use evidence from several sources to explain fast and slow Earth changes, read a map and explain how our stopper helps.
Phase 5: Prove It
Hill riddle. I can happen in seconds after lots of rain. Soil and rocks rush down a slope. What am I?
What is it called when soil and rocks move fast down a slope?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Land Detectives, today you show what you know. You have learned from many sources. Good scientists use more than one source.
Our sources. Our own tests showed a big storm moves sand fast. The National Park Service dune page told us a tall dune takes a very long time to grow. The USGS told us landslides can rush down a slope. Three sources, one big idea: wind and water can change land fast or slow.
Worked example 1: Grace uses evidence. Grace writes, “A landslide is fast. The USGS says it can rush down a slope. A tall dune is slow. The park page says it takes a very long time. I know because one I could watch, and one I would only see after many years.”
Worked example 2: Eli reads a map. Eli looks at a map of a park. He sees a blue river, a blue lake and brown hills. He says, “The river flows into the lake. The hills are around the water. Maps can show the shape of land and water anywhere.”
Good sources. Scientists check facts. A science page from USGS or NOAA gives facts. “Hills are boring” is just an opinion.
Big idea. Use evidence from more than one source to explain how fast Earth changes.
Warm up for the check. Talk with a partner first.
Unit check. Do your best work on your own.
1. Use facts from three sources (our tests, the dune page and the landslide page). Explain how wind and water can change land fast and slow.
2. Look at your hillside map. Point to the land and the water. Write one pattern you notice, like where the water goes.
3. Draw how wind or water washes sand off a hill. Draw your stopper. Write how it should work in a gentle rain and in a big storm.
Wonderful thinking! Next time we share our stoppers with the people who playground team.
Exit ticket: which question was easiest? Which one made you think the hardest?
Pacing: warm-up 3, reading 7, mini lecture 6, guided checks 7, unit check 15, exit 2 minutes.
Accuracy: the slow-change evidence is from the 2.24 NPS dune reading (tall dunes take a very long time to form; the page gives a number, which we do not use). Keep earthquakes and landslides at the level of “fast changes”; do not frighten students.
Misconceptions: “one source is enough”; “slow means not happening”.
Supports: read questions aloud; allow drawing plus a short sentence. Provide the three-source organizer.
Answer guide: Q1 using three sources shows 2-ESS1-1:2b and 1b. Q2 naming land and water shapes and a pattern (“water flows downhill into the pond”) shows 2-ESS2-2:2b and 3a. Q3 shows 2-ESS2-1:1a and 2a and K-2-ETS1-1:4a. Naming USGS, NPS or NOAA as trusted sources shows 2-ESS2-3:2a.
U.S. Geological Survey, What is a landslide and what causes one? · U.S. government work, public domain
A landslide is when rock, soil or dirt moves down a slope. Gravity pulls it down.
A slope is held together by its own soil and rock. A landslide starts when the pull of gravity is stronger than what holds the slope together.
Most landslides have more than one cause. Water is a big one. Heavy rain can start a landslide. So can melting snow. A stream can wear away the bottom of a slope. Earthquakes can start landslides too.
People can cause landslides by mistake. Building roads without shaping the slope safely can do it. So can changing where water drains.
Some landslides flow like wet mud. People sometimes call them mudslides. They can rush down a slope. Some landslides move so fast that they make big waves when they fall into water.
A landslide is a fast Earth change. Water moving a little soil in many small rains is a slow change.
Source: U.S. Geological Survey, What is a landslide and what causes one? (usgs.gov)