
use my orbit model to compare satellite orbits for wildfire monitoring, evaluate them against weighted criteria and constraints, and recommend and defend a design.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Your client will hear your recommendation at a partnership vote. Write the one number from your model you most want them to remember, and why.
Which statement is the strongest reason a single geostationary satellite cannot meet a criterion of detecting very small new fires?
The design problem. The forest-protection agency wants frequent, detailed satellite views of wildfires across its region. You will act as a mission-design team, choose an orbit (or a combination of orbits) for a new fire-watch satellite system, and justify the choice with your orbit model and a trade-off analysis. Real missions weigh many more factors; your job is to reason as their designers do.
The options, computed with your model.
Criteria, constraints and trade-offs. Typical criteria: how often a fire is seen (revisit time), how small a fire can be detected (resolution), how quickly data reach firefighters (latency) and coverage of the whole region. Constraints: budget, number of launches, mass that a rocket can lift, and responsible use of space. Every orbit also adds to the debris problem. At orbital speeds, even a 1 g fragment at 10 km/s carries ½mv2 = 50,000 J, more than 60 times the 800 J of a 10 g bullet at 400 m/s (illustrative comparison). A decision matrix makes the trade-offs explicit: weight each criterion, score each option 1–5, and add the weighted scores.
Using the computational model. Your spreadsheet predicts period, speed and orbits per day for any altitude. Use it to test proposed solutions: for example, how many evenly spaced satellites in one 700 km polar orbit would it take so that one passes over the region about every 25 minutes? (Four, if the orbit is aligned over the region, which a real Earth rotating beneath the orbit makes harder, as you found in 4.08: say so.)
Why they stay up. In every option, Earth’s gravity is the net force on the satellite and supplies exactly the centripetal force mv2/r its circle needs; that is why the speed is set by the altitude.
What your report must show. A clear recommendation, calculations of at least two orbits from Newton’s laws, a check of your model against published data, a weighted decision matrix, one sensitivity test, the model’s limitations, and a paragraph on social and environmental impacts (cost, debris, who gets the data). Label every figure as sourced (NASA, NOAA, your model) or illustrative.
Check your method before you draft.
Draft, review and revise across the three sessions.
Peer review: rerun your partner's orbit calculations in your own spreadsheet, check their matrix arithmetic and challenge one weight. Write two specific notes.
Final: submit your 1,000–1,400 word report, then present or record your five-minute defense.
Task: Recommend an orbit, or a combination of orbits, for a satellite system that helps the regional forest-protection agency detect and track wildfires across its large, fire-prone region. Use your spreadsheet orbit model to compute the speed, period and orbits per day of at least two candidate orbits, and check the model against a published value (ISS, GPS, NOAA-20 or a geostationary weather satellite). Build a weighted decision matrix with at least four criteria (for example revisit time, resolution, latency and cost) and the constraints you must respect, and run one sensitivity test that changes a weight or an input. Explain the physics of why your satellites stay in orbit, discuss social and environmental impacts including orbital debris, identify when a plan’s negative consequences would outweigh its benefits, and state the limits of your model. Label every number as sourced (NASA, NOAA, NIST, your model) or illustrative.
Choose your starting point. All three earn full credit and are the same difficulty.
Option A — your own plans. Use the plans your team brainstormed and tested in 4.06–4.08.
Option B — the four plans in 4.07. Plans A–D (one low polar satellite, four in one plane, one geostationary, and a hybrid), plus the version-2 idea of spreading low satellites across planes. Recompute every output yourself.
Option C — PhET Gravity and Orbits. Use the Model screen to explore how speed and distance change an orbit, then build your spreadsheet for Earth and report how the sim’s behavior supports your model. Cite the sim and the date you used it.
| Criterion | What proficient looks like |
|---|---|
| Computational model (HS-ETS1-4) | Orbit model built from Newton’s laws, with realistic inputs, checked against published data, used to test more than one solution, and its limitations stated. |
| Trade-off evaluation (HS-ETS1-3, HS-ETS1-4) | Weighted criteria and constraints, correct matrix arithmetic, a sensitivity test that informs the recommendation, and a judgment of when negative consequences outweigh benefits. |
| Gravitation physics (HS-PS2-4, HS-PS2-1) | Correct explanation and calculation of orbital speed and period from gravity supplying the centripetal force. |
| Impacts | Addresses cost, debris and access to data at an appropriate scale. |
| Sources | Every input sourced or labeled illustrative. |
| Defense | Clear recommendation and reasoned answers to questions. |
Your recommendation is in the client’s hands. Next: the unit checkpoint.
Exit ticket: which Wonder Board question can you now answer with a number? Write the question and your answer.
Timing: three sessions, as in Poly: plan and model; peer review; final and defense.
Materials: rubric copies, team spreadsheets, devices, a timer.
Setup: invite a staff member or family volunteer to play the remote-sensing team. The agency, region and partnership are generic. NOAA-20, GOES, GPS and ISS values are published approximations.
Listen for: recommendations with no model check; limitations left out; debris treated as cost-free.
Support / stretch: provide a report outline and a pre-built spreadsheet. Stretch: add the one-way signal delay and a ground-station pass to your latency estimate.
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 6.