analyze how a scientist’s allusion and connotative words shape the meaning and tone of his plea for support, and explain the distinction he draws between two kinds of astronomy.
Phase 2: Investigate
Do Now. Two signs ask for help for the same school club. Sign 1: “The club needs money.” Sign 2: “Our club is the forgotten little sister of the school, talented but penniless.” Which would make you give, and which words did the work?
In 1888 the director of Pittsburgh's Allegheny Observatory wrote a book for the public. Why would a scientist write for ordinary readers?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Words carry feelings. A word’s denotation is its dictionary meaning. Its connotation is the feeling it carries. Unfunded and portionless both mean “without money,” but portionless calls up a young woman with no inheritance, which feels sad and unfair. Word choices like these create tone, the writer’s attitude toward the subject.
Allusion. An allusion is a short reference to a famous story, person or text that the writer expects readers to know. Langley alludes to Urania, the Muse of astronomy, and imagines her as once “a poor Chaldean shepherdess” who is now rich. Her “younger sister” is the new science he wants funded.
Worked example 1: decoding the allusion. Zainab asks what the sisters stand for. Urania began poor (ancient star-watchers) and is now “well-to-do”: that matches “the Old” astronomy, which he says is “relatively munificently endowed.” The younger sister is “unendowed”: that matches “the New,” which “struggles almost unaided.” The story repeats paragraph 2 in a form readers can feel.
Worked example 2: connotation and tone. Jamal lists the words for the New Astronomy: “fruitful,” “bearing every mark of her celestial birth,” “unendowed and portionless.” The first two are admiring; the last two are pitying. Together they make a tone of gentle, respectful pleading: she deserves support and does not have it.
Connections and distinctions. Langley also draws a distinction, a clear difference, between two kinds of astronomy based on who pays for them. The old kind measured where stars and planets are; his new kind studied what the sun and stars are made of and how their energy reaches us. The preface does not explain all that; the book does.
A model paragraph. Langley’s allusion to Urania turns a complaint about money into a story of family unfairness. By calling the New Astronomy her “younger sister… all unendowed and portionless,” he makes readers feel that a deserving young science has been left out, which makes his request for support harder to refuse.
Underline words that carry feeling. Circle the allusion.
Word-choice analysis.
Rewrite paragraph 3 in plain, neutral words (for example, “New research gets little money.”). Then explain in 3-4 sentences what Langley's allusion adds that your plain version loses. Quote two words or phrases.
Connect: the polio vaccine work was helped by donations to the National Foundation for Infantile Paralysis. How is Langley's plea like a request for donations? Use one phrase from the preface.
A small story can carry a big request. Next we return to the polio vaccine and study how one paragraph builds an idea sentence by sentence.
Exit ticket: write one sentence for our exhibit that uses a word with a strong connotation on purpose. Name the feeling you want.
Pacing (40 min): Do Now 5, reading 8, mini lesson 9, guided practice 9, analysis 9.
Text note: copied from Project Gutenberg #64577 (Ticknor and Company, Boston, 1888; chapters first printed in The Century magazine, copyright 1884-1887). Curly quotation marks are as in the file. Allegheny City was a separate city until it was annexed by Pittsburgh in 1907; the observatory is now part of the University of Pittsburgh.
Background (from the book, not the preface): Langley’s “New Astronomy” is what we now call astrophysics, the study of what the sun and stars are and how their energy reaches Earth. Keep students’ claims about it to what the preface says: it is fruitful and poorly funded.
Likely misconceptions: that Urania’s sister is a real person; that connotation means the same as definition; that a plea must sound desperate (Langley’s is gentle and witty).
Supports: a two-column chart, Old Astronomy / New Astronomy, with the words used for each. Stretch: why would an allusion to Greek myth suit readers of an 1880s magazine?
Answer guide: the allusion adds feeling and a sense of unfairness (“younger sister,” “portionless”) and admiration (“bearing every mark of her celestial birth”). Connection: both ask ordinary people to pay for research that experts cannot fund alone; the phrase “on whose support he is so often dependent.”
Samuel Pierpont Langley, The New Astronomy (Ticknor and Company, Boston, 1888), Project Gutenberg eBook #64577 · Public domain in the U.S. (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg eBook #64577
About the text. Samuel Pierpont Langley directed the Allegheny Observatory in Allegheny City, now part of Pittsburgh, from 1867 to 1887. His title page calls him “Director of the Allegheny Observatory.” The New Astronomy (1888) gathers magazine articles he wrote to explain sun science to the public.
What to notice. The preface has three short paragraphs. The first names his audience. The second compares “the Old” and “the New” astronomy. The third turns that comparison into a little story about two sisters. Ask why he tells it that way.
Words to know. A benefaction is a gift of money for a good cause. Munificently endowed means given money very generously. Urania is the Muse of astronomy in Greek mythology. The Chaldeans were an ancient people of Mesopotamia famous for watching the stars. Celestial means heavenly. Portionless means having no inheritance or money of one’s own.
Read the passage under “The text” once for the big idea and once with a pencil.
PREFACE.
I have written these pages, not for the professional reader, but with the hope of reaching a part of that educated public on whose support he is so often dependent for the means of extending the boundaries of knowledge.
It is not generally understood that among us not only the support of the Government, but with scarcely an exception every new private benefaction, is devoted to “the Old” Astronomy, which is relatively munificently endowed already; while that which I have here called “the New,” so fruitful in results of interest and importance, struggles almost unaided.
We are all glad to know that Urania, who was in the beginning but a poor Chaldean shepherdess, has long since become well-to-do, and dwells now in state. It is far less known than it should be that she has a younger sister now among us, bearing every mark of her celestial birth, but all unendowed and portionless. It is for the reader’s interest in the latter that this book is a plea.
Source: Samuel Pierpont Langley, The New Astronomy (Ticknor and Company, Boston, 1888), Project Gutenberg eBook #64577 (gutenberg.pglaf.org)