analyze how a NASA profile connects and distinguishes Samuel Langley’s work at Pittsburgh’s Allegheny Observatory, his inventions and later NASA missions.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Something invented long ago still helps you today (the bicycle, the pencil, the radio). Pick one and write how the old idea connects to the thing you use.
A heat-measuring instrument invented in Pittsburgh in 1878 later flew on NASA missions. What do you predict it measured from space?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Connections and distinctions. Informational texts often show how people, ideas or events are connected (one leads to, causes or resembles another) and how they are distinguished (how they differ). Writers use comparisons, categories, cause and effect, and time order to do this.
Connecting words. Time: then, after 1887. Cause: backed by these experiments. Category: bolometers have been flown on numerous NASA missions puts Langley’s single invention into a whole class of instruments. Separation: in addition to his solar interests marks a second, different line of work.
Worked example 1: a cause-and-effect connection. Rosa traces a chain: “While at the Allegheny Observatory, he made important experiments on the lift and drag” → “Backed by these experiments, he was the first to offer a clear explanation of the way birds soar.” The phrase backed by shows the experiments made the explanation possible.
Worked example 2: a distinction. Ben notices the NASA Earth Observatory profile calls the sun Langley’s “chief scientific interest” and flight something “in addition.” He writes: “The text separates his main work, studying the sun, from a second passion, flight, but shows both began at the Allegheny Observatory.”
Across a century. The biggest connection jumps about a hundred years: a detector invented in 1878 became the ancestor of instruments on NASA missions that measure Earth’s energy balance. That is one answer to our driving question: some discoveries help millions slowly, as later scientists build on them.
A model paragraph. NASA connects Langley’s Pittsburgh years to modern science. It says that in 1878 “he invented the bolometer,” and then that “Bolometers have been flown on numerous NASA missions.” By placing these sentences close together, the profile shows one invention growing into a whole family of space instruments.
Circle connecting words. Box words that separate one idea from another.
Connection timeline and response.
Make a timeline of five events from the passage (with dates where given). Under each arrow, write the connecting word or phrase the text uses, or write “none” if the text only lists them in order.
Write 4-5 sentences: How does the NASA Earth Observatory profile show that a discovery made in Pittsburgh kept helping people long after? Use two quotations and name the kind of connection each shows (time, cause, category).
One life, many connections. Next we read Langley’s own words about the sun and study how technical and figurative language work together.
Exit ticket: what is one fact from today that belongs on a Pittsburgh Breakthroughs panel? Write it in one clear sentence.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, timeline and response 10.
Text note: copied from the NASA Science page (Earth Observatory feature). Cuts skip the description of the bolometer’s parts and a sentence on Langley’s honors. The page’s slips (“as an astronomy, physics”; “did not fair as well”) are outside today’s passage. The page’s phrase “man was destined to fly” is period-style wording for people.
Accuracy note: the text says bolometers (the instrument type) flew on NASA missions, not Langley’s own 1878 device. Watch for that overstatement.
Likely misconceptions: that listing events in order proves one caused the next; that the observatory was in Washington; that a radiation budget is about money.
Supports: a partly filled timeline (1867, 1878, 1887). Stretch: the passage puts the NASA missions between the bolometer and the flight paragraph; what does that order emphasize?
Answer guide: cause: experiments on lift and drag gave him the data to explain soaring and gliding. Response: invented the bolometer in 1878 while at Allegheny (time); “Bolometers have been flown on numerous NASA missions” (category) measuring Earth’s radiation budget; flight experiments at Allegheny led to explaining how birds soar (cause).
NASA Science, Earth Observatory: Samuel Pierpont Langley · U.S. government work, public domain
About the text. This short biography comes from NASA’s Earth Observatory, a NASA website about our planet. NASA has a research center named for Langley. The passage covers his career, his invention of the bolometer, and his flight experiments.
What to notice. Watch for words that connect events across time (then, after, backed by) and words that separate one kind of work from another (in addition to). The original has a small slip (“as an astronomy, physics…” elsewhere on the page); we copy the page’s words exactly.
Words to know. Radiation here means energy the sun sends out as light and heat. A radiant-heat detector senses that energy. Radiation budget is the balance between the energy Earth gets from the sun and the energy it gives off. Lift pushes a flying object up; drag holds it back. Appreciable means large enough to notice.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
Langley began his career as a civil engineer in Chicago, continuing later in St. Louis, before returning to Boston to accept an assistantship at the Harvard Observatory. Heading south once again, Langley later taught mathematics at the U.S. Naval Academy in Annapolis, Md. Then, from 1867-87, he served as professor of physics and astronomy as well as director of the Allegheny Observatory at the Western University of Pennsylvania (now known as the University of Pittsburgh). After 1887, Langley was appointed Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution in Washington D.C.
Langley’s chief scientific interest was the sun and its effect on the weather, and believed that all life and activity on the Earth were made possible by the sun’s radiation. In 1878 he invented the bolometer, a radiant-heat detector that is sensitive to differences in temperature of one hundred-thousandth of a degree Celsius (0.00001 C) . […]
Bolometers have been flown on numerous NASA missions including the Earth’s Radiation Budget Experiment (ERBE) and the Clouds and Earth’s Radiant Energy System (CERES), which provided accurate regional and global measurements of the components of the Earth’s radiation budget. […]
In addition to his solar interests, Langley was the only professional scientist of his day who believed that man was destined to fly. While at the Allegheny Observatory, he made important experiments on the lift and drag of an aircraft moving through the air at a measured speed. Backed by these experiments, he was the first to offer a clear explanation of the way birds soar and glide without appreciable wing movement.
Source: NASA Science, Earth Observatory: Samuel Pierpont Langley (science.nasa.gov)