a rainforest and a storm in a desert can make very different runoff.
People build things to handle rain water. These help a lot in small storms. But very hard rain can be too much for them.
Plants, soft soil and rain gardens help water soak in. Bare soil can wash away when runoff flows over it.
So engineers test their ideas with small rains and big storms. A good solution should work for both.
Source: U.S. Geological Survey Water Science School, Surface Runoff and the Water Cycle (usgs.gov)