
use friction data to find coefficients of static and kinetic friction, and argue from evidence whether friction depends on normal force, contact area or both.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Push a heavy textbook across your desk, then stack a second book on top and push again. What changed, and why?
A 20 kg crate has μs = 0.5 and μk = 0.3. You push horizontally with 80 N. What happens?
The argument. Two claims come up every year. Claim A: “Wider tires stop a car faster because more rubber touches the road.” Claim B: “Friction depends on how hard the surfaces press together, not on how much area touches.” Today you use data to decide which claim the evidence supports for everyday sliding friction, and where the simple model stops working.
The friction model. Static friction holds a resting object in place. It adjusts to match whatever push you apply, up to a maximum fs,max = μsFN. Once the object slides, kinetic friction is roughly constant, fk = μkFN, and usually μk < μs. The coefficients μ have no units and depend on the two materials. OpenStax College Physics 2e lists wood on wood at about μs = 0.5 and μk = 0.3.
Worked example. A 20 kg wooden crate on a wooden floor: FN = 196 N, so it will not move until you push harder than 0.5 × 196 = 98 N. Push with 60 N and static friction pushes back with exactly 60 N; nothing moves. Push with 120 N and it breaks free; kinetic friction is 0.3 × 196 = 58.8 N, so a = (120 − 58.8)/20 = 3.06 m/s2. That is why a heavy object “jumps” once it starts: friction suddenly drops.
Evidence 1: friction against normal force. A student pulled a wooden block with a spring scale, adding masses to change the normal force (illustrative data):
| Block + added mass (kg) | Normal force FN (N) | Max static friction (N) | Kinetic friction (N) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.500 | 4.9 | 2.2 | 1.6 |
| 1.000 | 9.8 | 4.5 | 3.0 |
| 1.500 | 14.7 | 6.5 | 4.8 |
| 2.000 | 19.6 | 8.9 | 6.2 |
Both sets of points lie close to straight lines through the origin, so friction is proportional to the normal force. The slopes are the coefficients: μs ≈ 0.45 and μk ≈ 0.32.
Evidence 2: contact area. The same 1.000 kg block (FN = 9.8 N) was dragged on its wide face and then on its narrow side, three times each. Kinetic friction averaged 3.13 N on the wide face and 3.17 N on the narrow side: μk = 0.320 and 0.323. The difference, 0.03 N, is smaller than the 0.1 N spread between repeated trials, so the data show no measurable effect of area. At the microscopic level, surfaces touch only at tiny high points. Pressing harder flattens more of them together; spreading the same load over more area just means each point presses more lightly, and the true contact area stays about the same.
Causal or correlated? Notice the design of the evidence. Normal force was changed on purpose with area held fixed, and area was changed with normal force held fixed. That is how we tell a causal effect (normal force) from a factor that only seems related. Someone who noticed that wide-tired race cars stop well, without controlling for tire rubber, heat and weight, would be reading a correlation.
What it means for stopping a car. For tires, μ is the grip coefficient. At 25 m/s with μ = 0.7 on dry pavement (illustrative), the maximum deceleration is μg = 6.86 m/s2 and the braking distance is v2/(2μg) = 45.6 m. On wet pavement with μ = 0.5 it is 63.8 m. Mass cancels: a heavier car needs more friction but also presses harder on the road. Rubber on pavement is where the simple model is weakest. Tread, temperature and water film all matter, and wide tires are chosen mainly for heat and wear, not because the textbook model predicts more friction.
Materials. A rectangular wooden block (or a full box of crayons or a hardcover book) with a string loop; a 0–10 N spring scale (or a rubber band calibrated with known masses); 500 g bags of rice, cans or slotted masses; a kitchen scale; a long flat table.
| Total mass (kg) | FN (N) | Static, 3 trials (N) | Kinetic, 3 trials (N) | Mean static | Mean kinetic |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Narrow side | — | — |
Use your data or the illustrative table.
Make your argument.
Record a 90-second argument (or write 200 words) that answers Claim A or Claim B. Cite your own or the illustrative friction data (slopes, means and spread), explain the microscopic reasoning, say which relationship is causal and which is only a correlation, and answer the strongest counterclaim, including what new evidence would change your mind. Then respond to one classmate by supporting, qualifying or challenging their argument. A written post earns equal credit.
Friction depends on normal force, not area. Next, we put friction and slopes together into an escape-ramp model.
Exit ticket: a gravel bed resists a truck like friction. Using today's evidence, would a heavier truck feel a larger resisting force? Would it decelerate faster? Explain both.
Materials: blocks, spring scales, masses, kitchen scale; devices for the sim.
Setup: one 50-minute period: 20 min lab, 10 min sim, 20 min arguments. Recorded and written arguments earn equal credit.
Listen for: “more area, more friction”; static friction always equal to μsFN; differences smaller than the spread treated as real.
Support / stretch: give a CER-with-rebuttal frame. Stretch: find the angle at which the block just starts to slide on a tilted board and show tan θ = μs.
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 5; OpenStax College Physics 2e, chapter 5.