determine the central idea of a 1965 speech, trace how its paragraphs develop it, and write an objective summary.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Write one sentence that tells what happened in a movie or game you like, with no opinion words at all (no great, boring, best). Was it hard?
Ten years after the vaccine, a member of Congress wrote a speech about the polio victory. Whom do you predict he credited?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
How a central idea develops. Writers rarely state a central idea once and stop. They prepare for it, state it, and support it. In Fogarty’s opening, paragraphs 1 and 2 show how much the vaccine changed life, and paragraph 3 says who deserves the credit.
Objective summary. A summary retells the central idea and the most important supporting ideas in your own words, in order and briefly. Objective means it leaves out your opinions and the small details. Name the author, the title and the type of text in the first sentence.
Worked example 1: finding the central idea. Nora first picks “One seldom hears of polio today.” Then she notices the question “Who are the heroes of this great victory?” and its answer: “it was the triumph of millions.” The title says the same. She decides the central idea is that the polio victory belonged to millions of people, not a few.
Worked example 2: fixing a summary. Luis writes: “Fogarty gives an amazing speech about how polio was the worst disease ever, and I think Salk was the real hero.” He crosses out amazing, worst disease ever (the text does not say it) and his own opinion about Salk. His revision: “In a 1965 speech, Representative John Fogarty says polio cases fell from over 54,000 in 1952 to 121 in 1964 and argues that the victory was a triumph of millions of Americans.”
A model summary. In his 1965 speech “The Polio Vaccine–A Triumph of Millions,” Representative John E. Fogarty explains that polio, once feared every summer, had become almost forgotten ten years after the vaccine. He supports this with numbers: over 54,000 cases in 1952 and only 121 the year before his speech. He then argues that the victory belonged not to a few people but to millions, from scientists to ordinary donors.
Check your summary. Could someone who never read the speech learn its main point? Did you keep your opinion out? Did you stay under about 60 words?
Annotate: CI beside the central idea, S beside supporting details.
Write an objective summary.
Write an objective summary of Fogarty's opening in 3-4 sentences (about 60 words). Checklist: (1) author, title and type of text in sentence 1, (2) the central idea, (3) two key supporting ideas in order, (4) no opinions, (5) your own words except for short exact quotations.
Reading log: add today's pages from your nonfiction book. Write its central idea so far in one sentence.
Fogarty credits millions. Next we read what President Eisenhower said to Dr. Salk in 1955 and choose the strongest evidence for what it means.
Exit ticket: Fogarty lists many groups. Which group on his list surprised you most, and why?
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 4, reading 9, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, summary 9.
Text note: transcribed from the four-page scan on the NLM record (the page’s OCR text is full of errors, e.g. “polto”) and checked word by word. The date 4/13/65 is handwritten on page 1, so “last year” is 1964 and “this year” is 1965. The NLM record does not say whether or where the speech was delivered; call it a speech prepared for the House.
Language note: “this great crippler” and “victims” are 1960s phrasing. Discuss how word choice shapes how we see people; today we would say people who had polio, or polio survivors.
Likely misconceptions: that the first sentence is always the central idea; that a summary includes every number; that quoting a lot makes a summary objective.
Supports: summary frame “In ___, ___ explains that ___. He supports this with ___. He concludes that ___.” Stretch: what is the purpose of opening paragraph 3 with a question?
Sample summary: see the model in the mini lesson. Guided open question: the fear of every spring shows how big the change was, so listeners are ready to ask who made it happen.
John E. Fogarty, The Polio Vaccine–A Triumph of Millions (typescript speech, 1965), National Library of Medicine Digital Collections · Public domain (the National Library of Medicine states it believes this item is in the public domain); speech by a U.S. Representative
About the text. John E. Fogarty was a U.S. Representative from Rhode Island who worked for many years to fund medical research. This typed speech is dated April 13, 1965, ten years after the vaccine was released. “Mr. Speaker” is how members address the House of Representatives. The National Library of Medicine keeps a scan of the original pages.
What to notice. Paragraph 1 describes life before and after. Paragraph 2 gives numbers. Paragraph 3 asks a question and answers it. Find the sentence that states the central idea and notice how the first two paragraphs build toward it.
Words to know. A decade is ten years. Apprehension is worried fear about the future. Stricken means struck by a disease. Triumph means a great victory. Isolated means alone, cut off from others.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
THE POLIO VACCINE — A TRIUMPH OF MILLIONS
Mr. Speaker, it is now a full decade since the first polio vaccine was made generally available to the American people. The word polio, which only a few years ago brought dread to parents and young people around the world, is today, thankfully, an almost forgotten word. When at one time in our recent history, the first warm winds of the spring brought with them a cold apprehension and fear of the dangerous summer months ahead, today’s children can freely swim and play, confident in the protection assured them by the polio vaccine.
One seldom hears of polio today. But it is not difficult for us to remember just how much a part of our daily lives this great crippler was–not merely to those of us whose loved ones and friends were stricken or who were themselves victims–but to all of the rest of us as well, who knew polio’s effects and silently wondered if we or our families would be next. Just thirteen years ago, in 1952, there were over 54,000 cases of polio in the United States; last year, only 121 cases were reported. After three months of this year, only six cases are on record.
Who are the heroes of this great victory? There are many names we can single out in the fight against polio–a fight which did not begin nor end with the discovery of an effective vaccine–but in reality it was not the triumph of a few isolated men or even of a single group. Rather it was the triumph of millions–scientists, physicians, administrators, public health and other public officials, volunteer health agencies, fund raisers, those in advertising and public relations–and of all the countless other Americans who donated time and money to the research effort.
Source: John E. Fogarty, The Polio Vaccine–A Triumph of Millions (typescript speech, 1965), National Library of Medicine Digital Collections (collections.nlm.nih.gov)