use our data to tell what is good and not so good about each shelter and pick the best one.
Phase 4: Build
Think. Your shoes keep your feet dry, but they are a little heavy. Is that good, not so good or both?
Can one design have a good part and a not so good part?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Builders, time to decide. We have data from the Rain Test and the Strong Test. Now we use it to pick the best shelter.
Good and not so good. Most designs have both. Look at each shelter. What did it do well? What did it not do well? Use your chart, not just your feelings.
Best means best for our job. The best shelter meets the most criteria on our Design Card. It stays dry, stands strong and fits our hiker.
Worked example 1: Mei’s choice. Mei’s Shelter A had 3 dry tries but held only 3 blocks. Shelter B had 3 dry tries and held 6 blocks. Both stay dry. Only B stands strong. Mei writes, “B is best because it stays dry and stands strong.” These are sample results.
Worked example 2: Tariq’s tricky one. Tariq’s tent shelter stayed dry every time. But the toy hiker did not fit inside. His flat shelter fit the hiker but got wet once. Tariq writes, “Neither one is best yet. The tent is good at staying dry. Next, we make it wider.” These are sample results.
| Shelter | Good | Not so good | Meets which criteria? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shelter A | |||
| Shelter B |
Use your chart to answer.
Fill in the good and not so good table.
For each shelter, write one good thing and one not so good thing. Use numbers from your chart.
Write which shelter is best for our job and why. Name the criteria it meets.
Next time, we meet real builders and hear how they test their work.
Exit ticket: how did sorting materials by their properties help you choose your best shelter?
Pacing: warm-up 3 min, reading 7 min, mini lecture 7 min, guided practice 10 min, table and choice 11 min, exit 2 min.
Setup: each team has its full chart from 1.19 and 1.20 and its two shelters on the tray. Check that each toy hiker has been tried inside both shelters (Criterion 3).
Misconceptions: “best means it won one test.” Best means it meets the most criteria. If neither meets all three, that is fine; it tells us what to improve in 1.24.
Supports: smiley and frowny face stickers for good and not so good. Stretch: rank three class shelters from best to not yet.
Answer guide: “B is best because it had 3 dry tries and held 6 blocks, and the hiker fits.” For NASA: both build smaller shelters and test for leaks and strength. The exit ticket should connect a property (not absorbent, stiff) to a result.
NASA, Teams 3D Print Planetary Habitats, Awarded $700K in NASA Challenge · U.S. government work, public domain
Someday, people may live on the Moon or on Mars. They will need shelters there. NASA held a contest to find new ways to build them.
The contest went in steps over a few years. First, teams made designs. Next, they built parts of shelters. Last, they built whole shelters.
In the last round, the shelters were smaller than real size. Each one was about one third of the full size. Robots did most of the building. Teams used recycled materials and materials like ones found in space.
Then the shelters were tested. Judges checked the mix of materials. They checked for leaks, or places where things get through. They checked how long each shelter would last and how strong it was.
Two teams made it to the end. One team won first place, and one won second place. NASA said ideas like these might also help people build homes here on Earth.
Source: NASA, Teams 3D Print Planetary Habitats, Awarded $700K in NASA Challenge (nasa.gov)