choose a Pittsburgh breakthrough for my exhibit panel, name my audience and big idea, and plan my panel using advice from National Park Service exhibit writers.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Picture the last sign you read at a museum, park, zoo or science center. Did you read every word, the title only, or something in between? Write one sentence about what made you stop, or what made you walk away.
National Park Service planners say an exhibit may have only a few seconds to grab a passing visitor’s attention. How many do you predict?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Writers, welcome to Build. In Part 1 you read like researchers. You traced central ideas, chose the strongest evidence and compared accounts of Jonas Salk’s polio vaccine and Samuel Langley’s work at the Allegheny Observatory. Now you become the experts. Each of you will write one panel for our exhibit, Pittsburgh Breakthroughs, for a STEM night or the public library. Real visitors will read your words, so every fact must be right.
Your task. An exhibit panel is informative writing: its job is to explain a topic clearly, not to tell a story or win an argument. Yours has a title and subtitle, an introduction that previews what follows, two or three short sections with headings (250 to 350 words in all), one graphic with a caption and credit line, a “Words to know” box and a conclusion that answers “So what?” At Exhibit Night you will also give a 60-second gallery talk.
Breakthrough bank. The polio vaccine developed at the University of Pittsburgh (Part 1); Langley’s sun studies and bolometer at the Allegheny Observatory (Part 1); Langley’s flying-machine experiments (Part 1); the University of Pittsburgh’s 1918 influenza laboratory (this part, 2.16, 2.18 and 2.21); Carnegie Mellon students’ Iris lunar rover (2.26). You may propose another Pittsburgh breakthrough if you can find two reliable sources and your teacher approves them.
Read our mentor panel. We wrote it for this unit from sources you will read in the next lessons. Look for its parts: title, introduction with a preview, headed sections, a graphic, a quotation, words to know and a so-what ending.
Mentor exhibit panel (written for our class)
Title: Five Weeks in the Lab
Subtitle: How Pittsburgh Scientists Fought the 1918 Flu
Introduction: In the fall of 1918, a deadly flu swept the world, and Pittsburgh’s doctors raced to understand it. This panel explains how the epidemic reached the city, how the University of Pittsburgh turned its medical school into an emergency laboratory, and what the researchers learned, including what they got wrong.
A City Under Attack. The epidemic reached Pittsburgh about the last week of September 1918. It was part of a pandemic, an outbreak that spreads around the world. The CDC estimates that about 500 million people, one-third of the world’s population, were infected, and that about 675,000 people died in the United States. In Pittsburgh, one 150-bed hospital was caring for more than 300 flu patients by its sixth day as an emergency hospital.
The Medical School Becomes a Lab. On October 5, 1918, the university’s School of Medicine began providing laboratories for the emergency military hospital. As the flu spread, the school closed and gave the hospital every laboratory that could help. For about five weeks, teams in pathology, bacteriology and physiology studied the disease. Meanwhile, at the Carnegie Steel Company, workers and their families received free test vaccines.
Learning from a Wrong Guess. Most of the Pittsburgh researchers thought a germ called B. influenzae caused the flu. Today the CDC reports that the 1918 pandemic was caused by an H1N1 virus. Even in 1919, bacteriologist W. L. Holman admitted that stronger evidence might reveal “another more probable living virus as the cause.”
Conclusion: A breakthrough is rarely one bright moment. The Pittsburgh team’s careful records, even their wrong guess, show how science moves forward: observe, test, write it down and share it.
Graphic and caption: Chart I, Carnegie Steel Company. The 1919 report counted flu cases among workers who received zero to four shots. University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Studies on Epidemic Influenza (1919)
Words to know: epidemic, a disease spreading quickly through a community; pandemic, an epidemic that spreads around the world; vaccine, a preparation given to build protection against a disease.
Worked example 1: Destiny chooses a breakthrough. Destiny lists three choices: the polio vaccine, the bolometer and the Iris rover. For each she asks, Do I have at least two sources, and will a visitor care? The bolometer is hard to picture and she has one source. The polio vaccine has the Eisenhower citation and the Fogarty speech from Part 1, and the church bells from our first lesson give her a hook. She chooses the vaccine.
Worked example 2: Mateo names his audience and big idea. Mateo writes, “Audience: families at STEM night, from fifth graders to grandparents. Big idea: At the Allegheny Observatory, Langley built an instrument sensitive enough to measure tiny amounts of the sun’s heat.” A big idea is one sentence that tells what every visitor should remember. The park planners say the title and the first sentence must catch a moving visitor and that a panel should make one point, so Mateo plans to put his big idea in his title and first sentence.
Our checklist. Visitors will judge our panels by these twelve points, and so will the unit check. We will build each skill in the lessons ahead.
| # | Panel checklist | Standard |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | My whole panel informs: it explains a breakthrough clearly and accurately for a public audience, not a story or an argument. | A |
| 2 | My title and subtitle name the breakthrough and make a visitor curious. | B |
| 3 | My introduction states the topic and previews my sections. | B |
| 4 | I develop each section with well-chosen facts and concrete details from at least two named sources. | C |
| 5 | I define at least two technical words for my reader. | C |
| 6 | I include at least one short, exact quotation and name its source. | C |
| 7 | My graphic helps visitors understand, and its caption explains it and gives a credit line. | C |
| 8 | My sections group related ideas under clear headings. | D |
| 9 | Varied transitions link sentences, paragraphs and sections. | D |
| 10 | My conclusion follows from my sections and answers “So what?” | D |
| 11 | I use precise, subject-specific words, varied sentences and a formal, objective style. | E |
| 12 | Grammar, usage, capitals, punctuation and spelling are correct, and numbers and dates follow our style sheet. | F |
Constraints: 250 to 350 words in the introduction, sections and conclusion; caption 20 to 50 words. Every fact must come from a source you can name. Your gallery talk at Exhibit Night lasts about 60 seconds.
Use the National Park Service passage under “The text.” Talk with a partner before you answer the open question.
Plan your exhibit panel.
Plan card: (1) my breakthrough, (2) my audience, (3) my big idea in one sentence, (4) three facts I already know and the source of each, (5) two questions I still need to answer and (6) one graphic I might use.
Medium check: a visitor could learn about your breakthrough from a printed panel, a website or a short video. Name one advantage of a printed exhibit panel and one disadvantage, and explain how your panel will make up for the disadvantage.
A visitor may give your panel only a few seconds before deciding to read. Plan for those seconds.
Exit ticket: write your big idea sentence. Underline the words that must appear in your title.
Pacing: warm-up and reading 9 minutes, mini lecture with the mentor panel 10, guided practice 11, plan card 8, closure 2.
Partner: confirm the STEM night or library display before promising students a public audience. The mentor panel’s facts come from the 1919 Pittsburgh report (preface and Haythorn’s chapter), the archived CDC page and Holman’s conclusion 5, all read later in this part; its conclusion is the writer’s own interpretation, labeled as such in 2.21.
Likely misconceptions: that a panel should hold everything the student knows (the park planners say one point); that informative writing tells a story with a plot; that a title is decoration rather than the most-read line; that “objective” means boring rather than fact-based.
Supports: steer students who need rich sources to the polio vaccine or the 1918 lab, which have the most material across the unit. Let students talk through the plan card first. Stretch: plan a two-breakthrough comparison panel. The passage is about outdoor waysides; point out that our indoor panel follows the same advice about titles, first sentences and one point. Source note: the passage is copied from the Harpers Ferry Center page “Wayside Planning” (last updated March 18, 2024). Its section “Wayside Exhibit Writing” is already read in ELA 5 and ELA 7, so this course reads other sections of the page. “Seduce” is used in its older sense, tempt or attract.
Answer guide: sample summary: “Park exhibit planners say few visitors come to read and most keep moving, so the title and first sentence must catch them and each panel should make one point. They advise treating a panel as one part of a mix of media, since long stories fit a publication better. They also plan each panel with an outline of its subject and purpose.” Medium check: a printed panel stays in front of the visitor and needs no device, but it cannot move or play sound; a strong graphic and a gallery talk make up for that.
National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: Wayside Planning · U.S. government work (National Park Service), public domain
Harpers Ferry Center is the National Park Service office whose writers, editors and designers help parks build exhibits and other materials for visitors. This page gives their advice for planning waysides, the outdoor panels that stand beside a trail or a view and explain what visitors are looking at.
The planners begin with a hard fact about the audience: few people come to a park to read, and they keep moving. So the title and the first sentence must catch them, and the panel should make one point. Notice three more pieces of advice in the passage. A panel is only one of several ways to tell a story. A plan for each panel starts with an outline of its subject and purpose. And a writer may have only seconds to spark interest.
Words to know: succinctly, briefly and clearly; illuminate, light up or explain; terrain, the land itself; immerse, become deeply involved in; seduce, here, tempt or attract; captive, unable to leave; jargon, special words only insiders know; component, one part of a whole; parcel, divide into parts; sequential, told in order, step by step; interpretive, explaining the meaning of a place or object.
Wayside Exhibit Text
Few people come to parks for the express purpose of reading. At its best, the text should succinctly illuminate the terrain and help people immerse themselves in the resource. The text is the springboard. Admittedly, some of the subject matter may be fiendishly complex. That is where succinct expression finds an enjoyable challenge. Outdoors, the exhibit audience is mobile. The wayside graphic must attract people’s attention; the title must be short and intriguing; the first sentence (most crucially the first sentence) must seduce the audience into wanting to know more. A wayside exhibit audience is the opposite of captive. Show them something predictable, academic, or jargon ridden, and they move on, having far better things to do. The best waysides make one point and one point only.
[…]
The Planning Process
[…] For any park area, wayside exhibits should be just one component of a mix of media. Sequential narrative or in-depth analysis of a subject can be covered better in a publication than on the limited area of a wayside exhibit panel. Parcel the park’s story according to each medium’s strengths.
[…] For each exhibit, provide an outline that identifies the subject, the interpretive purpose or intent, the panel’s orientation or view, and a detailed description of the precise location and any landscaping considerations.
[…]
Understand Visitor Experience
Visitors are out of their cars and on the move. […] If you have 3 seconds to grab a visitor’s attention, what will spark a connection to the site? Don’t expect anyone to read your carefully crafted text until they have some desire to read. There are some who will read every word you put before them, but aim for those visitors who are charging headlong through a park hoping to have a great time.
Source: National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: Wayside Planning (nps.gov)