develop each section of my panel with well-chosen facts, concrete details, definitions and an exact quotation, and tell checkable facts from a writer’s dramatized details.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Sort these three sentences into “checkable fact” or “writer’s feeling”: (1) The first rabies injection in a human was given in 1885. (2) Pasteur was the bravest man in France. (3) The boy received fourteen injections.
How confident are you that you can I can tell a checkable fact from a writer's opinion.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Development is the body of your panel. The standard asks you to develop your topic with “relevant, well-chosen facts, definitions, concrete details, quotations, or other information and examples.” Relevant means it supports your section’s point. Well-chosen means it is the strongest of the details you could use.
Five tools. A fact can be checked (a date, a number, a name). A concrete detail lets a visitor picture something (“fourteen injections”). A definition explains a technical word inside the sentence. A quotation gives someone’s exact words, in quotation marks, with the speaker or source named. An example shows a general idea in one case.
Fact or telling? Popular science writers often dramatize. De Kruif reports a date, a boy’s age, the number of injections and the names of two physicians. He also uses loaded words (“dreadful,” “pitifully”) and tells us what Pasteur felt inside. On a panel, use the facts and quote the drama only as the writer’s words: “Writer Paul de Kruif called rabies ‘that dreadful disease.’”
Figurative language. De Kruif compares Meister’s case to “that first dog that Roux had injected years before.” This comparison connects two events: an early test on an animal and the first test on a human, both of which ended Pasteur’s doubts. He also calls those doubts the “doubts of the artist,” suggesting Pasteur’s fears were feelings rather than scientific reasons.
Worked example 1: Jayden chooses details. Jayden’s section on early vaccines has room for two details from the passage. He lists five: the date, the boy’s age, “pitifully whimpering,” the fourteen injections and the outcome. He keeps the date and the outcome because they answer his section’s question, “Did the vaccine work on a person?” He drops “pitifully whimpering” because it is mood, not information.
Worked example 2: Grace builds a sentence with a definition and a quotation. Grace writes: “Rabies, a deadly disease spread by animal bites, terrified families in the 1800s. In 1885, a physician named Vulpian urged Pasteur to treat a bitten boy, saying, ‘if you do nothing it is almost sure that he will die,’ according to Paul de Kruif’s 1926 book.” Her definition sits right after the word, and her quotation is exact and credited.
Your turn. Each section of your panel needs at least two facts or concrete details from named sources; the whole panel needs two definitions and one quotation.
Use de Kruif’s passage under “The text.” Box the numbers and dates; wave-underline the dramatic words.
Build your evidence bank.
For each section of your panel, record two facts or concrete details. For each one, write the source (author, title, year) and mark it F (fact), D (detail), Def (definition) or Q (quotation).
Draft one full section (80 to 120 words) that uses at least two facts, one definition placed right after the word and one exact quotation with its source named in the sentence.
Visitors trust a panel that shows where its facts come from.
Exit ticket: copy your strongest fact. Why is it stronger than the other details you could have used?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 9, mini lecture 10, guided practice 11, drafting 6, closure 1.
Source notes: the passage is copied from the Gutenberg file of the 1926 book, chapter V; Gutenberg prints de Kruif’s dashes as double hyphens, and they are kept. De Kruif imagines inner thoughts and scenes; lessons treat them as his telling. “Weakened microbes of hydrophobia” is his 1926 wording; scientists now know rabies is caused by a virus. Earlier in the chapter the vaccine is tested on dogs and made from the spinal cords of rabbits.
Discussion note: the passage describes a child’s dog-bite wounds and the fear of death. Preview it, let students who are afraid of dogs or needles know what is coming and keep the focus on the decision the adults made. Acknowledge students’ feelings about the animal experiments in the chapter and note that modern research follows strict animal-care rules.
Warm-up key: (1) fact, (2) writer’s feeling, (3) fact.
Likely misconceptions: that a dramatic detail is a fact because it is in a nonfiction book; that a quotation can be paraphrased inside quotation marks; that more details always make a stronger section.
Supports: provide a three-column organizer (detail, fact or telling, use or skip). Stretch: write the same section twice, once dramatic and once objective, and explain which fits a panel.
Answer guide: strong choices for “The First Human Test”: the date July 6, 1885, and the outcome (“never a sign of that dreadful disease,” quoted as de Kruif’s words) or Vulpian’s quotation. Details to leave out: “pitifully whimpering” or “shouted to the world,” because they add mood, not information.
Project Gutenberg, Microbe Hunters by Paul de Kruif (Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1926), eBook #77842, chapter V · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
Paul de Kruif wrote Microbe Hunters (1926), a popular book about the scientists who discovered germs and fought diseases. This chapter is about the French scientist Louis Pasteur. Earlier in the chapter, Pasteur and his assistants, Roux and Chamberland, make a weakened rabies vaccine and protect dogs with fourteen doses given day after day. Rabies, also called hydrophobia, is a deadly disease spread by the bite of an infected animal. Pasteur is afraid to try the vaccine on a person.
De Kruif writes like a storyteller. He includes exact dates and quotations, but he also imagines feelings and uses dramatic words. As you read, sort the facts a museum could check from the details that are de Kruif’s telling.
Words to know: Alsace, a region in eastern France; gashed, cut deeply; festering, infected and oozing; inoculations, injections of a vaccine; hypodermic needle, a needle for giving shots under the skin.
At last, mercifully, the worried Mrs. Meister from Meissengott in Alsace took the dreadful decision out of Pasteur’s unsure hands. This woman came crying into the laboratory, leading her nine-year-old boy, Joseph, gashed in fourteen places two days before by a mad dog. He was a pitifully whimpering, scared boy–hardly able to walk.
“Save my little boy–Mr. Pasteur,” this woman begged him.
Pasteur told the woman to come back at five in the evening, and meanwhile he went to see the two physicians, Vulpian and Grancher–admirers who had been in his laboratory, who had seen the perfect way in which Pasteur could guard dogs from rabies after they had been terribly bitten. That evening they went with him to see the boy, and when Vulpian saw the angry festering wounds he urged Pasteur to start his inoculations: “Go ahead,” said Vulpian, “if you do nothing it is almost sure that he will die.”
And that night of July 6, 1885, they made the first injection of the weakened microbes of hydrophobia into a human being. Then, day after day, the boy Meister went without a hitch through his fourteen injections–which were only slight pricks of the hypodermic needle into his skin.
And the boy went home to Alsace and had never a sign of that dreadful disease.
Then all fears left Pasteur–it was very much like the case of that first dog that Roux had injected years before, against the master’s wishes. So it was now with human beings; once little Meister came through unhurt, Pasteur shouted to the world that he was prepared to guard the people of the world from hydrophobia. This one case had completely chased his fears, his doubts–those vivid but not very deep-lying doubts of the artist that was in Louis Pasteur.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Microbe Hunters by Paul de Kruif (Harcourt, Brace and Company, 1926), eBook #77842, chapter V (gutenberg.pglaf.org)