
give and use peer critique, test version 1 against the criteria under harder conditions, and revise the connected sub-problem solutions into a version 2.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Name two ways a real runaway could be worse than your design assumed.
Packed, wet gravel lowers the effective μ from 0.25 to 0.20. With the same grade, the ramp's deceleration…
Gallery critique. Post your flow chart, matrix and version 1. Visitors leave I like…, I wonder… and What if… notes, and one visitor recomputes your length. Answer at least two notes in writing.
The stress test (illustrative). The runaway arrives 10 mph faster than the design speed (35.5 m/s instead of 31 m/s), and the bed has packed down after rain (μ = 0.20).
| Design | Speed (m/s) | Grade, μ | a (m/s2) | L (m) | Fits 220 m? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Version 1 (B) | 35.5 | 5%, 0.20 | 2.45 | 257 | No |
| Steeper only | 35.5 | 8%, 0.20 | 2.74 | 230 | No |
| Version 2: 8% + raking after every use | 35.5 | 8%, 0.25 | 3.22 | 195 | Yes, 25 m spare |
| Version 2 at design speed | 31 | 8%, 0.25 | 3.22 | 149 (186 with ×1.25) | Yes |
Worked example 1: connected sub-problems. Diego’s team learned that the sub-problems are linked. Raising the grade (deceleration) alone did not fix the length. Adding a maintenance rule (site and upkeep) kept μ at 0.25, and together they fit the land. A change in one sub-problem moved the others.
Worked example 2: priorities under a trade-off. Version 2 costs more to build (more earthwork for 8%) and more to maintain (raking after every use). The team ranks “stops the truck” above cost and writes: “A cheaper ramp that fails on a wet day fails at the moment it is needed.”
Scale-model retest. Repeat yesterday’s best bed with packed, damp gravel and then with freshly raked gravel. Compare the stopping lengths; this is the evidence behind the maintenance rule.
Run the stress test in your spreadsheet.
Write version 2.
Describe version 2: what changed in each sub-problem, the stress-test result and the spare length. Draw your updated flow chart and explain how each change affected the others.
Highway agencies in mountainous regions on several continents build escape ramps beside long downgrades where trucks can lose their brakes. Most are arrester beds: long lanes of deep, loose aggregate, often on an upgrade, that the driver steers into. The wheels sink into the bed, and the work of pushing the loose material aside slows the truck.
Design guides favor rounded, similar-sized gravel, because angular or mixed stones lock together and pack down, and packed gravel no longer lets wheels sink. Beds also need drainage, and crews rake them loose and tow out the truck after every use. In other words, the ramp only works if the maintenance plan works.
Think about it: Why do designers prefer rounded gravel to sharp crushed rock? What evidence from our friction lab and scale model connects to this choice, and what would you want to measure on a real ramp?
Version 2 is ready for the design report.
Exit ticket: explain how solving the maintenance sub-problem helped solve the length sub-problem in your version 2.
Materials: sticky notes, chart paper, the scale-model setups and spreadsheets from 2.07, a spray bottle of water to dampen one gravel tray.
Setup: 15 min gallery, 15 min stress test and retest, 10 min case study, 10 min version 2. All site values are illustrative.
Listen for: treating sub-problems as independent; dropping the safety factor to make a design fit.
Support / stretch: give the stress-test table with one row filled. Stretch: find the lowest μ at which version 2 still fits at 35.5 m/s.