show what I have learned in Unit 2 by reading a new passage closely, writing an on-demand informative paragraph and turning in my final exhibit panel.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Take a slow breath. Read the passage twice: once for the events, once with your pencil. Underline anything you might use as evidence, and put a star where de Kruif dramatizes.
How confident are you that you can I am ready to read closely and use evidence from the passage.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How this check works. Part A is a reading check on the new passage and our note cards. Part B is an on-demand informative paragraph. Part C is your final exhibit panel with your revision log and a timed 60-second gallery talk. Take your time and use evidence.
Reminders for Part A. When a question asks for evidence, choose the quotation that most directly supports the answer. When it asks for a central idea, choose the point the whole passage develops, not one detail. When it asks about disagreement, decide whether it is a matter of fact or interpretation. Use the note cards for the questions that name them.
| Note card | What the source says (our words) |
|---|---|
| A. Haythorn, 1919 (Pittsburgh) | Experts disagreed about vaccines, masks and closings. His data on mixed vaccines were inconclusive and gave little evidence that they protected against influenza. |
| B. Holman, 1919 (Pittsburgh) | The germ B. influenzae should be considered the bacterial cause of epidemic influenza, unless more convincing evidence shows a more probable living virus. |
| C. CDC (archived page) | The 1918 pandemic was caused by an H1N1 virus. There was no flu vaccine and no antibiotics, so control efforts were limited to steps such as isolation, quarantine and hygiene. |
| D. De Kruif, 1926 | On July 6, 1885, Pasteur’s team gave the first injection of the rabies vaccine to a human, nine-year-old Joseph Meister, who stayed well. |
Worked example 1: Zoe separates fact from telling. A practice question asks which detail a panel could check. Zoe writes, “Nocard’s number of dogs in France is checkable. ‘Unseen assassins’ is de Kruif’s figure of speech for the rabies germs.”
Worked example 2: Rafael connects two texts. Rafael notices that Pasteur asked a commission to check his experiments. He writes, “Like Haythorn, who warned that his chart’s groups were counted differently, Pasteur wanted his results tested by others before anyone trusted them.”
Reminders for Parts B and C. Use the twelve-item panel checklist: introduce and preview, develop with facts, definitions and a quotation, include a captioned graphic, group under headings with transitions, conclude with so what, choose precise words and edit carefully.
| # | Panel checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My whole panel informs: it explains a breakthrough clearly and accurately for a public audience, not a story or an argument. | A |
| 2 | My title and subtitle name the breakthrough and make a visitor curious. | B |
| 3 | My introduction states the topic and previews my sections. | B |
| 4 | I develop each section with well-chosen facts and concrete details from at least two named sources. | C |
| 5 | I define at least two technical words for my reader. | C |
| 6 | I include at least one short, exact quotation and name its source. | C |
| 7 | My graphic helps visitors understand, and its caption explains it and gives a credit line. | C |
| 8 | My sections group related ideas under clear headings. | D |
| 9 | Varied transitions link sentences, paragraphs and sections. | D |
| 10 | My conclusion follows from my sections and answers “So what?” | D |
| 11 | I use precise, subject-specific words, varied sentences and a formal, objective style. | E |
| 12 | Grammar, usage, capitals, punctuation and spelling are correct, and numbers and dates follow our style sheet. | F |
Constraints: 250 to 350 words in the introduction, sections and conclusion; caption 20 to 50 words. Every fact must come from a source you can name. Your gallery talk at Exhibit Night lasts about 60 seconds.
Part A: Reading check. Work alone. Use the passage and the note cards.
Parts B and C.
Part B (on-demand writing, about 15 minutes): Write an informative paragraph (120 to 180 words) for a STEM night visitor that explains how Pasteur turned his rabies vaccine from an idea into a treatment for people. Introduce the topic, use at least two facts from the passage and note card D, include one exact quotation with its source, use two varied transitions, keep a formal style and end with a so-what sentence.
Part C: Submit your final exhibit panel (title, subtitle, introduction, headed sections, graphic with caption and credit, Words to know box and conclusion) with your checklist marked and your revision log. Then give your 60-second gallery talk to your teacher with a timer.
Pasteur had his work checked by a commission. Today you had yours checked too.
Exit ticket: which part of the check felt strongest for you, and which skill do you want to keep practicing?
Pacing: warm-up and two readings 9 minutes, reminders 3, Part A 16, Part B 12 (finish in the next lesson if needed). Collect Part C at the end; schedule the timed gallery talks during Parts A and B or before Exhibit Night.
Source notes: copied from the Gutenberg file of the 1926 book, chapter V, the pages just before the Meister passage of 2.17. The cut removes two sentences describing how dogs were infected for the test (healthy dogs bitten by rabid ones, and an injection of material from rabid rabbits). De Kruif’s quotations of Pasteur’s thoughts are his telling. Pasteur’s claim that people get rabies only from dog bites is his 1880s statement in de Kruif’s telling; other animals, such as the wolf later in the chapter, also spread rabies.
Discussion note: the passage describes dogs that would die without treatment. Acknowledge students’ feelings, and note that modern animal research follows strict rules. Do not dwell on the cut details.
Coverage: Part A covers CC.1.2.8.A (Q1, Q10), B (Q2), C (Q3, Q9), E (Q4), F (Q5 allusion, Q6 word meaning, short response on figurative language and tone), G (Q7), I (Q8 fact, Q9 interpretation and certainty) and L (independent reading of a new passage). Part B and Part C are scored with the rubric below for CC.1.4.8.A-F.
Supports: read the passage aloud for students with reading accommodations (Part A then measures comprehension, not decoding). Allow typed responses and a word bank for Part B. Napoleonic and assassins are left out of the words to know on purpose, so Q5 and the short response test context and allusion; give the Napoleon hint (Q5 guidance) to all students.
Scoring Part A: Q1-Q10 are 1 point each (10 points). The short response is scored 0-3: 1 for an accurate meaning of the figure of speech, 1 for its effect on tone, 1 for an exactly quoted checkable fact. Total 13; 10 or more meets the standard.
Panel and Part B rubric. Score each row 4 (exceeds), 3 (meets), 2 (approaching) or 1 (beginning). Use rows 1-4 and 6 for Part B.
| Row | 4 | 3 | 2 | 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Informative purpose (CC.1.4.8.A) | Explains the breakthrough clearly and accurately for a public audience; every fact is sourced | Explains the topic clearly; facts are accurate | Some facts unclear or unsourced | Tells a story or opinion instead of informing |
| 2. Introduction (B) | Title, subtitle and introduction state the topic, hook the reader and preview every section in order | Topic is clear and sections are previewed | Topic clear but no preview | The reader cannot tell the topic |
| 3. Development and graphics (C) | Well-chosen facts from two or more sources, two definitions, an exact credited quotation and a graphic whose caption explains and credits it | Relevant facts, a definition, a quotation and a credited graphic | Few facts; quotation, definition or caption incomplete | Little or no evidence; no useful graphic |
| 4. Organization (D) | Logical categories under clear headings, varied transitions and a conclusion that follows and answers so what | Clear sections, some transitions, a fitting conclusion | Sections blur; ending stops suddenly | Hard to follow; no conclusion |
| 5. Style (E) | Precise, domain-specific words, purposeful sentence variety, objective tone and formal style | Mostly precise words; some variety; formal | Several vague or informal words; sentences sound alike | Vague or informal throughout |
| 6. Conventions (F) | Few or no errors; follows the style sheet | Minor errors that do not get in the way | Frequent errors | Errors make it hard to read |
A panel totaling 18-24 is ready for the exhibit. Below 18, confer and allow one more revision before display. The revision log and peer notes from 2.22 support row 3 and row 6 decisions; the timed gallery talk is noted for Exhibit Night (2.26).
Answer key: Q1 = A (index 0), Q2 = C (2), Q3 = D (3), Q4 = A (0), Q5 = B (1), Q6 = C (2), Q7 = A (0), Q8 = B (1), Q9 = C (2), Q10 = B (1). Sample short response: “The ‘unseen assassins’ are the rabies germs, too small to see, pictured as killers. The phrase makes the tone dramatic, like a thriller. A panel could use the commission’s finding instead: ‘nothing on earth can give him the disease.’” Sample Part B: “Louis Pasteur’s rabies vaccine began as a plan to vaccinate every dog in France. However, a veterinarian named Nocard pointed out that France had ‘more than two million, five hundred thousand dogs,’ each needing fourteen shots, according to Paul de Kruif’s 1926 book. Pasteur changed course. Because rabies takes weeks to reach the brain after a bite, he reasoned, bitten people could be treated in time. First, his team tested the idea on dogs, and a commission of French doctors confirmed the results. Then, on July 6, 1885, they gave the first injection to a human, nine-year-old Joseph Meister, who never showed signs of the disease. Pasteur’s story shows that a breakthrough needs more than a discovery: it needs a practical plan and careful checking.”
Project Gutenberg, Microbe Hunters by Paul de Kruif (Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1926), eBook #77842, chapter V · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
This passage comes from the same chapter of Paul de Kruif’s Microbe Hunters (1926) that you read in 2.17. It happens just before the Joseph Meister scene. Pasteur and his assistants, Roux and Chamberland, have made a weakened rabies vaccine from the spinal cords of infected rabbits. It takes fourteen doses, one each day, to protect a dog. Now Pasteur must decide how to use it.
De Kruif mixes facts with storytelling. He quotes Pasteur and a famous veterinarian, describes experiments on dogs and imagines Pasteur’s thoughts. Read it as you would read any popular science writer: enjoy the story, and check the facts. Keep our driving question in mind: what did Pasteur need besides a discovery?
Words to know: stupendous, amazingly large; veterinarian, an animal doctor; virulent, extremely harmful and quick to spread; commission, an official group chosen to check something; immune, protected from a disease.
At first Pasteur thought of shooting his weakened rabies virus into all the dogs of France in one stupendous Napoleonic series of injections: “We must remember that no human being is ever attacked with rabies except after being bitten by a rabid dog…. Now if we wipe it out of dogs with our vaccine …” he suggested to the famous veterinarian, Nocard, who laughed, and shook his head.
“There are more than a hundred thousand dogs and hounds and puppies in the city of Paris alone,” Nocard told him, “and more than two million, five hundred thousand dogs in all of France–and if each of these brutes had to get fourteen shots of your vaccine fourteen days in a row … where would you get the men? Where would you get the time? Where the devil would you get the rabbits? Where would you get sick spinal cord enough to make one-thousandth enough vaccine?”
Then finally there dawned on Pasteur a simple way out of his trouble: “It’s not the dogs we must give our fourteen doses of vaccine,” he pondered, “it’s the human beings that have been bitten by mad dogs….”
“How easy!… After a person has been bitten by a mad dog, it is always weeks before the disease develops in him…. The virus has to crawl all the way from the bite to the brain…. While that is going on we can shoot in our fourteen doses … and protect him!” and hurriedly Pasteur called Roux and Chamberland together, to try it on the dogs first.
[…]
Then they gave these beasts, certain to die if they were left alone–they shot the fourteen stronger and stronger doses of vaccine into them. It was an unheard-of triumph! For every one of these creatures lived–threw off perfectly, mysteriously, the attacks of their unseen assassins, and Pasteur–who had had a bitter experience with his anthrax inoculations–asked that all of his experiments be checked by a commission of the best medical men of France, and at the end of these severe experiments the commission announced:
“Once a dog is made immune with the gradually more virulent spinal cords of rabbits dead of rabies, nothing on earth can give him the disease.”
Source: Project Gutenberg, Microbe Hunters by Paul de Kruif (Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1926), eBook #77842, chapter V (gutenberg.pglaf.org)