
measure a cart’s acceleration for several pulling forces at constant mass, graph a against F, and use the slope and intercept to find the system’s mass and the friction force.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Wonder Board question: “Does a heavier truck need a longer ramp?” Before we can answer, we need to know exactly how force and mass control acceleration. Predict the shape of a graph of acceleration against pulling force for a cart of fixed mass.
The pulling force on a cart of fixed mass doubles. The acceleration…
The claim to test. Newton’s second law says acceleration is proportional to net force and inversely proportional to mass: a = Fnet/m. HS-PS2-1 asks you to support that claim with data. Today you pull a cart with a falling mass and measure the acceleration for six different pulling forces.
The setup, and why the total mass stays fixed. A cart on a level track is tied by a string over a pulley to a small hanger. The system is the cart plus the hanging mass, and the pulling force on that system is the hanger’s weight, mhg. To change the force without changing the system’s mass, keep a set of slotted masses on the cart and move them one at a time from the cart to the hanger. The total mass M never changes, so any change in acceleration comes from the change in force alone. That is a controlled variable, and it is what makes the evidence causal rather than merely correlational.
Measuring acceleration. Release the cart from rest and time it over a measured distance d (0.800 m here), or use phone video as in Unit 1. From rest with constant acceleration, d = ½at2, so a = 2d/t2. Worked example: t = 1.23 s gives a = 2(0.800)/1.232 = 1.058 m/s2.
Illustrative data. Cart plus all slotted masses and hanger: M = 0.520 kg.
| Hanging mass mh (g) | Pulling force mhg (N) | Time over 0.800 m (s) | a = 2d/t2 (m/s2) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | 0.098 | 3.86 | 0.107 |
| 20 | 0.196 | 2.29 | 0.305 |
| 30 | 0.294 | 1.83 | 0.478 |
| 40 | 0.392 | 1.51 | 0.702 |
| 50 | 0.490 | 1.37 | 0.852 |
| 60 | 0.588 | 1.23 | 1.058 |
Reading the graph. If a = F/M, the graph of a against F is a straight line with slope 1/M. The least-squares line through these points is a = 1.929F − 0.078, with r2 = 0.9985. The slope gives M = 1/1.929 = 0.518 kg, within 0.3% of the balance reading. The line does not pass through the origin: it crosses the force axis at 0.040 N. That intercept is evidence for friction in the wheels and pulley. The cart only accelerates once the pull exceeds about 0.04 N, and the true net force is mhg − f.
The string tension is less than the hanger’s weight. A common error is to say the string pulls the cart with mhg. If it did, the hanger would feel zero net force and could not accelerate. For a 50 g hanger and no friction, a = mhg/M = 0.942 m/s2 and the tension is T = mh(g − a) = 0.443 N, less than the 0.49 N weight. Treat the cart and hanger as one system and you never need the tension.
Uncertainty. If a hand-timed run of 2.00 s is uncertain by ±0.05 s (2.5%), the acceleration, which depends on 1/t2, is uncertain by about twice that, 5%. Time each force at least three times, use the longest track you can, and let the graph average out the scatter.
Materials. A dynamics cart or low-friction toy truck and a level track or smooth table at least 1 m long; a pulley clamped to the table edge (or a smooth round pencil taped down) and about 1.5 m of thin string; a paper-clip or cup hanger and six 10 g masses (coins, washers or slotted masses) massed on a kitchen scale; meter stick, masking tape, phone or stopwatch; a folded towel below the hanger and a stop block at the end of the track; goggles.
| mh (g) | F (N) | t1 (s) | t2 (s) | t3 (s) | Mean t (s) | a (m/s2) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | ||||||
| 20 | ||||||
| 30 | ||||||
| 40 | ||||||
| 50 | ||||||
| 60 |
No equipment? Use the illustrative data above, or PhET Forces and Motion: Basics (Acceleration screen, friction off): apply 50, 100, 150 and 200 N to the 50 kg crate, record a, and graph a against F.
Answer while your data run.
Write the lab conclusion.
Write your lab conclusion (150–200 words): your claim about a and F, the slope and intercept of your graph with units, the mass you calculated and its percent difference from the balance, and the source of error you think mattered most, with the direction it pushed your result. Explain why holding M constant makes your evidence causal.
Our data support a = Fnet/m. Next, we find out what friction depends on, because the gravel bed is a friction machine.
Exit ticket: use your graph to predict the acceleration for a 0.70 N pull on the same system. Show the equation of your line.
Timing: Poly ran this lab as 2 × 50 min. Period 1: setup and timed runs; period 2: graphs, the mass extension and the conclusion.
Materials: see the procedure; washers or coins work if slotted masses are scarce. Check masses on a kitchen scale.
Listen for: tension equal to the hanger’s weight; moving masses off the system entirely (changes M); forcing the line through the origin.
Support / stretch: pre-build the spreadsheet formulas for a. Stretch: correct each force for friction (F − 0.040 N) and refit.
Reading: OpenStax Physics (high school), chapter 4; OpenStax College Physics 2e, chapter 4.