use our questions, observations and test data to describe the problem and list what our model shelter must be like.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at the Wonder Board. Which questions have we answered? Move them to the “We learned” side.
What should we write first on our shelter wish list?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Engineers describe the problem first. Before we sketch or build, we write down the problem and what a good shelter must be like. This is our wish list.
Our problem. Hikers get wet and cold in the rain. Ranger Kim wants a shelter that keeps them dry and stands strong in wind.
Worked example 1: a problem statement. Amir wrote, “Hikers need a shelter that keeps rain out and does not blow over. We asked questions, and we tested materials to learn how.” He used his questions and tests.
Worked example 2: a wish list. Clara’s team wrote:
Use what we have. Like homestead builders, we must use the materials we have. Our classroom has foil, plastic, felt, paper, cardboard, craft sticks and clay.
What comes next. In the next part, you will sketch shelter ideas, build them and test them with a toy watering can and a fan.
Build your team’s wish list.
Write your own wish list.
Write the problem in one sentence. Then write three things your shelter must do or be.
Our wish list is ready. In the next part, we start designing and building our Stay-Dry, Stand-Strong Model Shelter.
Exit ticket: Pick one material for your shelter. Tell which job it will do and what test showed it can.
Materials: the Wonder Board, the roof/wall chart, a wish list template, a toy figure to show size.
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 7 min reading, 10 min problem and list, 12 min practice, 6 min closure.
Listen for: wish lists with only looks (color, decorations). Ask, “Does this help keep hikers dry or safe?” Keep the homestead history brief; the reading’s focus is choosing nearby materials.
Answer guide: a strong problem names hikers getting wet or cold and the need to stay dry and stand strong; the list ties each item to a property and a test. Part 2 begins with sketches (K-2-ETS1-2).
National Park Service, Homestead National Historical Park: 1867 Palmer-Epard Cabin · U.S. government work, public domain
Long ago, families called homesteaders built farms on the plains. A national park tells about their homes.
George W. Palmer built his cabin in 1867. He used hardwood trees. His cabin had one room, 14 feet by 16 feet. That was larger than most cabins at the time.
But in many places there were not enough trees for log cabins. So families lived in other kinds of homes. Some lived in dugouts, homes dug into the ground. Some lived in sod houses. Sod is grass with soil and roots stuck to it.
Later, a small room was added on the back. The Palmer family lived there until 1895.
Today, the cabin is in a national park. Workers have moved it several times. In 2009, they took it apart piece by piece. Then they put it back together at its new spot.
The cabin was built from wood in 1867. It is still standing today.
Source: National Park Service, Homestead National Historical Park: 1867 Palmer-Epard Cabin (nps.gov)