
give and use peer critique, interpret simulation results to predict their effects on the real system, recognize when a plan’s negative consequences outweigh its benefits, identify the simulation’s limitations, and build a version 2.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Four satellites share one polar orbit, evenly spaced. If the first passes over the forest at 10:00, when do the other three pass? Use the 98.6 min period.
Four evenly spaced satellites share one 98.6 min orbit. How far apart in time do they follow each other?
Gallery critique. Post your version 1 with its inputs, outputs and matrix. Visitors leave three sticky notes: I like…, I wonder… (question an assumption), What if… (a change to test). Answer at least two notes in writing.
Worked example 1: the model’s hidden assumption. Jamal’s team chose plan B, four satellites in one polar plane, scored as “about 8 passes a day, evenly spread.” A critic asked: “I wonder if they really spread out?” The orbital plane stays nearly fixed in space while Earth turns beneath it, so the region rotates under that plane about twice a day. All four satellites follow the same path about 25 minutes apart, so the region sees them in two bursts, a morning or evening group and a night group, with roughly 12-hour gaps between bursts. The spreadsheet could not show this, because it leaves out Earth’s rotation. That is a limitation of the simulation, and it changed the decision.
Version 2. Spread the low satellites into two or more orbital planes that cross the region at different times of day, and keep the geostationary satellite for constant watch (a version of plan D). The model’s outputs for period and speed are unchanged; what changes is how the passes fall through the day.
Worked example 2: when the costs outweigh the benefits. A team proposed plan E: forty small satellites at 300 km for the sharpest images. The model gives a 90.4 min period and 15.9 orbits a day, and the images would be sharper (700/300 = 2.3 times finer detail). But at 300 km, drag would bring each satellite down within a short time (illustrative: months, not years), so the system would need constant replacement launches; each launch adds cost, rocket stages and the risk of debris. The team judged that these negative consequences outweighed a 2.3-times gain in detail the client had not asked for, and dropped plan E.
Limits of our simulation. Our spreadsheet assumes circular orbits, a round, non-rotating Earth, no drag and no pull from the Moon or Sun. It predicts speed and period well (within a fraction of a percent for the ISS) but says nothing about drag, ground tracks, cloud cover, or how long data take to reach a ground station. Every recommendation must say which outputs the model supports and which come from other evidence.
Test your version 1 against the critique, then answer.
Write version 2.
Describe your version 2: what changed and why, the model outputs, what you predict it means for crews on the ground, two limitations of the simulation that affect it, and one negative consequence you accepted and why the benefit outweighs it.
In 1978, NASA scientist Donald Kessler warned that if low Earth orbit became crowded enough, collisions could create debris that causes more collisions. On February 10, 2009, that risk became real: a working communications satellite, Iridium 33, and a retired Russian satellite, Kosmos 2251, collided at roughly 790 km above Earth. It was the first known accidental collision between two intact satellites.
The crash broke both into well over a thousand pieces large enough to track, many of which stayed in orbit for years, in the same altitude band that many Earth-watching satellites use. Space agencies now track debris, plan avoidance maneuvers, and ask new missions to lower their satellites out of orbit when their work is done.
Think about it: How should the risk of debris change the weights in our decision matrix? What would you ask a mission team to promise before adding satellites to low orbit?
Version 2 is ready. Next phase: the mission design report and defense.
Exit ticket: name one limitation of our simulation and explain how it changed (or could change) your recommendation.
Materials: chart paper, three colors of sticky notes, team spreadsheets, a globe and a hoop to show an orbital plane with Earth turning inside it.
Setup: 15 min gallery walk, 10 min globe-and-hoop demo of the plane problem, 10 min case study, the rest for version 2. Satellite lifetimes at 300 km depend strongly on solar activity and design; keep them qualitative.
Listen for: trusting model outputs the model cannot produce; dismissing debris as someone else’s problem.
Support / stretch: provide a limitations checklist. Stretch: estimate how many planes, each with two satellites, would give a detailed pass about every 3 hours.