
set quantitative criteria and constraints for the scale-model liner, prototype and test three concepts, justify each material and structure, and choose one with a weighted decision matrix.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Sort these into criteria (what success means) and constraints (limits): the egg survives a 1.0 m drop; average force under 20 N; at most 100 g of added material; no side longer than 25 cm; only low-cost everyday materials; the liner can be reused.
A 60 g egg dropped from 1.0 m must feel an average force of at most 20 N. At least how far must the liner crush?
Engineers, today you prototype. Your prototype is a scale-model liner: a crush zone that protects a 60 g raw-egg “head” dropped from 1.0 m. One equation links every design choice to the force: at a steady crush force, the work the liner does equals the energy the egg brings, so Favg = mgh/d = mv2/(2d). It is the same result as Δp/Δt with Δt = 2d/v.
Step 1: criteria and constraints, quantified. Criteria: the egg survives; Favg ≤ 20 N (so d ≥ 2.9 cm); the liner is as light as possible, because riders refuse bulky helmets; reusable if possible. Constraints: added mass ≤ 100 g; no side over 25 cm; low-cost everyday materials; no parachutes (the test is about the impact, not the fall); goggles at every test. Trade-offs to watch: crush distance against mass and bulk; protection against reusability; cost against waste.
Step 2: justify the material from its structure. A concept is only as good as its reasoning. For each concept, name the structure that crushes, why it crushes at a steady force rather than springing back or shattering, and how far it can crush before it bottoms out (assume about 80% of its thickness, illustrative).
Worked example 1: three concepts on the test bench.
| Concept (illustrative bench data) | Material and structure | Thickness | Crush at 1.0 m drop | Average force F = mgh/d | Added mass | Meets 20 N criterion? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Card honeycomb | Corrugated card cut into hexagon tubes, standing on end | 5.0 cm | 3.5 cm | 0.588/0.035 = 16.8 N | 45 g | Yes, 3.2 N spare |
| B. Bubble pillow | Two layers of bubble wrap (trapped air cells) | 3.0 cm | 2.5 cm | 0.588/0.025 = 23.5 N | 20 g | No; egg also rebounds |
| C. Straw array | 30 drinking straws standing upright in a card frame | 8.0 cm | 5.0 cm | 0.588/0.050 = 11.8 N | 60 g | Yes, 8.2 N spare |
Concept B fails twice: it crushes too little, and trapped air acts like a spring, so the egg rebounds, which makes Δp larger. A and C crush steadily because their tube walls buckle one fold at a time, the same idea as EPS cells.
Worked example 2: the decision matrix. Diego’s team weights the criteria to match the client’s priorities and scores each concept from 1 (poor) to 5 (excellent):
| Criterion (weight) | A. Honeycomb | B. Bubble pillow | C. Straw array |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protection (×3) | 4 → 12 | 2 → 6 | 5 → 15 |
| Low mass and bulk (×2) | 4 → 8 | 5 → 10 | 3 → 6 |
| Cost (×2) | 5 → 10 | 4 → 8 | 4 → 8 |
| Reusability (×1) | 1 → 1 | 4 → 4 | 1 → 1 |
| Total | 31 | 28 | 30 |
A wins, but by one point. A one-point margin is a warning: a small change in a weight could flip it. The team carries both A and C into the critique and stress test next lesson.
Communicating the material. Your design record shows each material in at least two formats: a labeled sketch of its structure (tubes, cells or chains) and a number (crush distance and force).
Build and test your three concepts first, then answer.
Finish your team’s design record.
Write your team's criteria (at least three, two of them quantitative) and constraints (at least three). Record your three concepts with test data and a materials justification for each, your decision matrix with a reason for each weight, and which concept is version 1.
Version 1 is chosen. Next lesson, a gallery critique and a harder test.
Exit ticket: name one criterion and one constraint for the liner, and explain with F = mgh/d why a thicker liner meets the force criterion more easily but may break a constraint.
Materials: per team: sealed raw eggs and practice eggs, corrugated card, straws, bubble wrap, paper cups, tape, a kitchen scale, a meter stick, a phone, goggles, a tray and paper towels.
Setup: the concept data are illustrative. Fix the drop height at 1.0 m from a marked line, dropped by a student standing on the floor.
Listen for: justifications with no structure; weights changed after seeing totals; matrices that rank designs which fail a must-pass criterion.
Support / stretch: provide a matrix template with weights already filled in. Stretch: find the crush distance at which the bubble pillow would just meet the 20 N criterion if it did not rebound.