
derive the constant-acceleration equations from a velocity-time graph, use them to compute reaction and braking distances, and argue from evidence which part of a stop dominates at a given speed.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Hold your hand open. A partner will drop a ruler between your fingers without warning. Before you catch it, guess how many centimeters it will fall.
A car's speed doubles from 20 mph to 40 mph on the same road. What happens to its braking distance (not counting reaction)?
Three equations from one graph. For constant acceleration the velocity-time graph is a straight line from v0 at t = 0 to v at time t. Everything else follows from its slope and its area.
Check. v0 = 4 m/s, a = 2.5 m/s2, t = 6 s. Then v = 4 + 2.5(6) = 19 m/s. Rectangle plus triangle: 4(6) + ½(2.5)(36) = 69 m. Trapezoid: ½(4 + 19)(6) = 69 m. Third equation: 192 = 361 and 42 + 2(2.5)(69) = 16 + 345 = 361. All three agree.
Stopping a car. A stop has two stages. During the perception-reaction time tr the driver notices the hazard and moves a foot to the brake, and the car keeps its speed. Then the car decelerates to rest. Setting v = 0 in the third equation gives the braking distance v02/(2a), where a is the size of the deceleration:
dstop = v0tr + v02/(2a)
The table uses illustrative values: tr = 1.5 s (an alert driver; highway designers assume a longer, more cautious value) and a = 7.0 m/s2 (hard braking on dry pavement).
| Speed (mph) | v0 (m/s) | Reaction distance (m) | Braking distance (m) | Stopping distance (m) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | 11.2 | 16.8 | 8.9 | 25.7 |
| 35 | 15.6 | 23.5 | 17.5 | 41.0 |
| 45 | 20.1 | 30.2 | 28.9 | 59.1 |
| 65 | 29.1 | 43.6 | 60.3 | 103.9 |
Reading the pattern. Reaction distance is proportional to speed. Braking distance is proportional to speed squared: from 25 to 45 mph the speed rises by a factor of 1.8, but braking distance rises by 1.82 = 3.24. The two parts are equal when v0tr = v02/(2a), that is at v0 = 2atr = 21 m/s (about 47 mph). Below that speed, reaction distance is the larger part. At 25 mph it is 16.8 m out of 25.7 m, about 65%. One extra second of looking at a phone adds 11.2 m at 25 mph, more than the whole braking distance. Driver-education handbooks commonly recommend at least three seconds of following distance behind the car ahead for this reason.
From numbers to a design criterion. The stopping-distance equation turns a vague goal (“drivers should be able to stop”) into a measurable criterion: dstop must not exceed the sight distance to the crosswalk. That is the kind of quantitative criterion your design must meet.
Measure your own reaction time. A partner holds a ruler vertically with the 0 mark between your open fingers. Without warning they release it, and you catch it. The ruler falls from rest, so d = ½gt2 and t = √(2d/g). A catch at 20 cm means t = √(2 × 0.20/9.8) = 0.202 s. Do five trials and use the median. A ruler-drop time is shorter than a driving reaction time, because you are already watching and waiting. A driver must first notice an unexpected hazard, decide, and move a foot.
Building an argument. A strong scientific argument has a claim, evidence (numbers from the model or data) and reasoning (the physics that connects them), and it answers a counterclaim. For example: “At 25 mph, driver attention matters more than brakes.” The evidence is the table. The reasoning is that reaction distance grows with v but braking distance with v2. A good rebuttal considers the opposite case: on wet pavement a is smaller, which lengthens braking distance and lowers the crossover speed.
| Trial | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Median |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Catch distance d (cm) | ||||||
| t = √(2d/g) (s) |
Use the three equations and the stopping-distance table.
Argue from the evidence.
Do the ruler drop five times and compute your median reaction time. Then record a 90-second argument (or write 200 words) on the claim: “At school-zone speeds, reducing distraction saves more stopping distance than better brakes.” Use at least two calculated stopping distances as evidence, explain the v versus v2 reasoning, and answer one counterclaim (wet pavement, a younger or older driver, or a higher speed). Respond to one classmate's argument by supporting, qualifying or challenging it. A written post earns equal credit.
The stopping-distance model is now our main tool. Next, we extend motion to two dimensions.
Exit ticket: organize the 25 mph and 45 mph rows of the table into a claim about how speed changes stopping distance. Give the ratio of the braking distances and explain it.
Materials: 30 cm rulers, calculators, a projected table, a timer for 90-second arguments.
Setup: do the derivation on the board from one large v-t graph. Recorded arguments and written posts earn equal credit.
Listen for: “double the speed, double the stop”; using the ruler-drop time as a driving reaction time; arguments with no numbers.
Support / stretch: give a CER frame with a rebuttal box. Stretch: derive the crossover speed symbolically and recompute it for wet pavement, a = 5.0 m/s2.
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 3.