The Stay-Dry, Stand-Strong Model Shelter
Which materials should we choose to build a model shelter that stays dry and stands strong?
The mystery: Chocolate melts in a warm hand and gets hard again in the cold, but a cooked egg never turns back. Why?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
notice a puzzling change in materials, meet our client, and tell why the rangers want a new rain shelter.
Phase 1: Spark
Do Now. Your teacher holds a chocolate chip in a small bag. A helper holds the bag in a warm hand for two minutes. Look closely. What is happening to the chip?
If we put the soft chocolate in the cold, what will happen?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
A puzzle to keep. The chocolate got soft in a warm hand. A cooked egg also changed when it got hot. Some changes seem to go back. Some do not. We will find out why in this unit.
A message from our client. Ranger Kim works at a nature center by a park trail. Hikers get caught in the rain. They get wet and cold. The rangers want a small shelter by the trail. It must stay dry inside. It must stand strong in the wind.
Our mission. We will build a model shelter on a table. A model is a small copy of something big. Our model must stay dry and stand strong. Then we will share our best ideas with the rangers.
Worked example 1: what is the problem? Rosa wrote, “Hikers get wet in the rain. The rangers want them to stay dry.” Her sentence tells who has a problem and what they hope will happen.
Worked example 2: a good question. Theo asked, “Is the shelter pretty?” Ava asked, “What will keep the rain out?” Both are fine questions. Ava’s question helps us solve the problem.
Materials matter. A material is what something is made of. Wood, paper, foil and cloth are materials. To build a good shelter, we must learn how materials act.
Talk with your partner. Then pick an answer together.
Start our class Wonder Board.
Write one thing you wonder about the chocolate, the egg, or the shelter. Put it on a sticky note.
We met our client and our mission. We saw chocolate change. Next time, we will sort our questions and decide what our shelter should do.
Exit ticket: Finish the sentence. The rangers want a shelter because ____.
Materials: chocolate chips in a sealed bag, a hard-boiled egg and a raw egg in sealed bags, sticky notes, chart paper for the Wonder Board. Check allergies first (chocolate, egg).
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 8 min reading aloud with partner talk, 10 min client message and examples, 12 min practice, 5 min Wonder Board.
Listen for: “the chocolate turned into water” (it melted into a liquid, but it is still chocolate). Do not resolve the egg puzzle yet; 1.08 to 1.10 build the evidence.
Supports: sentence frame “The hikers need ___ because ___.” Answer guide: a strong exit ticket names getting wet or cold and staying dry or safe.
National Park Service, Mesa Verde National Park: Cliff Palace · U.S. government work, public domain
Long ago, the Ancestral Pueblo people built homes in the side of a cliff. One large group of these homes is now part of a national park. It had about 150 rooms. About 100 people may have lived there.
The builders used three main materials. They used sandstone, mortar and wooden beams. Sandstone is a kind of rock. A beam is a long, strong piece of wood.
The builders shaped each sandstone block. They used harder stones from nearby rivers to do it. The harder stone could scrape the softer sandstone.
Mortar is the sticky stuff that holds blocks together. Their mortar was made of soil, water and ash. Small stones were pressed into the mortar. These little stones filled the gaps. They helped the walls stand strong.
Many walls were covered with plaster made from earth. The plaster came in pink, brown, red, yellow and white. Over many years, the plaster was the first part to wear away.
Many walls still stand today, hundreds of years later. Park workers check and care for them. How did the builders pick materials that last?
Source: National Park Service, Mesa Verde National Park: Cliff Palace (nps.gov)