use our model and chart to show how our stopper’s shape solves the problem and recommend the best design.
Phase 5: Prove It
Practice voice. Say this to a partner in a clear voice: “Our stopper keeps sand on the hill because ___.”
What makes a share-day talk clear?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers, it is Share Day! Today our guests are the playground team, the grown-ups who care for our playground. You will show your stopper and give advice.
A strong share has four parts. One: tell the problem. Two: show your model and point to how its shape helps. Three: show your chart. Four: recommend the best design and tell why.
Worked example 1: Maya shows the shape. Maya points to her model. “The felt covers the top so rain and wind cannot hit the sand. The pebble wall goes across the bottom with no gaps, so it catches what slides. The clay anchors it.”
Worked example 2: Luis recommends. Luis says, “Both first designs helped. The wall was best in the storm. The blanket was best in the wind. Our blanket-plus-wall lost only 2 spoonfuls in the storm. We recommend it. On a real hill, plants could be the blanket and rocks could be the wall. A rain garden at the bottom could catch the water.”
Be a good audience. Listen. Then give one star (something good) and one wish (an idea to make it better).
Practice your share with another team, then present.
Write your advice for the playground hillside.
Draw your final model. Label how its shape keeps sand on the hill in wind, a gentle rain and a big storm.
Write a short note to the playground team. Tell which design is best for the real hill and why. Use one number from your chart.
You shared like real engineers! Next time we look back and think about the future.
Exit ticket: what wish did you get? How could you use it?
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 6, mini lecture 5, rehearsal 6, team shares 15 (about 2 minutes each), note writing 3, exit 2 minutes.
Audience: invite a custodian, principal, playground aide or family volunteers. If guests cannot come, have a buddy class listen instead.
Misconceptions: “the model is the real solution” (it shows how a real solution could work, such as plants and rocks on a real hill).
Supports: four-part speaking cards; partners may share the talking. Stretch: answer one guest question with evidence.
Answer guide: pointing to the model and explaining how its shape helps shows K-2-ETS1-2:3a and 2a. A recommendation with good and not-so-good parts and a number shows K-2-ETS1-3:3a. Explaining both gentle rain and big storm shows 2-ESS2-1:2a.