find the cause of one weak spot, change one thing and test again.
Phase 5: Prove It
Think. Your shelter got wet one time. Before you fix it, what should you find out?
What should you do first?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Builders, let’s make it better. Look at your good and not so good table from 1.21. Pick one weak spot. Find its cause. Change one thing. Test again.
Why only one thing? If you change three things, you will not know which one helped. Change one thing, and your data tells you.
Use the same test. Do the Rain Test or the Strong Test the same way as before. Then compare the old number and the new number.
Worked example 1: June finds the cause. June’s shelter got wet once. She looks closely. Water came in at a gap where the foil did not reach the edge. She adds a strip of foil over the gap. New Rain Test: 3 dry tries instead of 2. These are sample results.
Worked example 2: Malik’s surprise. Malik’s roof held 4 blocks. He changes the roof shape from flat to slanted. Now it holds only 3, because the blocks slide off. His change did not help. Malik says, “Now we know. We go back to flat and add one more stick.” That is still good learning. These are sample results.
| Weak spot | Cause | One change | Old result | New result | Better? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Find, change, test and check.
Fill in the Make It Better table.
Write your weak spot, its cause and your one change.
Write your old result and your new result. Did your shelter get better? How do you know?
Next time is our checkpoint. Then our guests come to see our shelters!
Exit ticket: how did choosing the right materials help make your shelter better?
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 6 min, mini lecture 6 min, find and change 10 min, retest 10 min (guided checks during), table 3 min, exit 2 min.
Use: this is the flex revision lesson. Teams whose shelter already meets all three criteria can try Hugo’s two-cup Rain Test as an extension and improve for that.
Misconceptions: rebuilding from scratch instead of changing one thing; thinking a worse result means failure. Celebrate honest data.
Supports: magnifiers to find gaps; a picture card of the Make It Better steps (look, cause, change, test). Stretch: try a second change after the first one is tested.
Answer guide: a strong answer names one cause, one change, the old and new number and whether it improved (“We covered the gap. Old: 2 dry tries. New: 3. It got better.”).
National Park Service, Preservation Brief 4: Roofing for Historic Buildings · U.S. government work, public domain
Roofs do not last forever. People who care for old buildings say every roof will fail someday. When a roof leaks, it needs a fix fast. Water inside can harm wood, plaster and paint.
A good fix starts with careful looking. Before any repair, workers plan a full check of the roof. They look inside the building and outside. They try to find all the causes of the problem. A cause is the reason something happens.
Then they pick a way to fix it. Some parts can be repaired. Some parts must be replaced. A quick patch can help for a short time. But workers choose it with care, so it does not hurt the good parts of the roof.
Water can cause more trouble over time. Wood that stays wet can grow moss. The moss holds even more water. Then the wood can rot.
So the steps are: look closely, find the cause, then fix the part that is not working.
Source: National Park Service, Preservation Brief 4: Roofing for Historic Buildings (nps.gov)