
specify quantitative and qualitative criteria and constraints for the school crossing, prototype three solutions in a stopping-distance spreadsheet, and choose one with a weighted decision matrix.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Sort these into criteria (what success means) and constraints (limits): stopping distance fits inside the sight distance; the city can spend no more than one sign budget this year; federal guidance keeps yellow intervals about 3 to 6 s; traffic should not slow much; the change must be in place before the next school year.
“The yellow interval must stay within federal guidance of about 3 to 6 seconds” is a constraint.
Designers, today you prototype. For a calculation-based design, the prototype is a working model: a spreadsheet that takes speed, reaction time, deceleration and sight distance and reports whether the stop fits. Your team designs for Site 1, the mid-block school crosswalk where parked cars hide children until a driver is 30 m away (illustrative values). Teams choosing the signal question use the same steps with the yellow model from 1.09.
Step 1: criteria and constraints. Quantitative criterion: dstop ≤ sight distance, using tr = 1.5 s and a = 5.0 m/s2 (damp pavement). Qualitative criteria: drivers understand the change; children are visible. Constraints: a small budget, one school year to install, existing laws and federal sign and signal guidance, and residents who need some parking.
Step 2: build the model. Spreadsheet columns: speed (mph), speed (m/s) = mph × 0.44704, reaction distance = vtr, braking distance = v2/(2a), stopping distance, sight distance, spare distance = sight − stop. Behind a is Newton’s second law: the road’s friction force on the tires divided by the car’s mass.
Worked example 1: three concepts in the model.
| Concept (illustrative) | Speed | Sight distance | tr | a | Stopping distance | Meets criterion? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Now: no change | 30 mph = 13.41 m/s | 30 m | 1.5 s | 5.0 m/s2 | 20.1 + 18.0 = 38.1 m | No (8.1 m short) |
| A. Lower the limit | 25 mph = 11.18 m/s | 30 m | 1.5 s | 5.0 m/s2 | 16.8 + 12.5 = 29.3 m | Yes, 0.7 m spare |
| B. Remove parking beside the crosswalk | 30 mph | 45 m | 1.5 s | 5.0 m/s2 | 38.1 m | Yes, 6.9 m spare |
| C. Flashing beacon (assumes tr = 1.0 s) | 30 mph | 30 m | 1.0 s | 5.0 m/s2 | 13.4 + 18.0 = 31.4 m | No (1.4 m short) |
Concept C depends on an assumption (a beacon shortens reaction time) that our data do not support yet, so we score its evidence low.
Worked example 2: the decision matrix. Priya’s team weights the criteria and scores each concept from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent):
| Criterion (weight) | A. Lower limit | B. Remove parking | C. Beacon |
|---|---|---|---|
| Safety margin (×3) | 2 → 6 | 4 → 12 | 1 → 3 |
| Traffic flow (×2) | 3 → 6 | 5 → 10 | 5 → 10 |
| Cost (×2) | 5 → 10 | 4 → 8 | 3 → 6 |
| Strength of evidence (×1) | 5 → 5 | 4 → 4 | 2 → 2 |
| Total | 27 | 34 | 21 |
B wins on these weights. A matrix does not end the thinking: B removes two parking spaces, a cost residents will feel, and A’s margin is very thin. Next lesson we test both against harder conditions.
Build your spreadsheet first, then answer.
Finish your team’s design record.
Write your team's criteria (at least three, two of them quantitative) and constraints (at least three). Then record your three concepts, the model results and your decision matrix, and state which concept is version 1 and why.
Version 1 is chosen. Next lesson, a gallery critique and a harder test.
Exit ticket: name one criterion and one constraint for the crosswalk design, and explain how your spreadsheet checks the criterion.
Materials: devices with a free spreadsheet, or graph paper and calculators; matrix templates.
Setup: all site values are illustrative. Teams may choose Site 3 (the yellow interval) instead; give them the yellow model y = tr + v/(2a) from 1.09 early.
Listen for: criteria that are not measurable; weights chosen after seeing the totals; treating the matrix as the final answer.
Support / stretch: provide a pre-built spreadsheet with one formula missing. Stretch: add a column that finds the highest speed that still fits the sight distance by solving 0.1v2 + 1.5v − 30 = 0.