review which changes from heating and cooling can be undone and which cannot.
Phase 5: Prove It
Remember our puzzle. Chocolate melts in a warm hand and gets hard again in the cold. A cooked egg never turns back. Why?
Which change can be undone?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Builders, today we review. A shelter must handle rain, snow, heat and cold. So let’s review how heating and cooling change materials.
Some changes can be undone. Ice melts into water when it warms. Water freezes into ice when it cools. Chocolate melts and gets hard again. We can go back and forth. These changes can be reversed.
Some changes cannot be undone. A cooked egg stays cooked. Baked bread stays bread. Cooling them does not bring back the raw egg or the dough.
Worked example 1: Nia’s claim. Nia says, “Melting snow on a roof can be reversed.” Her evidence: the reading says the water freezes back into ice at night. Her evidence supports her claim.
Worked example 2: Raj checks his evidence. Raj says, “A melted crayon can be reversed.” He only saw it melt. He needs more evidence. His teacher cools the melted crayon. It gets hard again. Now Raj has the evidence he needs.
Properties change, too. Hot chocolate is soft and runny. Cold chocolate is hard. The same material can have different properties when it is hotter or colder.
Review with a partner.
Claim and evidence.
Draw snow on a roof in the day and at night. Label melt and freeze.
Write a claim about a cooked egg. Can the change be reversed? Give your evidence.
Next time, we make our shelters better!
Exit ticket: name one change that can be reversed and one that cannot.
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 6 min, mini lecture 8 min, guided practice 10 min, claim and evidence 11 min, exit 2 min.
Use: this is the flex review lesson. Use your checkpoint planning to spend more time on whichever part 1 idea needs it most: properties, sorting, pieces or heating and cooling.
Optional demo: the teacher melts a crayon piece in a foil cup set in a bowl of hot tap water (teacher only, away from students), then lets it cool. Students do not handle hot water.
Misconceptions: “all melting is forever”; “a cooked egg would turn raw if we froze it.” Keep explanations at the level of what we can observe.
Supports: a two-column sort mat (can undo / cannot undo) with picture cards. Stretch: think of a heating change that cannot be undone that is not food (a clay pot fired in a kiln).
Answer guide: “Cooking an egg cannot be reversed. When I cool a cooked egg, it stays cooked.”
National Weather Service, Grand Rapids office: Preventing Roof Ice Dams · U.S. government work, public domain
In winter, a lot of snow can pile up on a roof. During the day, some of the snow melts into water. At night, it gets cold. The water freezes back into ice.
This can happen again and again. Melt in the day. Freeze at night. Over time, ice can build up near the bottom edge of the roof. This is called an ice dam.
An ice dam can cause trouble. Water and ice can push up under the roof’s shingles. Then water can get into the attic. It can harm ceilings, walls and things inside the house.
The National Weather Service shares ways to help. Keep gutters clear of leaves and sticks, so water can drain. Use a roof rake with a long handle, from the ground, to pull off heavy snow. Keep the attic cold with good insulation and air vents.
Ice dams happen most in places with cold, snowy winters.
Source: National Weather Service, Grand Rapids office: Preventing Roof Ice Dams (weather.gov)