
show what I learned about net force, mass and acceleration, friction and inclines, and breaking a complex design into connected sub-problems.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Back to the phenomenon: a truck with overheated brakes on a steep mountain highway grade. In two sentences, explain why it speeds up and why an uphill gravel bed can stop it.
On the escape ramp, the weight component along the slope and the gravel's resistance both point backward.
Physicists, this is the unit checkpoint. Part A is multiple choice with data and a scenario set. Part B is four constructed responses scored 0–3. Draw a free-body diagram whenever forces are involved.
How a 0–3 answer is scored. 3: correct claim, accurate evidence or calculation with units, and reasoning that names the physics or design idea. 2: correct claim and evidence with weak reasoning, or one small error. 1: partly correct with little support. 0: incorrect or blank.
Worked example: a 3-point answer. Question: “Why must the design speed be fixed before the ramp length?” Priya wrote: “Length comes from L = v2/(2a), so it cannot be computed until v is chosen. Because L grows with v2, a small error in speed makes a large error in length, so speed must be settled first and chosen with a margin.” Claim, equation and reasoning: 3 points.
Data for questions 1–3 (sample data).
| Net force (N) | 0.20 | 0.40 | 0.60 |
|---|---|---|---|
| a for the 0.50 kg cart (m/s2) | 0.40 | 0.80 | 1.20 |
| a for the 1.00 kg cart (m/s2) | 0.20 | 0.40 | 0.60 |
Scenario set for questions 7–12 (illustrative). A new escape ramp: design entry speed 30 m/s; 6% upgrade (θ = 3.43°); loose gravel, effective μ = 0.25; land available 200 m; required safety factor 1.25.
Part A: answer on your own. Your teacher reviews answers after everyone finishes.
Part B: constructed responses, each scored 0–3.
13. A highway department wants to reduce brake failures on the same grade before trucks ever need the ramp. Break this problem into at least three sub-problems in a flow chart, and explain how solving them together addresses the larger problem. (0–3)
14. The scenario site loses land: only 150 m is now available. Use the model to propose two different solutions to the deceleration sub-problem, with numbers, and say which you recommend. (0–3)
15. State the criteria and constraints for the length sub-problem, give the order you would solve the four sub-problems in, and justify which criterion wins if cost and safety conflict. (0–3)
16. Use the cart data to explain how net force, mass and acceleration are related, express the relationship as an equation, and explain why these data show cause and effect and not just a correlation. (0–3)
Finished. Unit 3 takes these forces into collisions and crash safety.
Exit ticket: which idea from this unit would you most like to practice again, and why?
How confident are you that you can I can use Newton's second law with data and design a solution by solving connected sub-problems.
Materials: printed checkpoint with the data and scenario tables, calculators, the 0–3 scoring guide.
Setup: about 35 minutes for Parts A and B, then a short review. Item tags: 1 PS2-1:1a; 2 and 4 PS2-1:2a; 3 and 16 PS2-1:3a; 5 PS2-1:3c; 6 and 16 PS2-1:3b; 16 PS2-1:1a, 3c; 9 and 15 ETS1-2:2b; 10 and 15 ETS1-2:2a; 11 and 13 ETS1-2:1c; 13 ETS1-2:1a; 14 ETS1-2:1b; 12 ETS1-2:2b. Check value for 14: at 8% (a ≈ 3.22) L ≈ 140 m, 175 m designed, still too long, so students must combine a steeper grade with a higher-μ bed (for example 10% and μ = 0.30: a ≈ 3.90, L ≈ 115 m, 144 m designed).
Listen for: sine and cosine swapped; “heavier trucks need longer ramps” in the simple model; sub-problems that do not connect.
Support / stretch: read items aloud on request and allow a formula card. Stretch: for item 14, find the smallest μ that fits 150 m at a 10% grade.