
model an impact with stopping distance, stopping time and average force, and explain how the molecular and cellular structure of foam and other designed materials lets them absorb a collision.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Press a thumbnail into three things: a piece of white packing foam, a rubber eraser and a plastic ruler. Which one stays dented? Which springs back? Which barely moves? Write one guess about why.
Two liners stop the same falling egg. Liner X crushes 1.5 cm; liner Y crushes 3.0 cm. How does the average force from Y compare with X?
Stopping distance is the design variable. Engineers rarely control stopping time directly; they control how far something can crush. If an object decelerates uniformly from speed v to rest over distance d, its average speed is v/2, so Δt = 2d/v and the deceleration is a = v2/(2d). Double the crush distance and you halve the force.
Worked example 1: the egg drop. A 60 g egg falls 1.0 m. It lands at v = √(2gh) = √(2 × 9.8 × 1.0) = 4.43 m/s with momentum 0.060 × 4.43 = 0.266 kg·m/s.
Worked example 2: a crumple zone. A 1,500 kg car hits a rigid barrier at 13.4 m/s (30 mph). If its front were nearly rigid and crushed only 10 cm, the deceleration would be 13.42/(2 × 0.10) = 898 m/s2 (about 92 g) over 15 ms. A crumple zone that folds over 60 cm gives 150 m/s2 (about 15 g) over 90 ms, and the average force on the car drops from 1,347 kN to 224 kN (distances illustrative). The passenger compartment is built stiff so that the front does the crushing and the cabin keeps its shape.
Why materials matter: structure at the molecular level. Expanded polystyrene (EPS), the white foam in most bike helmets, is made of long polystyrene polymer chains. Each chain is a carbon backbone with a ring-shaped side group on every second carbon, repeated thousands of times: –[CH2–CH(C6H5)]–n. Beads of the polymer are expanded with a gas and fused into a foam of tiny closed cells whose walls are thin polymer films. Solid polystyrene has a density of about 1,050 kg/m3; a foam of 60 kg/m3 (illustrative) is about 94% gas by volume. On impact the cell walls buckle and collapse one layer after another. Because the chains are tangled and glassy at room temperature, they do not snap back: the work of crushing becomes permanent deformation and heat instead of being returned as a bounce. That is why a helmet that has taken a hard hit must be replaced.
Three structures, three functions. A rubber ball’s cross-linked chains stretch and recoil; it returns energy, so the object rebounds and Δp grows. A brittle solid such as glass has rigid bonds that crack before they deform much, so it stops things in a tiny distance. A crushable cellular material (EPS foam, corrugated cardboard, a honeycomb, a folded steel crumple rail) is designed to collapse at a nearly constant force over a long distance.
The area under a force-distance graph is the energy absorbed, mgh = 0.060 × 9.8 × 1.0 = 0.588 J. The foam holds 19.6 N the whole way; a spring stopping the egg in the same 3 cm has to reach 39.2 N, then pushes the egg back up. A flat plateau is the ideal crash-safety shape.
Common misconceptions. (1) “Softer is always safer.” Foam that is too soft bottoms out and the force spikes at the end; the best liner is matched to the expected speed and mass. (2) “Strong cars are safe cars.” The cabin should be strong; the front and rear should be designed to crumple.
Question. How does the crush distance of a crumple zone on a cart change the average force on an egg “passenger” when the cart hits a wall at a fixed speed?
Materials. A lab cart or toy truck with a flat bed; a raw egg sealed in a zip-top bag and tape or a rubber band as a seat belt; a 1 m board propped on books to a measured height of 10–20 cm; crumple-zone materials (paper cups, straws, index cards, corrugated cardboard, packing foam); a heavy book or brick as the wall; a meter stick; a phone for slow-motion video; goggles, paper towels and a tray or plastic sheet.
| Design | Material and structure | Speed at wall (m/s) | Crush distance (m) | Stopping time 2d/v (s) | Average force on egg (N) | Egg survived? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Illustrative | 4 paper cups, mouth down | 1.40 | 0.035 | 0.050 | 1.7 | yes |
| Rigid front | ||||||
| Design 1 | ||||||
| Design 2 | ||||||
| Design 3 |
No equipment? Illustrative class data set. Five designs run on the same ramp with a 60 g egg. These numbers are constructed to show the calculation; they are not real measurements.
| Design | Speed at the wall (m/s) | Crush distance d (m) | Stopping time 2d/v (s) | Average force on the egg (N) | Egg survived? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rigid wooden front (control) | 1.40 | 0.004 | 0.0057 | 14.7 | no |
| 4 paper cups, mouth down | 1.40 | 0.035 | 0.050 | 1.68 | yes |
| 20 drinking straws standing upright | 1.42 | 0.055 | 0.0775 | 1.10 | yes |
| Folded index-card accordion | 1.38 | 0.022 | 0.0319 | 2.60 | yes |
| Packing-foam block | 1.41 | 0.018 | 0.0255 | 3.31 | yes |
A crush distance read from 30 fps video is good to about ±0.003 m. Carry that uncertainty through when you decide which designs really differ.
Work through these as your team analyzes its crash data.
Model and explain.
Write a one-paragraph explanation, with a labeled sketch, for a family buying a teen's bike helmet: why is the liner made of foam full of tiny closed cells rather than solid plastic or rubber, and why should a helmet be replaced after one hard crash? Use the words polymer, cell, deform and force, and include one number from today's data.
Crush distance controls the force, and structure controls the crush. Next, we pull the unit’s science together and brainstorm liner designs.
Exit ticket: compute the average force on a 60 g egg landing at 4.43 m/s on a material that crushes 2.0 cm, and name one material structure that could give that crush distance.
How confident are you that you can I can calculate the force in an impact from crush distance and explain how a material's structure helps it absorb a collision.
Timing: Poly ran this as 2 × 50 min. Period 1: the model and materials explanation, then build crumple zones; period 2: crash tests and analysis. Teams without equipment use the class data set.
Materials: per team: cart or toy truck, board and books, sealed raw and practice eggs, cups, straws, cards, cardboard, foam, tape, a brick or heavy book, meter stick, phone, goggles, tray and paper towels.
Listen for: “softer is always safer”; confusing stopping distance with drop height; explaining material behavior with no reference to structure.
Support / stretch: give the force formula F = mv2/(2d) on a card. Stretch: sketch the force-distance graph of a foam that bottoms out after 2 cm and explain why its peak force is higher.
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 8.