
explain with Fnet = ma why a car decelerates when it brakes, revise our stopping-distance model, tell causal from correlational evidence, and brainstorm solutions for the client.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Look back at your guess from 1.01. Using the table in 1.04, how close were you? Then answer: what actually makes a braking car slow down? Name the object that pushes on the car.
Two cars brake with the same braking force. One has twice the mass. How does its deceleration compare?
Revising our model. Our stopping-distance model so far is purely kinematic: it says how the car moves, given a. Today we ask why the car decelerates. The cause is a force: when the brakes grip the wheels, the road pushes backward on the tires through friction. A net force causes an acceleration in its own direction:
a = Fnet/m, or Fnet = ma
Newton’s second law turns our model from a description into an explanation. Unit 2 tests it in the cart lab; today we use it to make sense of data.
Worked example 1: braking data (sample data, test-track style).
| Trial | Car mass (kg) | Net braking force (N) | Measured deceleration (m/s2) | F/m (N/kg) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A | 1,500 | 3,000 | 2.0 | 2.0 |
| B | 1,500 | 6,000 | 4.0 | 4.0 |
| C | 1,500 | 9,000 | 6.0 | 6.0 |
| D | 1,000 | 6,000 | 6.0 | 6.0 |
| E | 2,000 | 6,000 | 3.0 | 3.0 |
Rows A–C hold mass constant: doubling and tripling the force doubles and triples the deceleration. Rows B, D and E hold force constant: the more massive car decelerates less. In every row the measured deceleration equals Fnet/m, so a = Fnet/m models the data.
Worked example 2: gravity’s constant acceleration. A 0.5 kg ball weighs 4.9 N; a 2.0 kg ball weighs 19.6 N. Both ratios are 9.8 N/kg, so both fall with a = 9.8 m/s2, as your projectiles did in 1.05. On the 1.03 ramp, only part of the weight acts along the slope, so the ratio, and the acceleration, is g sin θ.
Causal or just correlated? A causal relationship means changing one quantity makes the other change; a correlation means two quantities rise and fall together, possibly because of something else. In the controlled braking trials, force was changed on purpose with mass held fixed, so the evidence is causal. Now a sample city data set: intersections with longer yellow lights had more crashes per year. Does a longer yellow cause crashes? Probably not. Longer yellows are set on faster roads, and faster roads have more crashes; approach speed is a confounding variable. Only a controlled comparison (same road, yellow changed) could show cause.
Claim, evidence, reasoning. Sentence starters: I claim that … / The evidence is … (cite rows and numbers) / This happens because … (Newton’s second law) / Someone might argue …, but …
Ideate. The client needs a solution, not just an explanation. Every idea must change a term in dstop = v0tr + v02/(2a) or the sight distance it must fit inside. Example ideas: lower the speed limit (smaller v0); remove parking beside the crosswalk so drivers see it sooner (more sight distance); add an advance warning sign or flashing beacon (driver expects the hazard); lengthen the yellow; add a raised crosswalk that slows cars. Brainstorm rule: quantity first, judge later.
Use the braking table and the causal-or-correlated example.
Ideate for the client.
Brainstorm at least five solutions for the school crosswalk or the signal. For each, name which term of the stopping-distance model (or the sight distance) it changes. Circle the three your team will compare in the Build phase.
Revise your Wonder Board: mark which questions you can now answer and write one new question the force model raised.
We have a revised model and a list of ideas. Next phase: design, prototype and choose.
Exit ticket: explain the difference between a causal and a correlational relationship, using one example about braking or traffic.
How confident are you that you can I can use F<sub>net</sub> = ma to explain why an object accelerates, and tell causal from correlational evidence.
Materials: chart paper for CERs and the brainstorm, sticky notes, the Wonder Board.
Setup: the braking table and the yellow-light crash data are sample data invented for teaching; say so. The force idea is introduced here as a model; Unit 2 tests it in the lab.
Listen for: “heavier cars always stop slower” (true only if the force stays the same); treating any correlation as cause.
Support / stretch: give the CER starters on a card. Stretch: a car carries extra load of 300 kg with the same braking force; compute the new deceleration and stopping distance at 25 mph.