write a concluding section that follows from my panel and tells visitors why the breakthrough matters, after comparing it with the numbered conclusions of a 1919 scientific report.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Think of the end of a good movie, game or book. What did the ending do that made it feel finished? Write one sentence.
A 1919 scientist lists his conclusions about flu vaccines. Will he say the vaccines clearly worked?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Endings with a job. The standard asks you to “provide a concluding statement or section” that follows from what you wrote. A conclusion does not add a brand-new topic. It pulls your sections together and leaves the visitor with the meaning.
Two kinds of conclusions. A scientific conclusion, like Haythorn’s, states exactly what the evidence supports, with careful hedges, for other experts. An exhibit conclusion answers the visitor’s question, “So what?” Why should someone at STEM night care about this breakthrough today?
Three so-what moves. (1) Connect to now: “Today, children in the United States still receive polio vaccine.” (2) Name the bigger lesson: “A breakthrough is rarely one bright moment.” (3) Return to the hook: if you began with church bells, end with what the bells meant. Each move must grow from facts in your sections.
Your own interpretation. A so-what sentence is often your own judgment, and that is allowed in an exhibit if it is reasonable and clearly based on your facts. Our mentor panel’s ending, “science moves forward: observe, test, write it down and share it,” is the writer’s interpretation of the Pittsburgh team’s story, not a quotation from a source.
Worked example 1: Lena summarizes before she concludes. To be sure her ending follows from her panel, Lena first writes an objective summary of her own draft in two sentences, with no opinions. Then she adds one so-what sentence: “Every summer without polio fear began in a Pittsburgh lab.” Her partner points out that it overstates (other labs and millions of volunteers helped), so she revises: “Summers without polio fear began with work in a Pittsburgh lab and the millions who joined the test.”
Worked example 2: Andre fixes a fizzle. Andre’s draft ends, “That is all about the Iris rover.” It stops but does not conclude. He returns to his hook, a student team building a robot: “A rover built by students carried a big idea: young people in Pittsburgh can help explore the Moon.”
Hedges are honest. If your evidence is uncertain, say so, as Haythorn does. “Probably” or “the evidence suggests” is better than a claim your sources do not support.
Use Haythorn’s conclusions under “The text.”
Draft your conclusion.
Write a two-sentence objective summary of your own panel draft. Then draft your conclusion (30 to 60 words) using at least one so-what move: connect to now, name the bigger lesson or return to your hook. Label the move.
Check your conclusion: does every claim follow from a fact in your sections? Add a hedge wherever your evidence is uncertain, and explain one change you made.
The last line is the one visitors carry out of the room.
Exit ticket: read your so-what sentence to a partner. Write the partner’s answer to “Would you care? Why?”
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 8, mini lecture 10, guided practice 11, drafting 7, closure 1.
Source notes: the passage is copied from the Gutenberg file. Cut conclusion 2 sets rules for judging mixed vaccines (vaccination before the epidemic or week-by-week comparisons); cut conclusion 4 is about the army pneumo-lipovaccine and pneumococci. “Data … is” is printed as is. Haythorn’s focus on the Pfeiffer bacillus reflects 1919 science; the CDC page in 2.23 reports that the 1918 pandemic was caused by an H1N1 virus.
Likely misconceptions: that a conclusion repeats the introduction word for word; that a hedge is weak writing; that a so-what sentence may claim anything (it must follow from the facts).
Supports: provide frames: “Today, ___ because of ___.” “The story of ___ shows that ___.” Stretch: rewrite Haythorn’s conclusion 3 in plain language for a visitor, keeping its hedges.
Answer guide: sample summary: “Haythorn concludes that no evidence shows vaccines made only from Pfeiffer bacilli protect against influenza, and that the data on mixed vaccines are inconclusive, though they may reduce secondary pneumonia. He also warns that resistance may drop briefly after a shot.” Sample so-what: “Even a failed vaccine taught scientists to measure carefully, which helped later vaccines succeed” (accept as the writer’s interpretation if the student labels it as such or hedges it).
Project Gutenberg, Studies on Epidemic Influenza by Members of the Faculty of the School of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh (1919), eBook #60822 · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
This is the end of Dr. Samuel Haythorn’s chapter in the 1919 University of Pittsburgh report, the same chapter whose introduction you read in 2.16 and whose chart you read in 2.18. Before these conclusions, he studied records of vaccines tried during the 1918 epidemic. Some were made only from one germ, the Pfeiffer bacillus, which many scientists then blamed for influenza. Others, called mixed vaccines, combined several kinds of germs.
Scientists end reports with careful, numbered conclusions that claim no more than the evidence shows. Notice how Haythorn hedges with words such as “as yet,” “inconclusive,” “probably” and “suggestive.” Two of his five conclusions are cut, marked […].
Words to know: immunity, protection from a disease; bacilli, rod-shaped bacteria (one is a bacillus); inconclusive, not leading to a firm answer; secondary pneumonias, lung infections that follow another illness; suggestive, hinting at something without proving it.
Conclusions
From our statistics we conclude that:
1. There is as yet no evidence that vaccines composed purely of strains of Pfeiffer bacilli will confer immunity to epidemic influenza.
[…]
3. Data obtained from experiments conducted under the above qualifications is inconclusive, but presents little evidence of the value of mixed vaccines in protecting against influenza. There is, however, an indication that mixed vaccines used prior to the arrival of the epidemic will lessen the number and the severity of secondary pneumonias, and will probably lower the death rate to a small degree.
[…]
5. While it is impossible to say that the large number of influenza cases developing almost immediately after vaccination would not have occurred anyway, it is at least suggestive that a temporary break occurs in the resistance after the inoculation, and that unusual care should be taken by persons who have been recently vaccinated, particularly when they are in the midst of an epidemic disease.
Source: Project Gutenberg, Studies on Epidemic Influenza by Members of the Faculty of the School of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh (1919), eBook #60822 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)