use a model to explain that rocks break and wear away slowly, and how we know the change is slow.
Phase 2: Investigate
Feel and notice. Your teacher passes around a smooth stone from a stream and a sharp, rough rock. Feel each one gently.
How did the stream stone get so smooth?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Slow changes. Some changes are too slow to watch. A rock does not crumble in a day. It wears away a tiny bit at a time.
Weathering. Ice, water and plant roots break rock into smaller pieces. This is called weathering.
Our model. Scientists use models to study things that are too big or too slow. We will put chalk in a jar with a little water and shake it. The chalk is our rock. The shaking is like water tumbling rocks in a stream.
Worked example 1: Zoe counts shakes. Zoe shook her jar 20 times. The chalk edges got a little round. She shook 20 more times. They got rounder. She wrote, “More shaking, more wearing away.”
Worked example 2: Ethan explains. Ethan said, “In the jar it was quick. In a real stream it takes a very long time, because the water is gentle.” Ethan knows a model can speed things up.
How do we know it is slow? No one sees a rock wear down. We see clues later: smooth stones, cracks and little piles of broken rock. We see the change only after a long time.
Run the chalk model with your team, then answer together.
Record your model results.
Draw your chalk before and after shaking. Write one sentence: How is the jar like a stream?
Rocks wear away slowly. A model helps us see it. Next time, we watch water move sand and soil.
Exit ticket: name one clue that shows a slow change happened.
Pacing (40 min): rock feel 4, reading 7, mini lecture 7, model and guided practice 15, drawing 5, exit 2.
Materials (per team): a plastic jar with a lid, 2 short pieces of sidewalk chalk, a little water, a tray, goggles, a smooth stream stone and a rough rock to pass around.
Boundary: the jar takes minutes; stress that nature is much slower, but give no numbers. Weathering versus erosion: introduce only weathering today; 2.05 adds moving away.
Misconceptions: “Rocks never change.” The chalk bits and smooth stone are counter-evidence.
Answer guide: clues include smooth stones, cracks, broken bits, roots in rock. The jar is like a stream because water tumbles the rock.
National Park Service, Weathering · U.S. government work, public domain
Rocks look strong. But rocks at Earth’s surface break down. Scientists call this weathering. In weathering, the rock breaks or changes right where it is. It does not move away.
There are two kinds. In one kind, the rock breaks into smaller pieces. It is still the same rock, just in pieces.
How can rock break? Water can get into a crack. When the water freezes, it turns to ice and takes up more room. The ice pushes the crack wider. Rocks can also crack when they warm up and cool down again and again. Plant roots can grow in a crack and push it open. One park photo shows a fern growing in a crack in a rock wall.
In the other kind, water changes some of the stuff the rock is made of. Water can carry tiny bits of rock away, mixed into the water.
These forces seem small, but they are powerful. Little by little, they wear down even hard rock.
Source: National Park Service, Weathering (nps.gov)