edit my panel for grammar, usage, punctuation and spelling, use active and passive voice on purpose and follow a professional style guide for numbers and dates.
Phase 5: Prove It
Do Now. Find the errors: “In the 1950’s, Salks vaccine was tested on over 1 million children, it was a huge success.” List as many as you can.
How confident are you that you can I can find and fix errors in grammar, punctuation and style.
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Revising and editing are different jobs. Revising changes what you say and how you organize it (you did that in 2.22). Editing fixes how it is written: grammar, usage, capitals, punctuation and spelling. A visitor who spots an error starts to doubt your facts, so editing protects your credibility.
Our exhibit style sheet. From the Park Service entries you read: end captions with a period; use actual dates (the 1900s, not the 20th century); hyphenate a compound modifier before a noun (a 150-bed hospital) unless the first word ends in -ly; use fewer for things you count and less for amounts; write “percent” in text; add ’s to a singular noun (Salk’s vaccine) and only an apostrophe to a plural ending in s (the workers’ families). Class rules we add, from standard usage: spell out one through nine and use figures for 10 or more; spell out a number that begins a sentence; use commas in numbers over 999 but not in years; write decades with no apostrophe (the 1950s), since an apostrophe shows possession, not a plural; put a comma before and after the year in a full date (On April 12, 1955, the news came).
Active and passive voice. In the active voice, the subject does the action: “Salk’s team tested the vaccine.” In the passive voice, the subject receives it: “The vaccine was tested.” Active is usually clearer, and the park writers prefer it. Use passive on purpose when the doer is unknown or less important: “The observatory was built on a hill.” Do not shift voice in the middle of a sentence without a reason.
Mood. Verbs also have mood. The indicative states facts; the conditional (“would”) and the subjunctive (“If polio were still common…”) describe what is not real. A panel mostly uses the indicative, with the conditional or subjunctive for a so-what thought.
Verbals. A gerund is an -ing verb used as a noun (“Testing took a year”). A participle is a verb form used as an adjective (“the weakened virus”). An infinitive is to plus a verb (“to measure the sun’s heat”). Place participle phrases next to the word they describe, or you get a dangling modifier: “Walking into the lab, the microscope was…”
Worked example 1: Ava edits with the style sheet. Ava’s sentence: “In the 1950’s, 2 Pittsburgh scientists studied a 20th century disease.” She fixes three things: “the 1950s” (no apostrophe), “two” (spell out one through nine) and “a disease of the 1900s” (actual dates). If she kept “20th century” as a modifier, it would need a hyphen.
Worked example 2: Diego fixes a shift. Diego wrote: “Langley built the bolometer, and the sun’s heat was measured by it.” The sentence shifts from active to passive. His edit: “Langley built the bolometer and used it to measure the sun’s heat.” Now both verbs are active, and the infinitive to measure shows purpose.
Use the style guide passage and our class style sheet.
Editing passes on your own panel. Read once for each target.
Pass 1 (style sheet): circle every number and date in your panel and fix each one to match the style sheet. Pass 2 (voice): underline every passive verb; keep it only if the doer is unknown or less important. Record three edits with the rule for each.
Pass 3 (sentences and spelling): read your panel aloud from the last sentence to the first to catch run-ons, fragments, dangling modifiers and misspellings. Then trade with a partner for a final proofread, and copy your final word count.
Professionals edit because readers notice.
Exit ticket: what is the error you make most often, and how will you catch it next time?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading 7, mini lecture 10, guided practice 10, editing passes 9, closure 1.
Source notes: entries are copied from the HFC Editorial Style Guide (last updated August 19, 2026); cuts skip intervening entries and some examples. Entry heads are bolded here for readability, and the guide’s list of four reference books is shown as a list. ELA 5 and ELA 7 read the guide’s introduction and its dates, numbers, commas and dashes entries, so this lesson uses other entries; the date and number rules appear here only as class rules in the mini lecture. The straight and curly apostrophes in the possessive entry are as printed. Consistency matters most: the guide itself says to be consistent in a document.
Do Now key: “1950s” (no apostrophe); “Salk’s” (possessive); the comma splice after “children” (use a period or a semicolon); “huge” is informal and vague. “Over 1 million” is acceptable style; students must also check the number itself against a source before using it.
Likely misconceptions: that passive voice is always wrong; that an apostrophe makes a plural; that spell-check catches everything (it misses there/their and form/from).
Supports: give each student a one-page style sheet and an editing checklist with three passes. Let students edit in a color. Stretch: write one sentence with a gerund, one with a participle phrase and one with an infinitive, all about their breakthrough.
Answer guide: sample Do Now edit: “In the 1950s, Salk’s vaccine was tested on many children. The field trial was a major success.” Rules: no apostrophe in a plural decade (class style sheet); singular possessive takes ’s (style guide); fix the comma splice; precise, formal word choice.
National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: HFC Editorial Style Guide · U.S. government work (National Park Service), public domain
The writer-editors at the National Park Service’s Harpers Ferry Center keep an online style guide for anyone preparing park exhibits, signs and publications. A style guide is a set of rules a group of writers agrees to follow, so that all of their work is consistent and clear. It is organized like a dictionary, with entries in alphabetical order.
The passage begins with how the editors settle a style question: they check their own guide first, then three other well-known guides in order. Next they suggest that each office keep its own style sheet, which is what our class is making. Then come entries on captions, centuries, hyphens, fewer and less, percent and possessives, each followed by examples. Notice that the guide sometimes shows a correct and an incorrect form side by side, marked “not” or “but.”
Words to know: hierarchy, an order from first to last; consistent, the same every time; modify, to describe; quantity, an amount; bulk, a large mass that is not counted piece by piece; singular, one; plural, more than one; possessive, showing ownership, usually with an apostrophe.
How Decisions Are Made
When we have a question about editorial style or word usage, we follow this hierarchy:
- HFC Editorial Style Guide
- The Chicago Manual of Style
- Associated Press Stylebook
- GPO Style Manual
[…]
Your Own Editorial Style
We recommend you develop a style sheet for items specific to your park or office.
[…]
captions Captions end with a period, labels usually do not. Be consistent in a document.
Major Ferguson addresses his troops before the battle.
Pinelands tree frog
[…]
century Use actual dates—the 1500s not the 16th century.
[…]
compound words as modifiers Use a hyphen when combining two or more words to modify a noun, except when the first word ends in ly.
rust-resistant alloy but federally funded project
[…]
fewer, less In general use fewer for numbers or individual items that can be counted; less for quantity and bulk.
Fewer birds came to the feeder because Yuriko put out less food.
[…]
percent Spell out “percent” in text (one space between numeral and spelled-out word); use % symbol in scientific writing and in tables (no space between numeral and symbol).
Visitation to the hot springs increased this year by 25 percent.
[…]
possessive […] Singular nouns take ‘s (apostrophe and s).
the cat’s tail
Charles Dickens’s work
Plural nouns ending in s take only an apostrophe. Plural nouns not ending in s take ’s (apostrophe and s).
The employees’ entrance is on the left.
Source: National Park Service, Harpers Ferry Center: HFC Editorial Style Guide (nps.gov)