write dialogue that reveals what my characters want or fear and pushes the action forward, punctuated correctly, using “The Signal-Man” as a model.
Phase 4: Build
Do Now. Read this exchange: “Hi.” “Hi.” “How are you?” “Fine.” Now read this one: “Did you hear that?” “Hear what?” “Exactly. The dog stopped barking.” Which exchange moves a story forward? Why?
What makes the second exchange stronger story dialogue?
The reading opens over the lesson; close it to come back to exactly where you were.
Dialogue is action. In a suspense story, characters should rarely chat. Each line should do at least one job: reveal what a character wants, fears or hides; propel the action by causing the next event; or provoke a decision. If a line does none of these, cut it.
How Dickens does it. The narrator’s compliment, “You almost make me think that I have met with a contented man,” is bait; he admits he “said it to lead him on.” It works. The man answers, “I am troubled, sir, I am troubled,” and that one line provokes a decision: the narrator promises, “I will come at eleven.” Then the strange order “don’t call out!”, repeated three times, reveals a fear we do not yet understand.
Questions pull readers forward. Look at the last lines. They are almost all questions: “For no other reason?” “What other reason could I possibly have?” Each question raises the tension until the narrator’s flat “No.” leaves us, and him, with a chill. Short lines speed up the pace.
Punctuating dialogue. Put the exact spoken words inside quotation marks. Start a new paragraph each time the speaker changes. Put commas and periods inside the closing quotation mark: “I’ll show my white light, sir,” he said. When a tag interrupts a sentence, use commas on both sides and no new capital. A dash at the end shows speech that is cut off: “I cried something to that effect—”
Worked example 1: Imani cuts small talk. Imani’s draft has her two characters greet each other for six lines before anything happens. She keeps one line and adds a reveal: “‘You’re late,’ Kai said, not looking up. ‘Your mom called here twice. She sounded scared.’” Now the dialogue reveals a worry and propels the plot: Imani’s narrator must find out why.
Worked example 2: Ethan adds a beat. A beat is a small action between lines that shows feeling. Ethan writes: “‘It was just the wind,’ Dad said. He checked the window lock anyway.” The beat contradicts the words, so the reader learns Dad is more nervous than he admits, just as the signal-man’s “peculiar low voice” shows his unease.
Use the passage under “The text.” Then practice with a partner.
Add dialogue to your anthology draft.
Write a dialogue scene of 8-14 lines for your story. At least one line must reveal a fear or secret, one must provoke a decision, and one must include a beat. Punctuate every line correctly and start a new paragraph for each speaker.
Label three of your lines R (reveals), P (propels) or D (provokes a decision) and explain each label in one sentence.
Your audio-drama listeners will meet your characters almost entirely through what they say. Make every line count.
Exit ticket: copy your strongest line of dialogue. What does it reveal, and what does it make happen next?
Pacing: warm-up 3 minutes, reading (two-voice read-aloud) 8, mini lecture 8, guided practice 12, drafting 7, closure 2. Confirm audio-drama teams today.
Likely misconceptions: that more dialogue is always better; that every tag must be a fancy verb (“said” is usually best); that a new speaker can continue in the same paragraph.
Supports: provide a dialogue punctuation card with three patterns (tag after, tag before, interrupted). Let students practice by re-punctuating an unpunctuated copy of six lines from the scene. Note that Dickens sometimes reports speech without quotation marks elsewhere in the story; students should use full quotation marks for spoken words. Listen to the partner discussion for CC.1.5.8.A.
Answer guide: sample discussion answer: “I first felt the shout matters at ‘Those were the very words. I know them well.’ My partner chose ‘don’t call out!’ I agree that line is strange, and I also think the ‘very words’ line suggests the signal-man has heard them before from someone else.” Sample label: “‘Your mom called here twice’ (P) – it sends the narrator home to find out why.”
Project Gutenberg, Three Ghost Stories by Charles Dickens (1894 Chapman and Hall text), eBook #1289, "The Signal-Man" · Public domain in the United States (published before 1931); Project Gutenberg text
This scene comes later on the narrator’s first evening with the signal-man. The narrator has climbed down into the cutting and visited the man’s small hut, or box, which holds a fire, a logbook, a telegraph and a little bell. The signal-man seems careful and exact at his work. Yet twice, the narrator noticed, he turned toward the little bell when it did not ring and looked out at the red light near the tunnel.
Now the narrator is leaving. Watch how one sentence the man “would have recalled” if he could changes the whole visit, and notice what the man keeps asking about the narrator’s very first shout.
Words to know: contented means satisfied and at peace; rejoined means answered; recalled the words means taken them back; impart means to tell or explain; expressly means definitely, on purpose; conveyed means carried or sent; supernatural means beyond the natural world.
As you read, mark each line that reveals a feeling and each line that pushes someone to act.
Said I, when I rose to leave him, “You almost make me think that I have met with a contented man.”
(I am afraid I must acknowledge that I said it to lead him on.)
“I believe I used to be so,” he rejoined, in the low voice in which he had first spoken; “but I am troubled, sir, I am troubled.”
He would have recalled the words if he could. He had said them, however, and I took them up quickly.
“With what? What is your trouble?”
“It is very difficult to impart, sir. It is very, very difficult to speak of. If ever you make me another visit, I will try to tell you.”
“But I expressly intend to make you another visit. Say, when shall it be?”
“I go off early in the morning, and I shall be on again at ten to-morrow night, sir.”
“I will come at eleven.”
He thanked me, and went out at the door with me. “I’ll show my white light, sir,” he said, in his peculiar low voice, “till you have found the way up. When you have found it, don’t call out! And when you are at the top, don’t call out!”
His manner seemed to make the place strike colder to me, but I said no more than, “Very well.”
“And when you come down to-morrow night, don’t call out! Let me ask you a parting question. What made you cry, ‘Halloa! Below there!’ to-night?”
“Heaven knows,” said I. “I cried something to that effect—”
“Not to that effect, sir. Those were the very words. I know them well.”
“Admit those were the very words. I said them, no doubt, because I saw you below.”
“For no other reason?”
“What other reason could I possibly have?”
“You had no feeling that they were conveyed to you in any supernatural way?”
“No.”
Source: Project Gutenberg, Three Ghost Stories by Charles Dickens (1894 Chapman and Hall text), eBook #1289, "The Signal-Man" (gutenberg.pglaf.org)