answer the unit’s driving question with evidence from our texts and our panels, and reflect on my growth as a reader and informative writer.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Reread the driving question: What does it take to turn a discovery into something that helps millions? List three things it takes, based on everything we read in this unit.
How confident are you that you can I can answer the driving question with evidence from more than one text.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Back to the bells. We began this unit with a 1955 headline and a question: why did people ring church bells for a vaccine? Now you can answer with evidence from many texts, not one.
What our texts showed. Part 1 traced the polio vaccine from a Pittsburgh lab to a nation and Langley’s work at the Allegheny Observatory. In Part 2, Haythorn’s 1919 report showed that careful testing and honest conclusions matter, even when a vaccine fails. Holman and the CDC showed that knowledge changes as evidence grows. De Kruif showed Pasteur rethinking a plan that could not scale and asking others to check his results. The NASA article showed scientists sharing their work with the public.
Reading the speech. Pasteur’s message is a series of questions students should ask themselves, moving outward from my instruction to my country to humanity. That structure is his central idea: learning leads to service. De Kruif’s phrase “a hymn of hope” compares the speech to a song of praise, and his comparison to the welcome usually given to generals suggests that saving lives deserves more honor than winning battles.
Worked example 1: Bryce builds an answer. Bryce writes: “Turning a discovery into help for millions takes testing that others can check. Pasteur asked a commission to check his dog experiments, and Haythorn warned that his own chart could not prove the flu shots worked.” He makes a claim and supports it with two texts.
Worked example 2: Nia reflects on her writing. Nia compares her first plan card with her final panel. “My first big idea was ‘Salk was amazing.’ My final one is ‘A vaccine developed in a Pittsburgh lab became a nationwide effort.’ I learned to say what is true and checkable instead of only what I feel.”
Looking ahead. Next semester you will research the 1889 Johnstown Flood, where sources disagree about what really happened. The skills you built here, from comparing conflicting texts to crediting every source, will come with you.
Use de Kruif’s passage under “The text” and your notes from the unit.
Answer the driving question and reflect.
Synthesis paragraph (120 to 180 words): What does it take to turn a discovery into something that helps millions? Make a claim with two or three parts, and support it with evidence from at least two unit texts, named. Include one sentence about a Pittsburgh breakthrough.
Reflection: compare your first plan card (2.15) with your final panel. Name two specific improvements, the lesson where you learned each skill and one goal for your next informative writing.
Pasteur asked students, “What have I done for my instruction?” This unit, you can answer.
Exit ticket: finish this sentence: “A discovery helps millions only when…”
Pacing: warm-up 4 minutes, reading 8, mini lecture 8, guided practice 10, synthesis and reflection 13, closure 2.
Source notes: the passage is copied from the end of chapter V of the 1926 book (Gutenberg #77842). It begins with “But there is another end,” because de Kruif first describes Pasteur’s death in 1895; the summary mentions only the Pasteur Institute from the earlier pages. De Kruif writes “young men,” “boys” and “new way of life for men,” as was common in 1926; invite students to notice whom the ceremony included and whom it left out, and point out that Pasteur’s collaborators included women, such as Madame Pasteur, whom de Kruif calls one of his most important collaborators. The speech is de Kruif’s quotation of a translation; treat its wording as his.
Discussion note: the phrase “futile butchering of thousands of enemies” is de Kruif’s strong opinion about war; students with family in the military may react. Frame it as the author’s point of view and his reason for the comparison.
Likely misconceptions: that the driving question has one answer (it has several parts); that reflection means only saying what was fun.
Supports: provide a claim frame: “It takes ___, ___ and ___. For example, in ___ (text), ___.” Stretch: compare Pasteur’s speech with Eisenhower’s 1955 citation from Part 1.
Answer guide: sample synthesis: “Turning a discovery into help for millions takes a practical plan, testing that others can check and a way to share results with the public. Pasteur dropped his plan to vaccinate every dog in France and treated bitten people instead, and he had a commission check his experiments (de Kruif, 1926). Haythorn’s 1919 Pittsburgh report showed why careful counting matters, because his chart could not prove the flu shots worked. Finally, the polio vaccine developed at the University of Pittsburgh reached millions only after a huge public test.” Accept any claim with accurate, named evidence.
Project Gutenberg, Microbe Hunters by Paul de Kruif (Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1926), eBook #77842, chapter V · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
This is the end of the Pasteur chapter in Paul de Kruif’s Microbe Hunters (1926). After the rabies vaccine succeeded, money came from around the world to build a laboratory in Paris, the Pasteur Institute. De Kruif then describes a ceremony in 1892 at the Sorbonne, a famous university in Paris, for Pasteur’s seventieth birthday. The surgeon Joseph Lister, known for bringing germ-fighting methods into surgery, comes to honor him.
Pasteur is old and ill, so his son reads his speech. Notice who is in the audience and whom Pasteur speaks to. Also notice de Kruif’s comparisons: he contrasts the honor given to Pasteur with the honors usually given to generals.
Words to know: magnificoes, very important people; tier, one of a set of rows placed one above another; futile, useless; hymn, a song of praise; deprecating, belittling; barren, producing nothing; skepticism, doubt; serene, calm.
But there is another end of his career that I like to think of more–and that was the day, in 1892, of Pasteur’s seventieth birthday–when a medal was given to him at a great meeting held to honor him, at the Sorbonne in Paris. Lister was there, and many other famous men from other nations, and in tier upon tier, above these magnificoes who sat in the seats of honor, were the young men of France–the students of the Sorbonne and the colleges and the high schools. There was a great buzz of young voices–all at once a hush, as Pasteur limped up the aisle, leaning on the arm of the President of the French Republic. And then–it is the kind of business that is usually pulled off to welcome generals and that kind of hero who has directed the futile butchering of thousands of enemies–the band of the Republican Guard blared out into a triumphal march.
Lister, the prince of surgeons, rose from his seat and hugged Pasteur and the gray-bearded important men and the boys in the top galleries cried and shook the walls with the roar of their cheering. At last the old microbe hunter gave his speech–the voice of the fierce arguments was gone and his son had to speak it for him–and his last words were a hymn of hope, not so much for the saving of life as a kind of religious cry for a new way of life for men. It was to the students, to the boys of the high schools he was calling:
“… Do not let yourselves be tainted by a deprecating and barren skepticism, do not let yourselves be discouraged by the sadness of certain hours which pass over nations. Live in the serene peace of laboratories and libraries. Say to yourselves first: What have I done for my instruction? and, as you gradually advance, What have I done for my country? until the time comes when you may have the immense happiness of thinking that you have contributed in some way to the progress and good of humanity….”
Source: Project Gutenberg, Microbe Hunters by Paul de Kruif (Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1926), eBook #77842, chapter V (gutenberg.pglaf.org)