make a claim about whether changes from heating and cooling can be reversed, and back it up with evidence.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at the class chart: chocolate, ice, toast and egg. Point to each change that went back.
Which claim fits ALL our evidence?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Claim and evidence. A claim is what we think is true. Evidence is what we saw in our tests that backs it up. A scientist says, “I think ___ because I saw ___.”
Our evidence. Chocolate melted when warm and got hard when cold. Ice melted and froze again. Toast stayed toast when cooled. The cooked egg stayed firm in ice water.
Worked example 1: a claim with evidence. Noor wrote, “Some changes can go back. I saw ice melt and then freeze in the freezer.” Her claim and her evidence match.
Worked example 2: do we need more evidence? Dev wrote, “All changes from cooling go back.” His team asked, “Did we test enough things?” They only tested two things with cooling. They decided they need more evidence. Good scientists ask this.
Sorting changes. We sort each change into two groups: can go back and cannot go back. Our class chart will grow as we learn more.
Back to the puzzle. Chocolate melts in a warm hand and gets hard in the cold. That change can go back. A cooked egg never turns back. That change cannot.
Work with your partner.
Write your own claim.
Finish: Some changes from heating or cooling can go back, like ____. Some cannot, like ____. I know because I saw ____.
We solved part of our puzzle! Next time, we use our test data to pick the best materials for our shelter’s jobs.
Exit ticket: Why does the chocolate go back but the egg does not? Use what you saw.
Materials: the class change chart from 1.08 and 1.09, claim sentence strips, two sorting hoops labeled “can go back” and “cannot go back,” picture cards (ice, chocolate, toast, egg, butter, glass).
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 7 min reading, 10 min claim talk, 12 min practice and writing, 6 min closure.
Listen for: “cold always undoes heat.” Point to the egg. Accept “I need more evidence” as a strong answer.
Answer guide: the exit ticket should say chocolate got hard again when cooled but the egg stayed firm and white, so one change is reversible and one is not. Students do not need to explain why at a hidden level.
NOAA Satellite and Information Service (NESDIS), Water Cycle Board Game · U.S. government work, public domain
NOAA scientists study water from space. They use satellites. A satellite is a machine that circles Earth.
Solid ice is found in many places. It is in glaciers, which are huge, slow rivers of ice. It is in snow. It is near the North and South Poles.
Liquid water is in oceans, rivers, lakes and streams. Some is under the ground.
When the temperature of water changes, its state can change too. Each change from one state to another is called a phase change.
Ice and snow melt into liquid when they warm. Liquid water freezes into ice when it cools. Then it can melt again. Water can go back and forth.
Water also falls from the sky. Scientists call this precipitation. It can be rain, snow or hail.
The water cycle can bring big weather, like blizzards and hurricanes. Satellites help scientists track water. That helps them tell what the weather will be.
The water cycle is a process that never stops.
Source: NOAA Satellite and Information Service (NESDIS), Water Cycle Board Game (nesdis.noaa.gov)