compare central ideas across the unit’s texts to answer the driving question, write an objective summary of a new passage, and show independent reading of grade 8 nonfiction in a reading check.
Phase 3: Make Sense
Do Now. Reread our Wonder Board. Pick one question we can now answer and one we still cannot. Write both.
A 1914 writer about aeroplanes and a 1965 speaker about polio: do you predict they reach a similar idea about breakthroughs?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Central ideas across texts. When several texts address the same big question, compare their central ideas: where do they agree, where do they differ, and what does each add? This is how we will build the main message of our exhibit.
Worked example 1: a connection. Hailey sets two sentences side by side. Zahm: the aeroplane “is the creation not of any one man, but rather of three generations of men.” Fogarty: “it was not the triumph of a few isolated men or even of a single group.” She writes: “Both argue that great breakthroughs are shared work, across people (Fogarty) and across time (Zahm).”
Worked example 2: a distinction. Carlos notices a difference. Fogarty uses the shared-credit idea to honor millions of ordinary people. Zahm uses it to rescue one man’s reputation: inventors “too poorly appreciated in their own day” later rise to “permanent honor,” and the next paragraph applies that to Langley. Same idea, different purposes.
Back to the driving question. What does it take to turn a discovery into something that helps millions? Our texts suggest: patient research (Langley’s “decade and a half,” his years at Allegheny), public support and money (Langley’s plea, the National Foundation, Congress), fair distribution (the priority system), testing and honesty about problems (the Michigan evaluation, the Cutter investigation), and time for others to build on the work (bolometers on NASA missions).
A model synthesis paragraph. Across our texts, a discovery helps millions only when many people carry it forward. Fogarty calls the polio victory “the triumph of millions,” and Zahm says the aeroplane is “the creation not of any one man.” The vaccine needed funders, testers and a fair plan to reach children; Langley’s bolometer reached space only through later NASA missions.
Reading check. Today’s quiz items check your independent reading of the unit’s texts. Read each question, go back to the text, and choose the answer the text supports.
Reading check: use today’s passage and the texts from earlier lessons.
Summary, synthesis and reading reflection.
Write an objective summary of Zahm's opening in 2-3 sentences. Checklist: author, title and date; central idea; how paragraph 2 applies it; no opinions.
Driving question response (6-8 sentences): What does it take to turn a discovery into something that helps millions? Use evidence from at least three of our texts, including one about polio and one about Langley. This becomes the big idea for your exhibit panel in Part 2.
Reading reflection: name your nonfiction book, the pages you read this unit, and one way its story answers the driving question.
We have read, compared and weighed our sources. In Part 2 we turn this evidence into exhibit panels for real visitors.
Exit ticket: write the single sentence you most want a visitor to remember from our exhibit.
Pacing (40 min): Wonder Board 4, reading 7, mini lesson 8, reading check 9, summary and synthesis 12.
Text note: copied from Project Gutenberg #44466, the first two paragraphs (the second is cut after its second sentence).
Reading check scoring (formative, 10 points): six quiz items, the true/false and the fill-in, 1 point each (8); objective summary 2 points (1 for the central idea, 1 for no opinions). Students below 6 meet in a small group to reread with the central-idea frame before Part 2.
Coverage: this part develops CC.1.2.8.A, B, C, E, F, G, I and L with formative checks; all are assessed again in Part 2’s unit check.
Likely misconceptions: that two texts with the same idea must have the same purpose; that a synthesis lists texts one at a time; that the driving question has one right answer.
Supports: a synthesis organizer with rows for each text and a column for “what it takes.” Stretch: Zahm says no one of his generation can “appraise correctly” inventions. Does that warn us about our own panels?
Sample summary: In his 1914 Smithsonian report, A. F. Zahm argues that the aeroplane was created not by one person but by three generations of inventors, and that some were overlooked in their time but honored later. He then applies this to Samuel Langley, who spent fifteen years building the science of flight. Driving question response: accept any well-supported answer; strong ones name research, funding, testing, fair distribution and later builders, each tied to a quotation.
A. F. Zahm, The First Man-Carrying Aeroplane Capable of Sustained Free Flight (Smithsonian Report for 1914; Government Printing Office, 1915), Project Gutenberg eBook #44466 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #44466
About the text. This is the opening of A. F. Zahm’s 1914 report for the Smithsonian Institution, the same report we read from in 2.11 and 2.13. Before describing Langley’s aeroplane, Zahm steps back to think about who really creates an invention.
What to notice. The first paragraph makes a general claim about the aeroplane and about how history treats inventors. The second applies it to Langley. Find the central idea and compare it with Fogarty’s “triumph of millions.” Zahm’s report argues for Langley, so read his general claim with that purpose in mind.
Words to know. To appraise is to judge the value of something. Fruition means coming to full development. Sagacious means wise. An exponent is a person who explains or supports an idea. Aeromechanics is the science of how air acts on moving objects. Obscurity is the state of being forgotten.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
It is doubtful whether any person of the present generation will be able to appraise correctly the contributions thus far made to the development of the practical flying machine. The aeroplane as it stands to-day is the creation not of any one man, but rather of three generations of men. It was the invention of the nineteenth century; it will be the fruition, if not the perfection, of the twentieth century. During the long decades succeeding the time of Sir George Cayley, builder of aerial gliders and sagacious exponent of the laws of flight, continuous progress has been made in every department of theoretical and practical aviation–progress in accumulating the data of aeromechanics, in discovering the principles of this science, in improving the instruments of aerotechnic research, in devising the organs and perfecting the structural details of the present-day dynamic flying machine. From time to time numerous aerial craftsmen have flourished in the world’s eye, only to pass presently into comparative obscurity, while others too neglected or too poorly appreciated in their own day subsequently have risen to high estimation and permanent honor in the minds of men.
Something of this latter fortune was fated to the late Secretary of the Smithsonian Institution. For a decade and a half Dr. Langley had toiled unremittingly to build up the basic science of mechanical flight, and finally to apply it to practical use.
Source: A. F. Zahm, The First Man-Carrying Aeroplane Capable of Sustained Free Flight (Smithsonian Report for 1914; Government Printing Office, 1915), Project Gutenberg eBook #44466 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)