use our test data to argue which material is best for a shelter roof and which is best for a wall.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look at our picture chart. Find one material that is waterproof. Find one that is strong.
Is the best roof material also the best wall material?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Data helps us decide. We do not pick a material because it looks nice. We pick it because our tests show it can do the job.
Roof job: keep rain out. Look at your drip test from 1.05. Which materials kept water on top? Those are roof choices.
Wall job: stand strong. Look at your bridge test from 1.04. Which materials held the most pennies? Those are wall choices.
| Material | Drip test result | Pennies held | Good for roof? | Good for wall? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Foil | stayed on top | 3 | ||
| Felt | dripped through | 1 | ||
| Cardboard | soaked in a little | 12 | ||
| Craft stick | stayed on top | 20 | ||
| Plastic strip | stayed on top | 8 |
These are sample numbers. Use your own team’s data, too.
Worked example 1: arguing for a roof. Ivy said, “Foil is best for the roof. In the drip test, water stayed on top. It is also flexible, so it bends over the top.” She used two pieces of evidence.
Worked example 2: arguing for a wall. Marco said, “Craft sticks are best for walls. They held 20 pennies, more than anything else.” Hope added, “Cardboard is strong, but it soaked in water. It might get soggy in rain.” The data showed a problem.
Use the sample table and your own data.
Make your case.
Finish: The best roof material is ____. I know because in our test ____.
Different jobs need different materials. Next time, we see how the same pieces can be built into new shapes.
Exit ticket: Which material is NOT good for a roof? Use your data to tell why.
Materials: team data from 1.04 and 1.05, the class picture chart, a two-column “roof / wall” anchor chart.
Pacing: 5 min Do Now, 7 min reading, 10 min argument talk, 12 min practice, 6 min closure.
Listen for: “I like it” as a reason. Ask, “What did your test show?” The reading is about real rock, not our classroom test; keep it as an example of materials acting differently with water.
Answer guide: poor roof = felt or paper towel (water dripped through or soaked in); best wall = the material with the most pennies in that team’s data.
National Park Service, Mesa Verde National Park: Cliff Alcoves · U.S. government work, public domain
At a national park, old stone homes sit in big hollows in a cliff. A hollow like this is called an alcove. The park tells how alcoves form.
The cliff is made of a rock called sandstone.
Sandstone has tiny spaces in it. Water can soak right down through it. Under the sandstone is a different rock called shale. Water cannot get through the shale. So the water stops there.
In winter, water gets into cracks in the rock. The water freezes into ice. Ice takes up more space than the water did. It pushes on the rock. This loosens chunks of stone. Over time, the chunks fall away. A hollow is left behind. That hollow is an alcove.
Most alcoves are small. Very few are big enough to hold a large group of stone homes.
Two rocks sit side by side, but they act very differently with water. Sandstone lets water through. Shale stops it.
Source: National Park Service, Mesa Verde National Park: Cliff Alcoves (nps.gov)