The Hillside Wash-Away Stopper
How can we design a way to slow down water and wind from washing away a hillside near a playground?
The mystery: Waves can wash away a sandcastle in a few minutes, but a river took a very long time to carve a canyon. How can water make both kinds of change?
Questions we will figure out together in this unit:
tell that some changes to Earth happen fast and some happen slowly, using a sandcastle and a canyon as examples.
Phase 1: Spark
Watch closely. Your teacher builds a small sandcastle on a tray. Then your teacher pours a cup of water on it, like a big wave. Watch what happens. Next, look at a picture of a deep canyon with a river at the bottom.
Which change do you think took a longer time?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Hello, Land Detectives! Earth is always changing. Some changes are big. Some are small. Some are fast. Some are slow.
Fast changes. A fast change happens while we watch. A wave knocks down a sandcastle. A storm washes sand off a beach. We can see it happen.
Slow changes. A slow change takes a long, long time. A river carves a canyon a tiny bit at a time. No one can watch it happen. We only see the change after a very long time.
Worked example 1: Ava’s sandcastle. Ava built a sandcastle at the beach. A wave came. The tower fell right away. Ava said, “That was a fast change, because I saw it happen.”
Worked example 2: Omar’s canyon. Omar saw a picture of a deep canyon. He asked, “Did the river dig it in one day?” No. The river carried away little bits of rock for a very long time. Omar said, “That is a slow change.”
Our job. Near a playground, a hillside is washing away. Rain and wind carry the dirt down. Our class will design a Hillside Wash-Away Stopper. First, we need to learn how water and wind change land.
Let’s think together. Read each card with a partner. Then choose.
Fold a paper in half. Label one side Fast and one side Slow.
Draw the sandcastle on the Fast side. Draw the canyon on the Slow side. Write one word under each picture that tells how long it took.
Write one question you wonder about how Earth changes. We will put it on our Wonder Board.
Today we met our big puzzle. Water can change land fast or slowly. Next time, we visit the hillside problem.
Exit ticket: write one sentence. How is the sandcastle change different from the canyon change?
Pacing (40 min): sandcastle demo and predict 6, reading 8, mini lecture 8, guided practice 10, drawing and Wonder Board 6, exit ticket 2.
Materials: tray with damp sand, a cup of water, a canyon photo with a river at the bottom, chart paper for the Wonder Board, sticky notes, towels.
Boundary: keep time words qualitative (“fast,” “a very long time”). Do not teach years or ages for the canyon.
Misconceptions: “Earth never changes” or “the canyon was always there.” Accept these now; 2.04 and 2.13 bring evidence.
Supports: sentence frame: “The ___ was fast because ___. The ___ was slow because ___.” Stretch: name another fast change.
Answer guide: exit tickets say the sandcastle changed fast (we saw it) and the canyon changed slowly (it took a very long time).
National Park Service, Beach Response to Storms · U.S. government work, public domain
A beach is always changing. Waves move the sand. Scientists at the National Park Service study what happens to beaches when big storms come.
A big storm, like a hurricane, brings tall, strong waves. These waves can wash sand off a beach very fast. After the storm, the beach is often flatter than before. In one storm, a beach can change as much as it would in a long, long time of calm days.
Then the storm ends. Small, gentle waves come back. Little by little, they carry sand back up onto the beach. This fixing-up takes much longer than the storm did. Later, wind can pile sand into hills called dunes, and plants can grow on them again.
So the ocean makes two kinds of change. A storm makes a fast change. Calm waves make a slow change. Our puzzle is like that, too. Water can knock down a sandcastle fast. Water can also carve a canyon slowly.
Source: National Park Service, Beach Response to Storms (nps.gov)