
test bed materials on a scale-model escape ramp, measure their effective friction, and choose a full-scale ramp concept by solving the sub-problems in order with a weighted decision matrix.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Put the four sub-problems in the order you would solve them, and explain why the first one has to come first.
Why must the design speed be chosen before the ramp length?
Engineers, today you build two prototypes. The first is physical: a scale-model arrester bed that tests which material slows a toy truck best. The second is mathematical: your ramp spreadsheet, used to compare full-scale concepts.
Scale model. A toy truck rolls down a launch ramp (the “downgrade”), crosses a 0.20 m timing zone, and enters a bed tray 0.30 m long (the “available land”). From the entry speed and the stopping length, the effective coefficient on a level bed is μ = v2/(2gL), because a = μg and L = v2/(2a). Sample results at an entry speed of 1.20 m/s:
| Bed (sample data) | Stopping length (m) | Effective μ | Stops within 0.30 m? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bare board, level | runs off the end | — | No |
| Dry sand, level | 0.12 | 0.61 | Yes |
| Aquarium gravel, level | 0.18 | 0.41 | Yes |
| Aquarium gravel, 10% upgrade | 0.15 | 0.41 (model predicts 0.145 m) | Yes |
The upgrade result checks the model: a = 9.8(sin 5.71° + 0.41 cos 5.71°) = 4.95 m/s2, so L = 1.202/(2 × 4.95) = 0.145 m, close to the 0.15 m measured.
Full-scale concepts (illustrative site). Design entry speed 31 m/s; land available 220 m; required safety factor 1.25.
| Concept | Grade, bed | a (m/s2) | L (m) | L × 1.25 (m) | Fits 220 m? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A. Gravity ramp | 15% up, paved (rolling resistance 0.01) | 1.55 | 310 | 388 | No; truck may roll back |
| B. Ascending arrester bed | 5% up, gravel μ = 0.25 | 2.94 | 164 | 205 | Yes |
| C. Level arrester bed | 0%, gravel μ = 0.25 | 2.45 | 196 | 245 | No |
Worked example 1: solving the sub-problems in order. Mei’s team fixes the design speed (31 m/s) first, because every later number depends on it. Next, the deceleration (grade plus bed), then the length with the safety factor, and last the site check. When concept C failed the site check, they went back one step and changed the deceleration, not the land.
Worked example 2: the decision matrix. Scores 1–5, times the weight:
| Criterion (weight) | A | B | C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fits the land with the safety factor (×3) | 1 → 3 | 4 → 12 | 2 → 6 |
| Stops the truck with no roll-back (×3) | 1 → 3 | 5 → 15 | 5 → 15 |
| Cost and maintenance (×2) | 4 → 8 | 3 → 6 | 3 → 6 |
| Driver can see and enter it (×1) | 3 → 3 | 4 → 4 | 4 → 4 |
| Total | 17 | 37 | 31 |
Safety criteria carry the highest weights because a ramp that fails to stop a truck has failed completely; a ramp that costs more has not. That is how you justify which criteria win when trade-offs appear.
Run three trials per bed, then answer.
Record version 1.
Write your team's version 1: the concept, the criteria and constraints for each sub-problem, the order you solved them in, the numbers from your model, and the matrix totals. Explain which criterion you would protect first if a trade-off forced a choice, and why.
Version 1 is chosen. Next lesson: critique, a harder test and version 2.
Exit ticket: why did safety criteria get weight 3 and cost weight 2? Would you change either weight? Defend your answer.
Materials: per team: a launch ramp (board and books), a toy truck with free-rolling wheels, a 0.30 m bed tray, dry play sand, aquarium gravel, a phone for timing, goggles, towel, stop block; devices with the ramp spreadsheet.
Setup: 25 min scale tests, 20 min concepts and matrix. All values are sample or illustrative; toy wheels sink differently from truck tires.
Listen for: fixing the land instead of the design; weights chosen after the totals; trusting the scale model as a full-scale prediction.
Support / stretch: give the μ formula and a filled first row. Stretch: find the grade at which concept C’s level bed would just fit 220 m with the safety factor.