analyze how Langley’s technical terms and figurative comparisons work together to shape meaning and an awed tone in his description of a sunspot.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Describe a thunderstorm in one sentence using only science words (pressure, charge, front). Then describe it with a comparison (“the sky cracked like…”). Which is more exact? Which is more memorable?
Langley studied sunspots through a telescope at Allegheny. What do you predict a sunspot looked like up close?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Three kinds of meaning. A technical meaning is the exact sense a word has in a field (penumbra in astronomy). A figurative meaning goes beyond the literal through comparison: similes, metaphors and analogies. A connotative meaning is the feeling a word carries. Skilled science writers use all three.
Analogy. An analogy explains something unfamiliar by comparing it to something familiar, point by point. Langley says a line in a sunspot bridge is “made up of smaller parts as a rope is made up of cords.” Readers know ropes; now they can picture a structure twelve thousand miles long.
Worked example 1: technical plus figurative. Grace notes that Langley first names the “umbral space” and the “penumbra,” then says the penumbra is “filled with detail of the strangest kind.” The technical words tell readers where to look; the description tells them how it feels to look.
Worked example 2: a comparison of scale. Omari studies “if we could indeed drop our great globe itself upon the sun, it would be dissipated as a snow-flake.” Earth, which feels enormous, becomes a snowflake meeting fire. The comparison shows the sun’s heat and size more powerfully than a temperature number could for most readers.
Tone. Exclamations (“See how full of intricate forms…!”) and words like vastness, immensity of a dream and web-like fineness create a tone of awe. Langley wants readers to feel the wonder he felt at the telescope, which supports his plea from the preface.
A model paragraph. Langley pairs a technical term with an analogy so readers can both name and picture what he saw. After pointing to the “bridges,” he says one is “made up of smaller parts as a rope is made up of cords,” and that the cords unravel into “threads fine as threads of silk.” The rope image makes a structure thousands of miles long feel close enough to touch.
Highlight technical words in one color and figurative comparisons in another.
Word-work chart and analysis.
Make a three-column chart: technical words (at least 3), figurative comparisons (at least 3), words that show feeling (at least 3). For each figurative comparison, write what is being compared to what.
Write 4-5 sentences: How do Langley's word choices shape the tone of the passage? Quote one technical term and one figurative comparison, and explain how they work together.
Exact words help readers find; comparisons help readers feel. Next we ask which medium shows the sun best: a photograph, a drawing or a description.
Exit ticket: write one sentence about polio or about Langley that uses a technical word and a comparison a visitor would understand.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, chart and analysis 9.
Text note: copied from Project Gutenberg #64577, Chapter I. Cuts skip the sentence on viewing for hours, the paragraph on umbra and nucleus, and the description of his 1870 drawing. British spellings (fibres, unravelled) and “snow-flake” are as in the file.
Safety reminder for students: Langley used special equipment. Never look at the sun directly or through binoculars or a telescope without certified solar filters.
Likely misconceptions: that figurative language does not belong in science writing; that “the whole surface is composed largely of metals turned into vapor” is a figure of speech (it is Langley’s 1880s scientific claim; today we know the sun is mostly hydrogen and helium, with metals present only in small amounts).
Supports: pre-teach umbra/penumbra with a simple diagram. Stretch: is “the vague immensity of a dream” a good comparison for a science book? Argue either way.
Answer guide: technical: polarized, apparatus, umbral, penumbra, bridges (as a term); figurative: immensity of a dream, dissipated as a snow-flake, rope and cords, threads of silk, web-like fineness; feeling: vastness, strangest, intricate, exclamations. Tone: awe and excitement; the technical terms anchor the wonder in real observation.
Samuel Pierpont Langley, The New Astronomy (Ticknor and Company, Boston, 1888), Project Gutenberg eBook #64577 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #64577
Where we are. In Chapter I, Langley explains how he studied sunspots at the Allegheny Observatory starting in 1870, projecting the sun’s image onto paper and then looking through a special eyepiece. He compares a photograph of a large spot with his own detailed drawing of it.
What to notice. Some words are technical: they name exact things scientists study. Other phrases are figurative: they compare the sun to everyday things. Mark each kind with a different color and watch how they work together.
Words to know. Polarized light has been filtered so its waves vibrate in one direction, which dims glare. Apparatus means equipment. Umbral refers to the umbra, the dark center of a sunspot; the penumbra is the lighter ring around it. Dissipated means scattered until it disappears. Sinuosities are curves and twists. Intricate means having many small, connected parts.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
This instrument, one of the first of its kind ever constructed, and in which the light is polarized with three successive reflections through the three tubes seen in the drawing (Fig. 14), was made in Pittsburgh as a part of the gift of apparatus by one of its citizens to the Observatory, and has been most useful. By its aid the eye can be safely placed where the concentrated heat would otherwise melt iron. […]
The photograph has transported us already so near the sun’s surface that we have seen details there invisible to the naked eye. We have seen that what we have called “spots” are indeed regions whose actual vastness surpasses the vague immensity of a dream, and it will not cause surprise that in them is a temperature which also surpasses greatly that of the hottest furnace. We shall see later, in fact, that the whole surface is composed largely of metals turned into vapor in this heat, and that if we could indeed drop our great globe itself upon the sun, it would be dissipated as a snow-flake. […]
See how full of intricate forms that void, black, umbral space in the photograph has become! The penumbra is filled with detail of the strangest kind, and there are two great “bridges,” as they are called, which are almost wholly invisible in the photograph. Notice the line in one of the bridges which follows its sinuosities through its whole length of twelve thousand miles, making us suspect that it is made up of smaller parts as a rope is made up of cords (as, in fact, it is); and look at the end, where the cords themselves are unravelled into threads fine as threads of silk, and these again resolved into finer fibres, till in more and more web-like fineness it passes beyond the reach of sight!
Source: Samuel Pierpont Langley, The New Astronomy (Ticknor and Company, Boston, 1888), Project Gutenberg eBook #64577 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)